Re:Why I Write Books Even Though I’ve Lost Money on Every Bo...
by jaltucher on Sunday February 06, 2011 @05:10PM
(#2186596)
funny, for a guy who hates it you sure spent a lot of time on it.
Re:Why I Write Books Even Though I’ve Lost Money on Every Bo...
by jaltucher on Sunday February 06, 2011 @05:36PM
(#2186659)
A) not sure what dawkins has to do with anything.
B) i thought there's value in providing advances / sales numbers, etc. As a writer I can say there's nothing like that out there. It helps to understand the reality of the publishing business.
Re:Why I Write Books Even Though I’ve Lost Money on Every Bo...
by il on Sunday February 06, 2011 @05:52PM
(#2186708)
I think the numbers are the best part of the article, refreshingly candid. When a startup posts its revenue/traffic numbers it is lauded for honesty. The same should apply to this post.
It seems that books are like startups- unless you hit a huge home run, you really shouldn't be doing it for the money.
Re:Why I Write Books Even Though I’ve Lost Money on Every Bo...
by stevejohnson on Sunday February 06, 2011 @08:36PM
(#2187127)
> A) not sure what dawkins has to do with anything.
Simple, he hates religion but spends a lot of time on it.
Re:Why I Write Books Even Though I’ve Lost Money on Every Bo...
by stevejohnson on Sunday February 06, 2011 @05:33PM
(#2186655)
Others have said the same about Richard Dawkins, a man whose company I would be proud to be in. That's not to say that I think I come anywhere near him in terms of contributing to the discussion.
This is the first time in a while I have seen an article I disliked so much get up so high on the front page, so I feel obligated to explain my position to others so that they will think more carefully about what they vote up.
It's a meaningless story about a guy who, by his own admission, has written several books just for the attention. Then he meets, dates, and marries a girl in the space of a single paragraph, which somehow justifies the entire experience.
Now here I am, reading it on Hacker News, just wishing it would go away. We can debate internet philosophy (interacting with a System vs a Community) all day, but I'll just go ahead and concede the entire battle to you right now, because you're right, it was a bad comment made for unsound reasons. However, I am not a rational agent and will not delete it.