News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Well, duh (1996) by tptacek on Monday December 16, 2019 @09:59PM (#21810103)
The title of this piece is "Well, duh". The sentence from which this submission's title is taken is If nothing else, the success of Infinite Jest is proof that the Great American Hype Machine can still work wonders, in terms of sales.; the submission's title doesn't get the full intent of that sentence.

Use the story title! It's in the guidelines!

Articles like this, it seems to turn out, are part of Dale Peck's schtick, as you'll quickly learn from a Wikipedia page that seems to think these kinds of takedowns are the most notable thing about him:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dale_Peck

I'm always there for a good takedown, and while I like DFW's writing I think Infinite Jest is a rich, slow-moving, and inexplicably unharried target. But I do think it's kind of funny that Peck opens by saying that Infinite Jest is a book without much of a plot, in which not much happens other than a 700 page conversation, and then spends 2 gigantic paragraphs trying to explain all the details of the plot. Which, it turns out later, he actually enjoys, once the puzzle pieces fall into place and reveal the book's underlying simplicity. OK then.

The bit in Infinite Jest written in (attempted) African American vernacular is truly awful, though. Peck is clearly right about that.

Re:Well, duh (1996) by dang on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:16PM (#21810194)
OK, we've changed it above. The submitted title was "Infinite Jest is proof the Great American Hype Machine can work wonders (1996)".

Since the submitter was attempting to use representative language from the article, I figure they thought the original title was baity and were trying to follow the guidelines by changing it.

Re:Well, duh (1996) by vo2maxer on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:59PM (#21810396)
Indeed, I thought the original title was baity. Thank you.
Re:Well, duh (1996) by tptacek on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:21PM (#21810215)
You're right. I dialed back my comment a bit. Thanks! And thanks to the submitter for finding this.
Re:Well, duh (1996) by vo2maxer on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:04PM (#21810429)
You’re welcome and thank you for the comment.
Re:Well, duh (1996) by throwaway2048 on Monday December 16, 2019 @11:07PM (#21810457)
This title is absolutely useless, it says nothing about _anything whatsoever_, its insane you think its a better title.

You could literally change the title to "An article about something" and it would be an equally "good" title.

Re:Well, duh (1996) by dang on Tuesday December 17, 2019 @02:42PM (#21817827)
Sure! Except there's also value in a title being what the author wrote.

I wouldn't want every, or even any other title to be as vague as "Well, Duh". But one is ok. It's generally good for HN's front page to have a couple that don't give their secrets away. We don't want to spell everything out. It's good for readers to have to work a little.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

If all information on the front page is obvious and straightforward, that's like simple carbohydrates—so quickly metabolized that they turn into sugar-rush discussion in which people react quickly out of reflexive associations. It's good to have some fiber to slow that mechanism down.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re:Well, duh (1996) by wmhorne on Monday December 16, 2019 @10:36PM (#21810285)
> The bit in Infinite Jest written in (attempted) African American vernacular is truly awful, though. Peck is clearly right about that.

On this topic I certainly agreed with him. I found that section horribly out of tune and out of touch. Also---though maybe I'm forgetting something---I recall it played almost no role in the story or plot. It stuck out as easily the hardest part to get through during my second read.