News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by bilekas on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:22PM (#21847092)
I am skeptic also, but at the same time, I remember the skepticism of the higgs.

I am more than welcome to be proven wrong though!

This news is a little crazy and I don't think people 'not being sold on it' should stop people trying.

Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by jessriedel on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:52PM (#21847296)
No, the Higgs was considered the most probable thing the LHC could find, including the null result of "nothing". People are always going to be skeptical of particular measurements because this stuff is so tricky and the incentives are huge for discoveries, but the prior of experts was that the Higgs would exist.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by thefringthing on Monday December 23, 2019 @09:56AM (#21863939)
I studied the philosophy of science a bit in university and one of my professors did some work on reactions in the scientific community to the Higgs boson discovery. I remember her remarking about how "this is a huge discovery" and "we knew we would see this; it's not a big deal" narratives were popular simultaneously.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by jessriedel on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @10:30AM (#21872638)
I don't actually think those narratives are in strong tension, especially if each were stated precisely. In short, "surprisal" is not the sole measure of importance for a scientific discovery.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by machrider on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:37PM (#21847186)
The Higgs boson was expected though, while this claimed boson is not predicted by the model at all?
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by amelius on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:39PM (#21847206)
Yes, a better comparison would perhaps be the faster-than-light neutrinos.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by jessriedel on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:50PM (#21847284)
That is a better comparison, but not a great one. A new boson (and associated force) would be exciting but completely in line with known physics. Speed-of-light violations would be absolutely revolutionary, threatening almost everything we know about fundamental physics.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by hn_throwaway_99 on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:47PM (#21847258)
Well, I guess in the sense that the faster-than-light neutrinos turned out to be false.
Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by bilekas on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:58PM (#21847336)
Fair.. Absolutely fair, personally I don't believe faster-than-light neutrinos exist.

It will be an incredible change, if something else happens: that's really all, I'm not pushing some agenda.

Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by zamalek on Friday December 20, 2019 @07:07PM (#21848533)
> personally I don't believe faster-than-light neutrinos exist.

You don't have to believe they they exist, they were quickly and conclusively disproven. As I recall, GPS was used as a time source and there was timer inaccuracies on Earth due to relativistic effects.

Re:New boson appears in nuclear decay, could break standard ... by bilekas on Friday December 20, 2019 @03:52PM (#21847292)
I wouldn't go so far as to say it was expected, it was more of a placeholder. It was more: 'Well, something doesn't add up here, so the 'boson' should fill that gap. And people went and searched for it.

I feel something simular to what we see here, the problem is trying to tie everything else that we know back into it.. I say problem but I really mean excitement to understand a bit more!

Again, this could all be completely wrong and it could even draw down to a bad input along the chain, but the idea is definitely something worth investigating!

Remember, the Higgs Boson brought us the imagination of changing a light particle (photon) to a particle with mass.. It's a quite wacky idea if you look at it from a point we knew many moons ago!