News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by tempsy on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:32AM (#21920584)
I always hear this but the theory of compound interest has little to do with stock investing.

Not all stocks pay dividends. Most actually do not. And betting on a general YoY rise in stock prices into retirement is not the same thing as compound interest.

Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by Moodles on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:40AM (#21920620)
Stocks don’t need to pay out dividends for compound growth. Your last sentence is basically: “betting on compound growth is not the same as compound growth”. Yes ok, but a little pedantic imo. Over hundred years of evidence suggests betting on a diversified portfolio of stocks is a good idea in the long term.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by tempsy on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:43AM (#21920634)
It’s not being pedantic. When you talk about the theory of compound interest it’s essentially starting with $100, getting paid interest or a dividend, and then reinvesting that so now you have $102 that earns a dividend or interest and so on.

Investing in 100 shares of company XYZ that does not pay a dividend, or investing in a company that does pay a dividend but isn’t being reinvested, is not compound interest in the classic sense at all.

Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by Moodles on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:46AM (#21920660)
Roughly speaking, if a company doesn’t pay a dividend, it reinvests the profits in itself which compounds its own stock price. You get the benefits of compounding stock prices that way. I think we are arguing over semantics.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by tempsy on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:55AM (#21920697)
It’s analogous, depending on the company, but it’s still a misnomer to use compound interest to describe stocks when by definition is only appropriate to describe a loan or deposit (e.g. principal and interest payment)
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by PopeDotNinja on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:30PM (#21925784)
You're missing a key component of how dividends tend to work. If a stock it trading at $102 and they announce a $2 dividend, the stock almost immediately drops to $2. If you buy/reinvest that $2 back into the stock, effectively nothing has changed.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by loco5niner on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:15PM (#21937301)
Correct! Except it drops BY $2 ;-)
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by BeetleB on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @05:27PM (#21925194)
> Not all stocks pay dividends. Most actually do not.

Yes, but the historical performance of, say, the S&P 500 has more to do with dividend reinvesting than the actual value of the shares appreciating. If they did not reinvest the dividends, the S&P 500 would not be as attractive as it is.

It's still not compound interest, but it is compounding.

Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by sweeneyrod on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @09:56AM (#21921339)
But given that a company can choose to stop paying a dividend whenever they want, by your standard dividend-paying stocks also have nothing to do with compound interest.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by _se on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:41AM (#21920622)
Historically speaking, you're very wrong. There's no better place you could've put your money than the s&p.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by tunesmith on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @01:18PM (#21923118)
A few tidbits to balance in:

On average, S&P performance over 40 years is very good. However, if you look at every possible 40-year period so far, some are really good and some are lousy. If you instead ask "What performance would I have gotten in 90% of those cases?" the performance is not as high.

Performance over 30 years is naturally worse than over 40 years, and so on.

Due to volatility, you generally score better (in terms of percentage of x-year periods) if you do 70/30 stocks/bonds rather than 100% in stocks. Meaning, you can leverage it to either aim for the same performance with less volatility, or same volatility with greater return.

Finally, people tend to put more money in the market when times are good at stocks are high, and less when times are bad and stocks are low. This has a dragging effect on what performance a person can expect.

For example, I keep pretty good records and have a list of every date/amount of each retirement contribution I've made. I'm able to simulate what my current balance would be if I have immediately put each sum into S&P (by using the adjusted close for that period). It's not as good as the reported S&P average over that period.

Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by BeetleB on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @05:25PM (#21925187)
> On average, S&P performance over 40 years is very good. However, if you look at every possible 40-year period so far, some are really good and some are lousy. If you instead ask "What performance would I have gotten in 90% of those cases?" the performance is not as high.

What is "high" for you?

I basically did what you suggest (although stopped at 30 years instead of 40):

http://blog.nawaz.org/posts/2015/Dec/pay-down-mortgage-or-in...

On a 30 year horizon, even the worst 30 years (involving the Great Depression) gained money - equivalent of 4% per year after inflation for a lumped sum investment. For a periodic contribution, it was more like 2%.

Still, the average for the last 30 years is about 7%.

> Due to volatility, you generally score better (in terms of percentage of x-year periods) if you do 70/30 stocks/bonds rather than 100% in stocks. Meaning, you can leverage it to either aim for the same performance with less volatility, or same volatility with greater return.

Can you find me a 30 or 40 year period where 70/30 outperformed the 100/0 case?

If you're close to retirement, putting more money in bonds is beneficial due to the reduced volatility. It still has lower returns.

> For example, I keep pretty good records and have a list of every date/amount of each retirement contribution I've made. I'm able to simulate what my current balance would be if I have immediately put each sum into S&P (by using the adjusted close for that period). It's not as good as the reported S&P average over that period.

How long is that period? As the plots on my page show, you need to be well above 10 years to reduce the effect of volatility. I mean - a 10 year window has been as high as 22% per year and as low as -7%/year (i.e. lost money in the 10 year period). Contrast with a 30 year window: The swing is from 11% to 2% - much more stable. If you're looking at your simulated performance over just a few years, you are essentially looking at noise.

Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by tempsy on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @07:44AM (#21920640)
I’m saying a positive ROI is not the same thing as compound interest. An asset that rises in value like $SPY is not in of itself an example of compound interest.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by awrence on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @10:06AM (#21921404)
This feels like a semantics back and forth. Call it compound growth then. It's the same concept. This applies to all yielding assets. You can call it divs / buybacks for stocks and interest for bonds, but it's the same thing / effect.
Re:What Is the Most Valuable Thing You Can Learn in One Hour? by samatman on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @12:31PM (#21922733)
Not even vaguely.

Compounded interest is reliable, even boring. You know exactly what you'll have at any moment in time.

Your ten-year index returns are reasonably reliable, historically. But your 2007-2009 returns aren't your 2016-2018 returns, at all.

They're different concepts and deserve to be conceptualized differently, especially in the modern era, where interest rates on Treasure are lower than inflation.