If a CA "forgets" to add a certificate to the CT log, they need a really good excuse to not get distrusted immediately. That's part of the reasoning: malicious certs are almost useless if you don't present them to a client. And if that client manages to exfiltrate the cert...
Re:Giving every IPv6 address a name
by ownagefool on Saturday December 21, 2019 @04:14AM
(#21850467)
You have a very good point.
CAA does rely on DNS working, which your registrar can probably hijack. Fair point.
CT would help protect against the registrar but not against a malicious CA who simply wouldn't log if they were going to sign a cert maliciously.
You're generally right though.