News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by PaulAJ on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @12:35PM (#21929163)
Any prediction of decentralisation of the Internet, or anything built on it, needs to explain how this will overcome the economies of scale (1 big data centre is cheaper than 1000 little ones) and the network effects (everyone buys and sells through Amazon because thats where you find the most buyers and sellers).
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by FreeHugs on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @12:51PM (#21929295)

    1 big data centre is cheaper
    than 1000 little ones
There are billions of computers out there that are idle most of the time. Utilizing them might very well be cheaper then building and maintaining a new datacenter.

    everyone buys and sells through
    Amazon because thats where you
    find the most buyers and sellers
Not everyone. Not even the majority. Even in the USA which is Amazons biggest market, their market share is less then 50%. Individual onlineshops are also moving billions. Even the small ones built with Shopify are moving billions when you combine their revenue. And then there is Ebay, Facebook Marketplace, Alibaba, Rakuten, Zalando ... all moving billions worth of goods.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by ohazi on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:31PM (#21929966)
> There are billions of computers out there that are idle most of the time.

They will remain idle unltil untethered energy and bandwidth become free.

I won't let you use my phone's spare cycles and murder my battery while we're still using lipo cells that degrade after 2 years with regular use.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by hanniabu on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:25PM (#21930360)
> They will remain idle unltil untethered energy and bandwidth become free

unless you tie it to an incentive, and thus you arrive at cryptocurrencies

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by stickfigure on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:05PM (#21930635)
Funny you mention that, since we've seen cryptocurrency processing concentrated in big data centers... for all the same reasons everything else is located in big data centers - energy and bandwidth are cheaper.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by hanniabu on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:41PM (#21931239)
That's up to whoever is supplying the services. While many may be outsourcing this to data centers, I'm sure it's not the case for everyone and there are people operating their own hardware.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by cesarb on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:33PM (#21931202)
> There are billions of computers out there that are idle most of the time. Utilizing them

That used to be popular (for instance, distributed.net) back when the processors used the same power whether they were idle or not. Nowadays, there is a huge difference in power usage and heat output between an idle or mostly idle processor, and a fully loaded one.

(My first desktop had a processor without a fan or even a heat spreader, and came with an operating system which had a busy loop as its idle loop.)

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by redisman on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:14AM (#21933198)
And most of these computers are running on batteries. Even on my desktop I'd have to get a decent return to share my CPU/GPU/storage. The computer cost me about $700 to build so I certainly wouldn't share it for pennies.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by ineedasername on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:42PM (#21930050)
Re: unused computers: I don't see technology on the horizon that would tackle usage of unused systems in any way that could compete with the low-friction of something like AWS. I'm not saying it's impossible, only that it doesn't seem like a problem that is getting much attention.

Re: Amazon: Most of the other venues you mention are secondary markets for the exact same sellers. People have their own Shopify, Etsy, Ebay, etc., storefront but then also sell on Amazon because that's where so much of the market is. As far as I can tell it's an increasing trend in that direction.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by bhauer on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:41PM (#21930038)
The gradual return of symmetric connectivity, which is underway today, as well as edge adoption of IPv6, could/should usher in a revitalized era of peer-to-peer and other decentralized computing models.

Peer-to-peer models last thrived when connectivity was predominantly symmetric (e.g., the early days of DSL) and faded quickly as asymmetric connectivity became mainstream. I think the decline of decentralization and the rise of asymmetric connectivity are intertwined; neither necessarily caused the other, but they are correlated. One could argue asymmetric connectivity became popular because users only wanted to consume rather than share/serve. But similarly, people stopped sharing and serving because their connectivity discouraged that use case.

Today, symmetric connectivity is returning, such as in the form of 1G/1G fiber connections to the home. Combine this with infinite static IP addresses, and ever rising edge compute capacity, and I think decentralization is inevitable. I won't predict the magnitude, but as a fan of decentralization, I personally hope it is at least significant.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by ken on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:55PM (#21930141)
I assumed that was covered by #8 ("The biggest consumer technology successes of this decade will be in the area of privacy"), somewhat by #9 ("Millennials and Gen-Z will be running many institutions"), and mostly the second half of #5 ("a killer decentralized consumer app").

Network effects of centralization explain why current big companies prefer to build centralized services -- but the next big idea never comes from existing big companies, anyway.

My 30,000' view of computing history is that big companies, as a rule, don't create big ideas that survive. They pick up small ideas that work and scale them up (Gall's Law). Git and HTTP and Python didn't come from Microsoft or Google or Amazon, but those companies took them once they were already popular and made them scale -- in large part by making them work well in a centralized architecture.

The software that comes next won't win because FAANG like it better for building centralized architectures. It'll win because everybody and their dog will be using it at home. Then companies like FAANG will see that and pick it up and try to centralize it. Then the cycle will repeat.

We've already got a billion tiny data centers -- the powerful computers and smartphones in our houses and pockets. All we need is the right software, and the desire to not have every service delivered free-with-ads-over-the-web from big corporations.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by amelius on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:42PM (#21930485)
> We've already got a billion tiny data centers -- the powerful computers and smartphones in our houses and pockets.

With asymmetric up/download speeds.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by rishirishi on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:23PM (#21930339)
> All we need is the right software

Who authors and maintains this software? And what is their incentive?

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by redisman on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:18AM (#21933205)
A cloud infrastructure startup I'd imagine?
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by esotericn on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:22PM (#21929913)
Network effects are important, granted.

Regarding economies of scale - it's all so cheap that it doesn't matter for most cases that don't involve utterly tremendous amounts of resource usage.

I mean, the primary thing holding this back is consumer level ISP's being arsey about servers. A 10 year old machine hooked up to my 35mbit home connection is more than enough to run most internet services.

And that's effectively free because I already have it.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by maxerickson on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:11PM (#21930670)
It's $X per month though right, because of the electricity? I'm thinking about setting up an always on computer and I definitely will make sure to compare up front costs and operating costs if I do it.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by esotericn on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @04:14PM (#21930692)
I guess that having had a computer since age 10 or so I just considered it a fairly standard thing for nerds to do.

Yes, strictly. A 20W average laptop would cost approx 3-4GBP per month to leave on all the time in the UK, a modest desktop perhaps 10-15GBP.

It's been a measurement error in my power budget as far back as I can remember. Sure, you can go and compare it to EC2 or whatever if you like, but that's just silliness. It's a big mac meal.

My Threadripper box with a shitton of HDD's and RAM etc moves the needle because it has high idle consumption. I'll probably be getting rid of that soon; but it's still a low cost relative to purchase price.

Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by rishirishi on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:20PM (#21930316)
How does the layperson know how to set up a node? And, care to.
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by rishirishi on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @01:04PM (#21929399)
This. And who will constitute these 1000's of decentralized nodes?
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by dclowd9901 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @02:31PM (#21929965)
Free remote data storage + cell phone mesh network?
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by rishirishi on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:24PM (#21930351)
Who pays for the "free remote data storage"? And who writes the software for the cell phone mesh network?
Re:What Will Happen in the 2020s by hanniabu on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @03:26PM (#21930371)
The people operating them if you have the proper incentives in place such as is done with cryptocurrencies. They pay the upfront operational cost and then are paid for usage by those using the network.