News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by gogopuppygogo on Thursday December 26, 2019 @12:52PM (#21885446)
How is this surprising in a world with increasing global labor supply and levels of automation?
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatfrenchguy on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:09PM (#21885555)
It’s clearly societal choices: wages in the US for the poor and lower middle class are really low compared to the cost of housing / decent food / health care / education.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by opportune on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:26PM (#21885635)
The lower middle class can afford decent food, just some of them don’t want to eat within their means or aren’t cost conscious.

Actually I think innumeracy is a big problem for a lot of people with low incomes. I have a relative who I suspect is innumerate and it’s both fascinating and sad when you get insight into their budgeting/estimation abilities.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by bsanr2 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:42PM (#21886597)
The living conditions of poverty decrease cognitive capacity. So, in the cases where low-income households are not exceedingly proficient at stretching a dollar, there's an explanation for that, outside their control.

In any case, your first statement is objectively wrong (they can't afford decent food), and it's incredibly insulting on both a personal and intellectual level to compare people who are unable to keep themselves from dumping hundreds of dollars on luxuries to people who are splurging on, say, a full lunch instead of the PB+J they'd have time to pack otherwise.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by inkwater on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#21885694)
>innumeracy is a big problem for a lot of people with low incomes

the wavefront of the system of global capital since agriculture has been the liquidation of peoples for whom mass codified exchanges of increasing complexity didn't compute

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by falcolas on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:44PM (#21886154)
It’s worth noting that the “decent food” you’re referring to takes time to prepare. Time is something that the lower middle class doesn’t have a lot of.

Even 30 minutes of prep and cooking time can be too much to expect from someone after commuting home from their two jobs.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by txcwpalpha on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:20PM (#21885987)
You’re getting flak for this comment and I think it’s because people aren’t interpreting your point of view fairly. There certainly are many cases where people are legitimately struggling to make ends meet (and I don’t think you’re saying otherwise) but I think you are absolutely right that another big problem is that many people are making ‘enough’ money but simply don’t know (or don’t want to) spend it wisely.

It isn’t just the lower class, either. I know far too many people that make six figures and still complain that they live paycheck to paycheck, but meanwhile blow $500 at the bar every week, or buy a new $300 pair of shoes every month, or a new $1500 iPhone every year. There is a weird phenomenon where even people with means will prioritize luxuries and then complain that they don’t have enough money to save for a house or save for retirement. You see this on HN too, with several recent examples of posters saying that their $300k/year FAANG salary is too low and they can’t afford to live on it.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by opportune on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:35PM (#21886091)
Exactly, I don’t want to delegitimize poverty, but I do want to bring up that a lot (maybe not even most, but a decent chunk) of people with money problems have spending problems rather than earning problems. I also know people with very high incomes that spend a lot, and now that you bring that up, it reminds me that the problem in aggregate definitely has to go deeper than innumeracy (though I still think this is a problem for a lot of people).

The issue I see with a lot of people in particular is spending too much on cars, food, (especially eating out) and clothes. If you make $150k+ in the Bay Area, whatever. But a lot of people with lower incomes get caught up in this. Where I’m from you can live by yourself decently on just $25k-40k a year, but you don’t have a lot of room for error.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by pnutjam on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:54PM (#21885828)
Wow, that fancy talking sure makes me think you're smart. Maybe you can help me. If I make x and everything I need to live costs x+y, what do I do? Die slowly...? Work a 27 hour day?
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by opportune on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:03PM (#21885894)
I’m not saying the system isn’t rigged against poor people. But I do personally know people who are just bad at budgeting or frequently get ripped off because they don’t know how much things are supposed to cost, and probably wouldn’t need to ask for help at the end of the month if they changed how they spent money.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by pnutjam on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:43PM (#21886147)
Often, people know what something should cost, but they have to buy it through some other more expensive channel for any variety of reasons.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatfrenchguy on Friday December 27, 2019 @01:24PM (#21893129)
I know a lot of upper middle class people in the Bay Area as well who don't know how much stuff is supposed to cost and get ripped off all the time as well ;-).
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by ac29 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:41PM (#21886585)
Poster you're replying to wasn't talking about people who struggle to put food on the table. They were talking about lower-middle class people who truly don't (or can't) understand that buying a $40,000 truck with 18% interest for 7 years isnt a "good deal", its horrible, financially ruinous decision.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by pnutjam on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:13PM (#21886833)
Well, good thing that's what the article was talking about.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by ChrisLomont on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:34PM (#21885695)
Do you have data for this? Everywhere I look puts the US among the very best.

For example, here [1] is UK by quintile: In 2017/18, the average UK household income before housing costs was:

top quintile: £52,000 second highest quintile: £34,700 middle quintile: £26,400 second lowest quintile: £20,000 bottom quintile: £13,100 The average UK household income after housing costs was:

top quintile: £47,700 second highest quintile: £30,900 middle quintile: £22,800 second lowest quintile: £16,100 bottom quintile: £9,200

Here [2] is the US, 2018 quntiles: 13,775; 37,293; 63,572 ; 101,570; 233,895

PPP Adjusted means adjusted to cost of living [3]. Adjusting the incomes above gives for the bottom 20% of US $13.7K income, for UK $13.1K.

From all the data I can see over many countries, the US poor and lower middle class are doing much better than almost any place in the world.

[1] https://www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk/work-pay-...

[2] https://www.census.gov/data/tables/time-series/demo/income-p...

[3] https://data.oecd.org/conversion/purchasing-power-parities-p...

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by pnutjam on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:59PM (#21885863)
The US is huge, numbers in one area can be very high or very low and skew things significantly. It doesn't help most American's if salaries are pulled up (in the average) by a high cost of living area, and housing is pulled down (in the average) by a different area 300 miles away.

You see this alot in school data. The top 90% of schools would, if averaged, put the US in top standing. However, those bottom 10% pull us down (alot). The big fight in America right now is whether we cut those bottom 10% and say EOBAD's (GOP), or work to help them catch up (Democrats).

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatfrenchguy on Friday December 27, 2019 @01:28PM (#21893178)
You're not looking at cost of education (the UK is a European outlier on that one) or healthcare (a disaster in the US), or price of vaguely healthy food (just compare a middle-class Safeway or Walmart to a middle-class Carrefour in France for example), or the cost of cars, going on vacation (super expensive in the US), the number of holidays, etc.

Direct money comparaisons doesn't explain everything unfortunately, and if you just look at that the US is clearly ahead..

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by mertd on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:44PM (#21885769)
You are overlooking healthcare costs. Most Americans are one fractured leg away from bankruptcy.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatcat on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:40PM (#21885747)
US is number 1 in manipulating GDP and job metrics.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by shuckles on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:21PM (#21885610)
I’m not sure about “decent food”, but costs in the other categories are pretty decoupled from trends anywhere else in the world.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by ChrisLomont on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:37PM (#21885726)
Only US healthcare is an outlier in costs among OECD countries. Housing, food, etc., costs are similar.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by coldtea on Thursday December 26, 2019 @03:02PM (#21886273)
Education, healthcare, transportation -- not to mention bad public services...
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by ChrisLomont on Friday December 27, 2019 @10:56AM (#21891982)
>Education

Do you mean pre-college? In which case the US spends more per pupil than OECD average by quite a bit.

If you mean college, then most OECD countries have nowhere the number of people in college as the US. And there are ample cheap local colleges in the US - people choose more costly ones because they can.

>healthcare

Yep, I stated that one. We're about twice the per capita cost as OECD countries. That cost is spread through the system, including doctor and nurse salaries being quite a bit higher. This is likely due to Baumol's Cost Disease, since almost all higher skilled jobs in the US pay about twice OECD countries. So to drive our cost to OECD levels, you'd need to mandate locally low salaries for doctors and nurses, which would result in lower quality care.

I'm not sure what a solution is here, but it's highly nontrivial.

>transportation

Gas far cheaper in the US than OECD average, and likely cheaper than most if not all OECD countries. Or did you mean in city busses? In which case ours are similar. Or did you mean metro tickets? Again, same cost. Or are you talking about intra-city routes, in which case again we're similar costs.

Please clarify with data.

>not to mention bad public services...

All depends on where you live. To compare the US (by area and population) to somewhere else, you'd need to include the entire EU, or all of OECD, in which case you're adding places with terrible services.

If you want to pick small, nice countries, then pick small, nice states, and again, very similar.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatfrenchguy on Friday December 27, 2019 @01:25PM (#21893146)
> This is likely due to Baumol's Cost Disease, since almost all higher skilled jobs in the US pay about twice OECD countries. So to drive our cost to OECD levels, you'd need to mandate locally low salaries for doctors and nurses, which would result in lower quality care.

The bureaucracy of billing in the US is something magical that somehow manages to be worse in outcome and number of people involved than French bureaucracy (and the bar is high in terms of badness)

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by JoeAltmaier on Friday December 27, 2019 @11:00AM (#21892012)
Yes! Surprising how European countries compare to the US in size. All of England and Wales fits nicely within the US state of Iowa for instance.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by coldtea on Friday December 27, 2019 @03:00PM (#21894051)
On the other hand, they are ~50 million.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatcat on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:42PM (#21885754)
Transportation cost is higher thanks to poor infrastructure. Rent for a single bedroom is higher thanks to poor zoning/building code regulations.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by nonford150 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:29PM (#21886041)
Rent is higher in some areas due to market forces. If I have an apartment and can rent it out for $2500/month why shouldn't I?

A 1 bedroom in my immediate are rents for @1800/month. Go 5 miles down the road and the same space rents for $1000-1200/month. Differences? "Desirability" "newness" "better schools (which makes no sense if you don't have kids" "atmosphere (I read everyone looks like me)"

You can go into some older areas of the city and find rents below $800/month.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by thatcat on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:53PM (#21886230)
The difference in price between an efficiency / 1br / 2br is often negligible. Explain the market force cause of this.

Let's consider why older housing is so much cheaper for a second.. Property tax isn't recalculated until you update the building or rebuild on the property. So it's a huge disincentive to ever change any buildings, split lots, etc.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by falcolas on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:51PM (#21886214)
> If I have an apartment and can rent it out for $2500/month why shouldn't I?

Perhaps because “you” value morals other than “make the most money I possibly can”? Or you want to provide housing that’s affordable by those who do the blue collar, nearly-minimum-wage work that powers our modern cities?

Profit isn’t everything. I’ll even go so far as to say that the current expectation to get “maximum profits at any cost” is a (“The”?) driving factor in the problems we lament in our society.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by nonford150 on Tuesday December 31, 2019 @11:10AM (#21922004)
Yes profit isn't everything. Providing a safe, clean place to rent is foremost. But - if $2500 is the market rate for that living space there is no reason not to charge the market rate. The goal of a rental space is to meet those forces. A lower wage worker should expect less amenities, but not should be expected to live in an unsafe dirty place.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by bsanr2 on Friday December 27, 2019 @09:39AM (#21891533)
Market forces shaped by poor zoning and building codes.

$800/m is still precarious for roughly twice minimum wage. Food is also more expensive and harder to get to in less upscale areas of most cities.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by JoeAltmaier on Friday December 27, 2019 @11:02AM (#21892030)
Not sure how zoning and codes raises housing prices? Poor codes would result in cheaper housing (with no alarms or sprinkler, weak roofs that collapse under snow load, thin walls etc). And zoning can definitely reduce housing costs. In my city developers were required to mix single-family and multiplex in neighborhoods.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by bsanr2 on Saturday December 28, 2019 @05:10PM (#21902150)
The opposite also happens: barring multi-family dwellings that would reduce costs, and enacting codes that would allow for cheaper, but still safe, dwellings. The former is happening in pretty much every city, and there's no shortage of reporting on it, so I'll leave that to you, but for the former, I would specifically look at the laws that are forcing advocates of tiny houses and backyard apartments to continue fighting. Toronto recently reformed their laws to allow for the latter, after years of pressure.

Suffice it to say, these situations are far more common in cities than the ones you've described.

Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by dantheman on Thursday December 26, 2019 @01:33PM (#21885689)
And they're a direct result of government policy.
Re:Jobs, jobs everywhere, but most of them kind of suck by badrequest on Thursday December 26, 2019 @02:02PM (#21885886)
I must have missed the meeting where all of society got together and chose this fate for ourselves.