News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open Hardware on Its Own Doesn’t Solve the Trust Problem by jacquesm on Friday December 27, 2019 @09:48AM (#21891592)
That may be so but if I have to choose between open source software and closed software I know which one I trust more and I would assume the same goes for open hardware, in spite of the difficulties of transferring trust at the hardware level because of the parties over which you have no control. Of course if your threat model includes parties changing the masks of your chips then all bets are off but in general more openness is better and my implicit trust in people working on open source software and hardware is at a different level than the alternative.

If only because the ones seem to be driven by altruistic motives and the alternatives have already been shown many times to be willing to sell their - and your - soul to the devil for a price.

Open source hardware would need a verification and inspection method that reliably determines whether or not the manufacturer delivered what they said they would if you want that level of trust. And even then those tools could be compromised and so on.

To put it simpler: between say Intel or AMD and 'Bunnie's chip factory' I know which one I would trust more because with Intel and AMD I know for sure that there will be a bunch of misery included and with Bunnie I would at least know that he didn't include it himself and would do his best to avoid others doing it. Trust, eventually, is always going to be in people.

I'd love to see his 'non destructive method for the verification of chips' become a reality. It would be at least an interesting exercise to compare that what we have with what we should have.

And if funding is an issue, this is exactly the sort of thing where I would be very happy to throw money at a kickstarter.

Re:Open Hardware on Its Own Doesn’t Solve the Trust Problem by ganzuul on Sunday December 29, 2019 @06:30AM (#21905372)
> Trust, eventually, is always going to be in people.

Funny thing about trust; you can trust your enemies to behave poorly too. Trust seems to be about predictability first and foremost, and great mathematical work is being done to factor humans out of it. Autonomous vehicles are subject to a formalized version of trust already and engineers are working to get dependent type theory to do verification for them.