Re:The Computational Theory of Mind (2015)
by michaelmrose on Thursday December 19, 2019 @01:23PM
(#21837648)
I'm not saying that your particular software running on your machine would produce a subjective experience. Quake at 3 billion frames per second doesn't equal self awareness.
I'm saying that your hypothetical gaming rig because it can simulate any type of classical computation including running a simulation of your brain and thus would be sufficient given a programmer.
Primates, which are very similar to us, do not have a comparable subjective experience. We know that because we can communicate with them and they don't have that much to say.
There are also brains in other animals that share a lot of similarities and are larger than ours.
Yet no beings (that's were aware of) have a subjective experience as rich as humans or can self-referentially communicate about that experience.
But turn up the clock speed on my gaming rig far enough and I get to debate the meaning of existence with it?
You have to ignore so much that is obvious to come to a reductive, materialistic conclusion like that.
[Edit]
Not sure if it's worth adding this but I do think we can build a computer that passes the Turing test. I also believe (sooner rather than later) we'll have a Siri-like AI that will provide enough companionship that a relationship can be formed with it.
We could even teach that AI to discuss subjective experience in a believable way.