News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by jbrennan on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:07PM (#2181475)
I wonder what kind of disturbance just the helicopter (or whatever method was used to capture the footage) caused on the tribe.

Obviously the tribe was aware of it, but if they've never been contacted, would they be able to even fathom what such a thing is? I'm genuinely curious because I'm also genuinely ignorant on how "uncontacted" tribes like that are and what their civilization is like.

Could anyone enlighten me? It seems like such a fascinating area of study.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by cshenoy on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:24PM (#2181548)
There's a pretty detailed article (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1022822/Incre...) that explains what anthropologists assume they're thinking. It's basically "Stay Away" since the plane is a foreign object. In fact, you can see the tribesmen readying their weapons in case the flying object veers towards them.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by riledhel on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:35PM (#2181603)
Photos taken a couple of years ago showing the "stay away" attitude pretty good http://www.boston.com/bigpicture/2008/05/uncontacted_tribe_p...
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by vietor on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:17PM (#2181521)
I would expect that it would do what every other unexplainable but repeated phenomena did in pre-scientific cultures, become part of the mythology. See: Weather.

But my only anthropology was a few GE classes in undergrad, so maybe someone with actual knowledge can chime in?

Hopefully future history books (or niche Ph.D. theses more likely ...) won't include a section about the bloody war between the plane-ists and the aplane-ists, over the deep theological issue of gods made manifest and physically watching over you... [See discussion below, not meant as a dig about this specific video or this specific group of people]

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by farlington on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:23PM (#2181544)
from their faq (http://www.uncontactedtribes.org/articles/3109-questions-and...):

"uncontacted tribes will have seen aeroplanes on numerous occasions. The idea that this damages their self-image and/or spiritual beliefs belongs in the realm of fiction, and is based on the false supposition that their cultures are fragile. Experience shows that such peoples are in fact robust and well able to adapt to outside goods – most have been doing so for a very long time. Tribal peoples are not destroyed when they get or see things from outside, but by violence and disease as their lands are invaded."

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by fingerprinter on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:34PM (#2181595)
I have to call BS on this.

It may not "hurt" them, but it does influence/effect them. It has to. Going way back to my anthro classes, all primitive cultures crafted religious beliefs as survival mechanisms, to pass down stories and things that would benefit future generations etc etc. It was also a way to explain what they couldn't explain but still experienced (weather, natural disasters...) and this would fall into that category.

What the FAQ did was use inflammatory language (damage, fragile) rather than talk about how this might shape and craft their thoughts and beliefs. If we haven't contacted them, we simply cannot know if IT DID impact them.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by chc on Saturday February 05, 2011 @02:12AM (#2182659)
You're being nitpicky. The point is that they won't form a religion around it and it won't have any major "The Gods Must Be Crazy"-style impact on their culture. Yes, it will have some effect, and so will a butterfly flapping its wings in China.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by vietor on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:35PM (#2181609)
I did not mean to suggest that they would deviate significantly from the norm of any other group of people presented with unexplainable phenomena throughout the remainder of human history. Given the variance in how smoothly minor points of difference in mythology have gone down in the rest of history, it was not intended to indicate any additional fragility over baseline humanity.

Suggesting that it damages anything is a significant value judgment. To suggest that notable, repeated, unexplained phenomena would have no impact at all whatsoever is sufficiently at odds with the entirety of human history, culture, and the general body of human mythology, that I'd like to see a stronger citation than the paragraph on their website if you find one.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by Groxx on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:40PM (#2181630)
>Experience shows that such peoples are in fact robust and well able to adapt to outside goods

Yes, fairly often by either adding it to their mythology or creating a cargo cult: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cargo_cult

Whether either of those count as "damage" is academic; it's change. Either we inflict more change or we try to prevent all change.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by pessimizer on Friday February 04, 2011 @06:02PM (#2181718)
That's a false dichotomy.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by Groxx on Friday February 04, 2011 @06:06PM (#2181728)
"do or do not" is a false dichotomy? Any contact causes change, so the only way to prevent forcing change is to prevent all contact.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by pessimizer on Sunday February 06, 2011 @02:50PM (#2186292)
It's a false dichotomy to say that if they've seen airplanes in the sky, we might as well airdrop xboxes. I may be misreading you.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by Groxx on Sunday February 06, 2011 @05:29PM (#2186645)
That's probably it. I dislike approaches that generate mythos rather than knowledge, but you really can't claim that such a thing is or is not damage. It is change, and you have to either seek to maintain what things are now (enforced isolation) or you must cause change, especially if you seek to communicate with them at any time in any way.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by angus77 on Saturday February 05, 2011 @01:54AM (#2182633)
Or they could go, "Oh, wasn't that weird!" and then forget about it.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by Groxx on Saturday February 05, 2011 @03:55AM (#2182780)
Sure, just like I'm sure you'd forget seeing a literal flying saucer, glowy lights and everything. Just like all the alien-visitation advocates forget it, and don't try to tell others.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by angus77 on Monday February 07, 2011 @01:39AM (#2187994)
First, you're making the assumption people have actually seen such things, rather than making up stories to draw attention to themselves.

Second, a helicopter high in the sky in broad daylight would be far less freaky.

Third, it's not inevitable that just anyone goes and form entire religions and mythological worlds based on seeing something fly by in the sky. You're average person just simply isn't that creative.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by Groxx on Monday February 07, 2011 @04:45AM (#2188355)
1) you're making the assumption that people haven't.

2) a noisy, black, flying thing that's bigger than any bird won't draw attention, clearly. Why would it be less freaky?

3) totally agree. But your average person does tell other people. Do you think Spielberg made Close Encounters because he was visited by aliens? Or a significant number of the many many many other alien books / movies?

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by angus77 on Monday February 07, 2011 @09:53PM (#2191723)
1) you're making the assumption one should accept something as true without the slightest shred of evidence beyond someone claiming it to be true. Well, I'm the King of Atlantis. Now the onus is on you to prove me wrong!

2) nobody said it wouldn't draw attention. Watch the video. It did. But where's the evidence that having seen something freaky has now just irreparably altered their way of life?

3) Not sure where you're going with that. People tell stories, some of those stories have budgets, but...how has that changed our way of life? If (if!) these people go on to tell their children about the Big Noisy Freaky Thing In The Sky for generations to come...so what? Does this in any way prevent them from living the lives they have always lived? Does the fact that they've seen such a thing now mean that we have to invade their culture and "civilize" them, because otherwise...well, otherwise what? At most, they've got a new god to add to their stories. If that.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by bugsy on Friday February 04, 2011 @06:40PM (#2181849)
The uncontacted tribes are not unknown and they are not ignorant that there is a world outside with airplanes. They are uncontacted because they choose not to make contact with non-tribal outsiders. This is in part due to violent conflicts in the past.

There's a statement by a Yamomani leader on the site that uncontacted tribes should be left alone on their own lands and since governments like Peru were denying their existence, the photos will help.

http://www.survivalinternational.org/material/1157

Yanomami if you recall are a stone age people from this area who only made peaceful contact a few decades ago. They have had contact and familiarity with some of these other tribes.

The tribes in this video are protected somewhat by the Brazilian government which uses aerial visits to check on the condition of tribes and make sure that outsiders have not breeched the perimeter of the reserve.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by goldins on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:12PM (#2181499)
I assume you're hinting at the theory regarding the Native Americans not being able to comprehend Columbus's ships. It would definitely be an interesting research study, though getting the paperwork filed might be a bit of a challenge :-)
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by geoffw8 on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:54PM (#2181688)
Yeah, I agree.

To be honest, I'm not sure I agree with what they've done. I have no proof, or evidence of anything, just a gut feel. That moment could have irreversibly changed each one of their lives - possibly for the worse.

Its all of our world, I know, but still. I mean, they're not zoo animals.

Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by Devilboy on Friday February 04, 2011 @05:43PM (#2181639)
I'm sure they've seen planes plenty of times, I mean commercial airliners fly pretty much everywhere I think? I'm sure they'd love to see it up close though. They must assume it's a bird monster or something.
Re:Aerial footage of uncontacted Amazon tribe by mrnothere on Friday February 04, 2011 @08:16PM (#2182093)
Nah, commercial airliners don't fly pretty much everywhere they fly between airports on predetermined routes. Through air traffic control "sectors" One of the things that is hard to understand for all of us who live so close to the civilized world, is how much of the world is uninhabited and poorly understood.