News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by lagadu on Friday December 27, 2019 @05:31AM (#21890453)
If most of the students did bad in the exam, the problem lies with the one factor in common: the professor.
Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by jccalhoun on Friday December 27, 2019 @09:11AM (#21891396)
As a college professor I agree completely. I forget who I heard if from but I remember someone saying that if your class is failing the problem isn't the students it is your pedagogy.

Certainly there are always individual students who fail but if most of them fail the midterm and it is only afterwards that you learn they don't understand the book then you aren't doing a very good job of tracking their progress and you aren't actually teaching them.

I don't know how large his classes are. It can certainly be hard to monitor what students are doing in a large lecture hall but in a smaller class of 20 students or so I haven't had much difficulty with students who wouldn't put their phones away when I asked them to.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by sharedfrog on Friday December 27, 2019 @06:12AM (#21890630)
In this case, maybe (I haven't read the article). But generally, I'd be wary of saying this. It conflates a complex subject to a single, easy answer which, incidentally, abolishes students of any responsibility for their own learning.
Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by ggggtez on Friday December 27, 2019 @11:05AM (#21892050)
And it abolishes the professor of responsibility as well.

Not to say the author is entirely full of it, but broad generalizations blaming the existence of cellphones for the problems of our entire culture is way too reductionist.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by memling on Friday December 27, 2019 @08:43AM (#21891265)
> If most of the students did bad in the exam, the problem lies with the one factor in common: the professor.

Class distributions vary significantly. I TA'd elementary computer programming for seven quarters.[1] Some classes were more engaged, some less. My worst was a TR 3pm: a quarter of the students failed. My best was a summer course in which I taught without a computer (except for the labs): the room wasn't equipped, so I printed the slides and wrote on transparencies.

My N of 7 isn't significant (average grades ran from 72-82%, I think, and I don't know the standard deviation), but it's worth thinking about the problem more globally than your comment suggests. We often think of student grades statistically (work that curve!), but we rarely think about it with respect to a set of classes. It's likely that this professor has had classes that were very good and very bad and some that were in between.

Reflecting honestly on my own career on the other side of the desk, I was not a very good student. I studied to pass tests, not to learn. I got a degree because failing me would have looked bad for the institution, not because I was particularly deserving.

The humiliation of that experience turned me (I think and hope) into a life-long learner--and it informed my teaching in the classroom. Failure is one of the best teachers to those willing to learn her lessons.

[1] We team-taught occasionally and always team-graded the exams (one question or section, depending, per TA) to help level the grading. We had a department policy that failing the final exam meant failing the course. We encouraged collaboration among the students on homework--less so on labs--reasoning that it would strike a balance between understanding the material and acquiring needed soft skills. Office hours policies were quite liberal: all students were welcome at all TA hours, so if you had an issue with your instructor you could visit the TA and supervisor. Complaints were taken seriously, and underperforming teachers were removed. My reviews were generally good, with the biggest complaints about my language. (I modified my class structure to spend a few minutes on vocabulary each day in response.)

{{ Edit: typo. }}

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by CrazyStat on Friday December 27, 2019 @10:35AM (#21891868)
As a TA I led computer labs for a large intro class for several semesters. One semester I got stuck with the 8am section, which I wasn't terribly excited about (especially since it was winter), but it turned out to be great--the section was smaller than the others because most students also didn't want to be there at 8am, and the students who did sign up for the 8am section were more motivated and self-directing than average.

Having to be on campus ready to teach at 8am still wasn't great.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by vezycash on Friday December 27, 2019 @08:58AM (#21891325)
I've given the same tests to my students 3 times - word for word and many students still failed. The good students who cared raised their scores with each repeat. The non-nonchalant students sometimes, managed to score less.

I don't keep my intention to repeat test questions secret. I do this to prepare them for pre-uni, university and professional exams which always reuse questions.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by learnstats2 on Friday December 27, 2019 @09:08AM (#21891379)
I'm curious: In what way do you think this is preparing students, if they - in your judgement - do not appear to be learning from it.
Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by vezycash on Friday December 27, 2019 @10:01AM (#21891672)
Is the statement below true?

>pre-uni, university and professional exams ALWAYS reuse questions.

Is solving past questions a useful SKILL / hack for student to learn?

If you don't agree with these, then nothing else I say would matter.

If other teachers repeated test questions, it would take less time for all students to adapt and benefit. I only taught in the first school for a term, the owner wanted me to stay but I had a better paying offer. Second school, two terms. By the second term, only 3 students consistently scored below 50% in tests. And of these three, one was extremely nonchalant. And remaining two were just slow.

Make no mistake about it - all teachers repeat questions. It's just that it takes too long for a test question to show up in exam - so most would see the exam questions as fresh ones.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by ggggtez on Friday December 27, 2019 @11:12AM (#21892103)
So... you include a discussion of getting "better offers" to indicate that your services are in high demand, as a signal that your teaching style must be good. You can leave that part out next time if you want to be taken seriously, because teaching for 3 terms at 2 different schools is hardly something to brag about.

But I'm afraid it doesn't really address the problem at hand. What if your first exam was bad, and by repeating it, you were just repeating the same bad questions, teaching a useless skill of memorizing questions instead of understanding the material?

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by vezycash on Friday December 27, 2019 @11:39AM (#21892288)
>because teaching for 3 terms at 2 different schools is hardly something to brag about

Context

>What if your first exam was bad

Good question but irrelevant. You ignored my questions. I want to believe that, I'm not the only one who sees that entrance exams to universities, university exams and professional exams repeat over 80% of their questions?

If all your exams were all freshly set questions, say so. If not, what wrong with preparing my students for reality?

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by learnstats2 on Saturday December 28, 2019 @10:28AM (#21899340)
Students should be aware that teachers can be lazy (like everyone else), and may repeat exam questions. It's an important part of exam strategy to teach that - by telling students. But this is a hack, as you say: it's not learning the material. If you don't have the understanding, then this hack is not valuable and may be very dangerous to rely on.

You are not preparing the students for an appropriate diversity of exam questions if you ask the same questions each time.

The students are perhaps doing worse because they have understood, probably correctly, that your testing is not a worthwhile exercise for them.

If you don't have novel questions, you are only demonstrating that it is unimportant to learn new material, or unimportant to find a deeper understanding of the existing material.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by vezycash on Sunday December 29, 2019 @03:40PM (#21908302)
Wonder if you would have the same opinion if you taught in a poor neighborhood, kids who have English as a second or third language.

I would gladly admit that my method is shitty if:

They only failed my subjects

Some still couldn't answer copy&paste kinda questions - open book quizzes

Other teachers didn't pad their scores at the end of the term

I'm done with this thread.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by chinesempire on Friday December 27, 2019 @07:45AM (#21891012)
> the problem lies with the one factor in common

Why not having a family?

Or living in the the same country?

Or having the same educational system?

Correlation is not causation.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by lagadu on Friday January 03, 2020 @06:57AM (#21945159)
- Because the original premise hasn't controlled for family, we can only work with the data we have

- Because other students in the same country succeed

- Because other students in the same educational system succeed

That argument only works if you manage to isolate the conditions to almost perfectly match a group, mine was "this teacher, teaching this subject" and the data fits.

Regardless, crying "my students use phones and all of them are failing" when there are students with other teachers that use phones as well and don't fail makes blaming phones an illogical conclusion.

Re:I asked my students to turn in their cell phones and writ... by chinesempire on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @08:57AM (#21979891)
> - Because the original premise hasn't controlled for family, we can only work with the data we have

I don't think data says what you imply though

> Because other students in the same country succeed

[citation needed]

The teacher in the article poses an ipothesys

- he has the suspect the phones might be partially involved in the problem

So he puts the hipotesys to test

- he asks his students what went wrong

- they answered, according to the article quotes “We don’t understand what the books say, sir. We don’t understand the words.”

- he asks them to not use their phones for 9 days, offering an extra credit as a reward

after the test he collected results. Among the other, I'll quote the first one

> “Writing a paper and not having a phone boosted productivity at least twice as much,” Elliott claimed. “You are concentrated on one task and not worrying about anything else. Studying for a test was much easier as well because I was not distracted by the phone at all.”

It looks to me that they were actually having a problem which is not their professor.

> Because other students in the same educational system succeed

Are they?

Across the Board, Scores Drop in Math and Reading for U.S. Students

https://www.usnews.com/news/education-news/articles/2019-10-...

> Regardless, crying "my students use phones and all of them are failing"

That's not what he did, what you are doing is manipulative, it's a well know bias called "false premise"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_premise