Now perhaps you could say that it's unethical because if he hadn't downloaded this album, he would've paid for someone else's, so he's not stealing from the creator of this album, but indirectly from the creators of other albums that he didn't buy instead. But that seems like an argument that proves too much; in that scenario, is it also unethical to listen to CC-licensed music, because doing so steals business from non-CC-licensed music?
Maybe they've done A/B testing on the way to release content to maximize their profit or some other good that they value and think that revealing the results to you would affect the outcome.
But if the work isn't being published (or isn't being published to a particular audience), then that side of the social contract isn't being upheld, so the purpose of copyright (to encourage such material to be produced and made available) isn't being fulfilled, and therefore I don't see copyright as ethically applicable (or ethically applicable to that audience).
I guess a shorter version of the obligation I feel users of a work have is: Compensate the creator, if they'll take your money.
If you and the musician are face-to-face and she says you can have an MP3 of her music for $1000, it's not right to take it if you think it's too expensive.
But I think the proper way to analyze ethical issues involving creative works is, therefore, to see who is upholding or violating the social contract that we call "copyright". I don't think there's any separate moral issue, and it certainly isn't a form of property (due to being non-rivalrous).
I and a musician are face-to-face, and she says I'm not allowed to listen to this particular waveform unless I hand her $1000. It's not right for her to claim monopoly over this non-rivalrous good because she feels like she owns it.
Anyway, is my understanding correct that if the artist was selling $1000 tokens to acquire her MP3 and you thought that was excessive, then you would take the token and leave whatever compensation you thought was appropriate?
She made an incorrect assumption. We don't work on the labor theory of value; things are only worth what you can sell them for.
> then you would take the token and leave whatever compensation you thought was appropriate?
It depends. I'd probably take the token and then get around to compensating her someday. If it was somebody I knew, I'd probably give it to them upfront, but if it was an unknown, I'd just end up buying a ticket to their next show and handing them some money at it. (Yes, I have done this before.)
Sure, I suppose he could just move on with his life, but it's an album he really wanted and even offered to pay for it. Changes in how the record industry operates need to happen, not peoples priorities.
My only point: pirating is not a valid form of protest, because it is actually about you satisfying your wants.
"Pirating" music is as much an act of protest as it does satisfy. In fact, it doubles the enjoyment whilst filesharing is considered illegal, and triples it when you tell the world about it. It's practically free joy for the price of naught, and contributes to world peace.
How does the second follow from the first?
I'm reluctant to pay for music when I know that a large portion of the money is going towards the record industry, which essentially means that I'm contributing to efforts like ACTA, IPRED, attacks on net neutrality and the gradual shift to blaming the ISPs. To me this is far worse to society than anything allegedly caused by piracy.
Considering how little money the average artist get from record sales, I would rather protest the record companies by pirating the music and spending money directly on the artists through live venues and merchandise.
If you think sharing digital music is "stealing", then I suggest you get familiar with the principle of abundance. The real crime is in drawing an analogy between peers who elect to share digital information, and pirates who kill and steal limited resources in transit from A to B.
The fact is, while the market includes a large number of P2P filesharers, many people will gladly pay for convenience and live concert tickets, and none of this is going to change. If you can't deal with this, you are in the wrong business. If you are a musician who feels robbed by the masses of torrent sharers, then I dare you to reveal your identity and speak up against filesharing and see how quickly you alienate your fans.
Understand that when you liken the free flow of information to "stealing", you are speaking a point of view that is quickly becoming extinct. The next generation born into the P2P era will think nothing of this, and find your prudish inclinations out of touch with reality.
People are seriously re-prioritizing their "needs". There's a prayer about having enough so you're not tempted to steal. It's supposed to be about food and daily necessities.
Apparently some people need music so much that it's worth stealing for. Can't you just move on with your life, and decide to not listen to that music?
Relevant discussion was "don't make me steal": http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2176804