News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Semester with the Snowflakes by sneak on Friday December 27, 2019 @02:13AM (#21889740)
It’s interesting how much implied context is in this: that someone old, and related to the military (presumably right-leaning from the “snowflake” term), likely distrusts/disrespects someone young and wealthy from the coasts (presumably left-leaning from geography).

Are we really so polarized? Are hundreds of millions so gung-ho to flock away from the center? Can the whole American situation be approximately summed up, statistically, by these two exaggerated caricatures?

It seems that’s the tone of the article. Maybe it’s right, maybe it’s wrong, but either way I would hope that the real situation is more nuanced than that.

Maybe the situation on the ground really is that bad in some places. I don’t leave my house in the US much other than to fly out of the country, and only know what I read online about it. Can someone with direct experiences in these places shed some more light?

Re:My Semester with the Snowflakes by SpicyLemonZest on Friday December 27, 2019 @03:03AM (#21889880)
I feel like this is a pretty weird reading of the article. The author makes it clear that the real situation is more nuanced than that, that the people he's met at Yale aren't trying to flock away from the center at all.
Re:My Semester with the Snowflakes by sneak on Friday December 27, 2019 @06:29PM (#21895772)
I feel like the article is written into that presumption/expectation. It comes very much from a “I was like that, but now I am like this” place.
Re:My Semester with the Snowflakes by atoav on Friday December 27, 2019 @03:31AM (#21889979)
I'd say what is polarized isn't necessarily "all the people", instead the perceived discourse is polarized. And like in any really entrenched discourse, the one side thinks to know exactly what the other side wants and thinks, without ever talking to each other.

One of my best friends became a neonazi years ago. I don't live in that village anymore, but every 3 years I manage to meet him at some party or so. He has a extremely clear (and sadly utterly fantasized) image of my political goals and ideas. One of my goals is apparently to introduce muslim Sharia law nationwide, although I never ever mentioned anything about Sharia law to him.

It isreally hard to speak with him about anything at all, because he always seems to "know" what my opinion is, to the point of misrepresentation, while I am more or less just curious what he wants. What he says is usally a progression of: "I just want the foreigners to respect the rules!", "Deport the foreigners!" or "Shoot the foreigners!", depending on how many beers we are in. The whole thing is spiked with unsolicited explainations why liberal ideas "like mine" (although I am usually more on the realistic side) will never work and it sometimes feels he is telling this more to himself than to me.

This is rightwing Austria, his grandfather was a Nazi and this is where the discourse in the US is moving as well.

Re:My Semester with the Snowflakes by Ygg2 on Friday December 27, 2019 @02:28AM (#21889780)
Stress of life is polarizing people. Extreme conditions give rise to extreme beliefs.
Re:My Semester with the Snowflakes by rumanator on Friday December 27, 2019 @02:47AM (#21889833)
Extreme conditions give rise to desperate solutions that materialize into extreme beliefs.