Lots of laws are privately enforced. DMCA doesn't have to be different.
If you file a false DMCA claim, even if unknowingly, you should be liable for damages. To the platform, for their cost in dealing with your B.S. An to the content owner, for their costs (including time and attorneys fees) and any lost or interrupted revenue.
I'd also make such judgements eligible for summary judgment, provided the damages are less than e.g. $25,000.
You can submit a counter-notice, and if for some reason they didn't give you the required information I'd expect you could contact support and ask for it.
You'll note how in that example, they provide lots of information on the party that filed the DMCA claim. That info is only provided to you if the DMCA notice actually included the info - Google will for some reason process malformed notices that don't contain the required information, which leaves you with no options.
In this case the person filing the claim provided no information except their name (4 japanese kanji) with no further contact information or other details. I was unable to find them on Google, if that was even their name.
It shouldn't prevent you from filing a counternotice with whatever information was provided - did it?
There are some logistical issues with enforcing that. I admit that upfront as I don't think those are a fruitful topic if you wish to discuss my initial "belief."
They do. They're the penalties for copyright infringement. DMCA provides a quick takedown mechanism; other copyright law lifts the rest.
The problem is no effective oversight. Laws without oversight are going to be obviously abused. The DMCA is like if police were responsible to ensure their own warrents are valid.