News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by dekhn on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @06:57PM (#21820396)
I was extremely lucky to transfer to a team at my employer that did full-time making (like Maker Faire). After many years of being totally ignorant about things that I cared about a lot (making structures that do interesting things), I was finally able to work with people who had been raised as gearheads and makers, and I found that I truly enjoyed working with my hands. Now, there are many things I don't like to do manually, but I will spend a ton of time designing parts in CAD, coercing my printer or mill to make them, and then assemble the parts into something larger/more interesting.

Eventually I managed to build some really cool stuff, including a scanning microscope (from CNC parts) and a "Bean Machine" which demonstrates the central limit theorem. Now I'm experimenting with rendering 3D surfaces into wood by writing python programs that output g-code so they can be milled (this would take far too long to do by hand unless I was retired).

Fun stuff. I think working with your hands (not typing on a computer, but cutting, carving, shaping, making etc) can be very enjoyable.

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by Ididntdothis on Thursday December 19, 2019 @03:25PM (#21838874)
I am mechanical engineer by trade. I definitely miss the times going to the workshop and watching a part I designed being built and being able to touch it. Definitely miss that in software. When I did mobile and desktop you could at least use the app but with server stuff you have nothing tangible. Often it’s nice to be able to work without any equipment but sometimes I really being able to touch my work.
Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by keithnz on Thursday December 19, 2019 @05:01PM (#21839753)
I used to do software for large fruit sorting machines. Nothing quite like standing in a huge multi multi million dollar buildings built to house a number of these machines all working together through your software and for the many many many thousands of concurrent actions working in perfect harmony at speed. Especially when you give those machines "smarts" and you see it adapt to changes in the environment / deal with problems. It was fun setting it all up testing, all hands on with the electronics/mechanicals

Also, nothing quite like the terror of when it all goes horribly wrong and you end up helping clear a mountain of fruit turned into unplanned jam(jelly) and everyone turns and looks at you....

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by Causality1 on Thursday December 19, 2019 @06:19PM (#21840302)
The familiar presence of a manager over your shoulder saying "A stopped line costs us eight hundred dollars per minute."
Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by monkeycantype on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:39PM (#21841075)
I spoke with some robotics engineers based in Brisbane, Australia who work on the machines that load bulk carriers (ships that carry coal, iron ore, grain etc.)

Though essentially just a conveyor belt, these things are simply enormous, as are the chains of operations that bring trains of ore and empty ships to port.

The largest of these is a coal loader that, through which one percent of the nation's GDP is flowing.

When it breaks down the pressure to get it going is intense.

It also gives some insight into why as bushfires rage across the country fuelled by the highest ever recorded temperatures, it's somehow controversial to discuss climate change.

https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/89683/heat-wave-bre...

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by pacificenigma on Friday December 20, 2019 @12:17AM (#21841876)
> Though essentially just a conveyor belt

It does look simple, but I spent many years in the bulk materials handling industry and there are also rail receival stations, electromagnets to remove contaminants, belt weighing equipment (real time volume calculation), samplers, surge bins (with vibratory hoppers under them), stackers, reclaimers, yard machine anti-collision systems, stockpile impact detection systems and a vast array of PLCs, front end processors, and application-level logic to manage it all.

> When it breaks down the pressure to get it going is intense.

Yeah. When you get calls at 2 am as lightning struck a microwave which stopped a network connect which stopped a database replication which stopped a stockpile calculation which caused a yard machine boom collision you really know how much fun it is.

On the bright side this industry is safety obsessed and quality engineering focused, so cutting corners is neither expected nor tolerated.

> It also gives some insight into why as bushfires rage across the country fuelled by the highest ever recorded temperatures, it's somehow controversial to discuss climate change.

Agreed. Although there are plenty of other factors which can improve bushfire outcomes as illustrated by the national Bushfire Cooperative Research Centre (of which most national fire agencies are members) research: https://www.bnhcrc.com.au/utilisation/overview.

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by keithnz on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:34PM (#21841042)
yes, some places were 2k+ a minute with a knock on effect for any serious delay, like when dealing with pomegranates, that when it rains they tend to split (to release the seeds) so everything is designed to put large volumes through as fast as possible during harvest
Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by jcoffland on Thursday December 19, 2019 @10:10PM (#21841450)
You should check out https://tplang.org/ It's Open-Source and part of the https://camotics.org/ CNC simulator. TPL is JavaScript with built-in extensions that make generating GCode programmatically and visualizing the results much easier. Disclaimer, I am the author.
Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by doorty on Thursday December 19, 2019 @04:47PM (#21839666)
Any chance you all are hiring? I'd love to get paid to do this full time.
Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by samcheng on Thursday December 19, 2019 @03:42PM (#21839028)
I've been thinking about wood CNC myself. What kinds of tools are used these days?

I have seen basically X-Y stages hooked up to a hand router, but I wonder if there are other approaches.

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by dekhn on Thursday December 19, 2019 @06:12PM (#21840253)
I have an X-carve, which is basic X-Y-Z stages hooked up to a hand router, for about $2K. I have one carving behind me right now (currently playing with generating sine wave and reaction-diffusion patterns in numpy, converting those to heightmaps in OpenSCAD, generating g-code with MeshCAM, and then rendering in wood).

There are also 6040 mills, which are similar but built differently, and shopbots, which are big but capable, plus a bunch of others. To me, the X-carve was the right combination of price, features, and support. I previously had the ShapeOko but it really wasn't capable enough.

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by samcheng on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:06PM (#21840922)
Thanks for the tips! I've been doing something similar with Python + FreeCAD for FDM (3D plastic printing).

Wood is just so much nicer as an end product, though.

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by jcoffland on Thursday December 19, 2019 @10:14PM (#21841467)
> I've been thinking about wood CNC myself. What kinds of tools are used these days?

Check out the https://buildbotics.com CNC controller and the https://CAMotics.org CNC simulator. Both are Open-Source. These are my projects.

Re:The case for working with your hands (2009) by samcheng on Thursday December 19, 2019 @11:40PM (#21841751)
Cool project! Thank you.