News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A VC: Anatomy Of A Pirate by steveklabnik on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @09:24AM (#2192912)
You're oversimplifying by applying physical property thinking to this.

I and a musician are face-to-face, and she says I'm not allowed to listen to this particular waveform unless I hand her $1000. It's not right for her to claim monopoly over this non-rivalrous good because she feels like she owns it.

Re:A VC: Anatomy Of A Pirate by mhb on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @09:35AM (#2192944)
The musician has spent part of her life creating this work with the expectation that she will receive the compensation she anticipated. It is not right for you to claim the fraction of her life invested in producing the work because of some zero-marginal-cost rationalization.

Anyway, is my understanding correct that if the artist was selling $1000 tokens to acquire her MP3 and you thought that was excessive, then you would take the token and leave whatever compensation you thought was appropriate?

Re:A VC: Anatomy Of A Pirate by steveklabnik on Tuesday February 08, 2011 @10:09AM (#2193068)
> with the expectation that she will receive the compensation she anticipated.

She made an incorrect assumption. We don't work on the labor theory of value; things are only worth what you can sell them for.

> then you would take the token and leave whatever compensation you thought was appropriate?

It depends. I'd probably take the token and then get around to compensating her someday. If it was somebody I knew, I'd probably give it to them upfront, but if it was an unknown, I'd just end up buying a ticket to their next show and handing them some money at it. (Yes, I have done this before.)