Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by teddyh on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @08:41AM
(#21824658)
People with actual authority should know better than to try and write simply by asserting their own authority; they should be able to source their statements and give proper references, like professionals. It’s when they don’t do that, and treat Wikipedia like their own private blog, that trouble ensues: Other Wikipedia editor and admins demand proper references, which these people interpret as an affront to their personal expertise, and it goes downhill from there.
Instead, people with actual expertise should realize that for Wikipedia, their expertise is not in the actual subject matter, but their value as experts is instead in knowing where to find proper references to things which most people might know already about the subject. This is where they can really contribute.
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by Jaruzel on Thursday December 19, 2019 @07:37AM
(#21834324)
Did I say not-referenced? Trust me, Librarians are the best people for referencing stuff - it's their job.
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by flir on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:02AM
(#21824013)
"wrong" or "unsourced"? It's an important distinction when playing the Wikipedia game.
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by thebooktocome on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:24AM
(#21824100)
It literally doesn't matter. A certain kind of Wikipedia editor only cares about deletionism, and will do any rules lawyering necessary to remove content they think isn't worthy.
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by belorn on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @09:58AM
(#21825457)
Its a bit like law enforcement. Certain kind of police only care about arresting people, and will just summon any law necessary to justify the arrest. The question becomes on how we perceive the majority of cases, if the rule of law still function, and if the amount of energy to defends one own rights is justifiable in order to not leave the community and find a better place.
In the case of Wikipedia I usually find that significant contributions require some energy in order to convince others that it should be added to the project, but in the majority of cases the enforcement is done in good faith (like most of moderation here on HN).
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by Angostura on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @06:11AM
(#21823772)
> There have been many reports
[citation needed]
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by thebooktocome on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:28AM
(#21824138)
Here's one (that links a second one):
https://twitter.com/cfiesler/status/1201246456599859200?s=20
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by belorn on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @10:15AM
(#21825648)
I am not very surprised given the initial motivation. She gave herself a quest to do political activism by editing Wikipedia, something with Wikipedia project generally looks at with suspicion and hostility.
I am not sure how well that translate to an librarian fixing errors and lifting decent covered topics with expert knowledge.
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by Angostura on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @08:09AM
(#21824412)
Thank you - enlightening and disturbing.
Re:Report for America funded a community Wikipedia editor at...
by cbm-vic-20 on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @07:55AM
(#21824315)
I wish we'd hire a gang of librarians to maintain our internal corporate wiki.
Librarians (the real ones, not the trolley pushing assistants) despair at Wikipedia. There have been many reports[1] of Librarians who are subject matter experts correcting the Wikipedia pages of which they are an expert in, only to end up in a edit wars with seasoned Wikipedia authoritarians who revert the Librarians edits because they are wrong(!). As such a lot of Librarians won't give Wikipedia the time of day, which is a real shame as these people are the real authority on their chosen subjects.
---
[1] No I don't have links; you'll have to ask my partner.