Context
>What if your first exam was bad
Good question but irrelevant. You ignored my questions. I want to believe that, I'm not the only one who sees that entrance exams to universities, university exams and professional exams repeat over 80% of their questions?
If all your exams were all freshly set questions, say so. If not, what wrong with preparing my students for reality?
You are not preparing the students for an appropriate diversity of exam questions if you ask the same questions each time.
The students are perhaps doing worse because they have understood, probably correctly, that your testing is not a worthwhile exercise for them.
If you don't have novel questions, you are only demonstrating that it is unimportant to learn new material, or unimportant to find a deeper understanding of the existing material.
I would gladly admit that my method is shitty if:
They only failed my subjects
Some still couldn't answer copy&paste kinda questions - open book quizzes
Other teachers didn't pad their scores at the end of the term
I'm done with this thread.
But I'm afraid it doesn't really address the problem at hand. What if your first exam was bad, and by repeating it, you were just repeating the same bad questions, teaching a useless skill of memorizing questions instead of understanding the material?