News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by bsder on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:25AM (#21794797)
> An entire board that basically sat quietly as valuations grew ever further out of touch with reality and that the first time they brought it up as an issue was already after the failed IPO had been halted

Um, like, duh.

The whole point of that IPO was to leave the public holding the bag. If Adam Neumann had only been slightly less of a douchebag, it might have happened.

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by chii on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:39AM (#21794845)
Banking on the public being stupid is not a good idea. Wisdom of the crowds is real. As long as there are regulations about financial reporting, these false valuations will come out eventually.

They needed to go all in, and commit fraud like Enron, if they really wanted to leave the public holding the bag.

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by bsder on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:46AM (#21795022)
> Banking on the public being stupid is not a good idea. Wisdom of the crowds is real.

Hardly.

It wasn't the fact that WeWork had horrific fundamentals that killed the IPO--look at Uber and Lyft. What killed the IPO was all the reporting on how Neumann was looting the company in just incredibly douchey ways.

If Neumann had been a touch more sophisticated or slightly less brazen in looting the company, the IPO probably would have succeeded.

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by leggomylibro on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:21AM (#21794953)
The aphorism that I'm familiar with is, "the wisdom of a crowd is proportional to the square root of its members."
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by johnsimer on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:07PM (#21799616)
Wisdom of crowd IMO only applies when estimating things whose estimate vs. probability of estimate being correct follows a Gaussian distribution
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by andy_ppp on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:27AM (#21794976)
Does that actually mean anything?
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by iudqnolq on Sunday December 15, 2019 @03:00AM (#21795064)
It's apparently a Terry Pratchett quote: "The intelligence of that creature known as a crowd is the square root of the number of people in it."

A sixteen-year-old newsgroup poster explains it as follows:

> Sorry to disagree, but I thought the quote worked extremely well the first time and on further reflection, still do. I think it's very apt and I would hesitate to say that perhaps you didn't see the intended purpose on first reading.

> Terry talks about the crowd as a creature, therefore implying one single IQ. So, to use your own methods, let's say a crowd of 100 people would have an IQ of 10 - not each, but altogether. Each person would have an IQ of 0.1 if you wanted to break it down, although to do so would be completely counter-productive, because we are talking about a crowd and not a single person. Once you start talking about single people, they are no longer part of the crowd and their IQ would revert to normal status. The crowd is a whole, and the description provides a picture of it being a single organism with one purpose (to imply the fervour that people get swept up in, in crowds, e.g. race riots, Paedophile lynchings, vigilantes that one person would not do)

> I think the purpose behind the description was to provide the metaphor of a crowd being a big, dumb, violent animal composed of intelligent, reasoning people - a sort of paraphrase on "the sum is greater than the parts".

https://alt.books.pratchett.narkive.com/nVL49SnZ/quote-from-...

As an aside, I find it amazing that I was able to go from a paraphrased description of a quote to an in depth discussion of the accuracy of the quote with suggestions for alternative functions. Despite all its flaws, the hacks upon hacks upon hacks we call the internet is incredible when you step back and consider it all.

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by cobbzilla on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:02PM (#21799587)
An interesting idea, but taken literally, it implies that any crowd larger than 22,500 people (150^2) has genius-level intelligence, which is kind of laughable.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by vjktyu on Sunday December 15, 2019 @07:02PM (#21799843)
The lower boundary of the 99 percentile goes up as 1/sqrt(N) and approaches the average member intelligence, but never reaches that level. At the same time, the upper boundary of the 99 percentile goes down at the same speed. However the number of super smart members, with IQ higher than say 160, grows linearly.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by iudqnolq on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:12PM (#21799635)
I agree completely, and I doubt Pratchett conducted much research to derive that algorithm. He might even be wrong about the constant factor at lower levels.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by iudqnolq on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:14PM (#21799645)
Correction: 16-year-old post. No idea about age of poster.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by vjktyu on Sunday December 15, 2019 @06:52PM (#21799806)
I think there is some math behind that statement. The average IQ of a crowd remains the same when the crowd grows, but the variance of that IQ, or more precise, the standard deviation, is stddev(crowd) = stddev(person) / sqrt(N). This is the central limits theorem. Now, if we assume that the intelligence of a crowd equals the intelligence of its most stupid member, and translate the latter into the lower boundary of the 99 percentile, we'll indeed observe how this lower boundary goes up as sqrt(N).
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by SkyMarshal on Wednesday December 18, 2019 @12:54AM (#21822230)
The problem with that quote is it's saying the intelligence of the crowd increases proportional to its size.

But I suspect he really means the opposite, that the larger the crowd, the less rational it is.

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by onetimemanytime on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:43AM (#21794856)
>>Banking on the public being stupid is not a good idea.

By the time public wakes up, the thinking goes, we've already cashed our chips. How many investment firms buy solid businesses, only to chop them up, milk them dry, load with debt and then IPO?

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by aguyfromnb on Sunday December 15, 2019 @05:40PM (#21799470)
This is why Silicon Valley stalwarts like a16z are pushing for an "alternative" stock market. They need a less transparent place to dump this stuff on the bagholders.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by dba7dba on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:06AM (#21794915)
This comment is downvoted but I have to agree with this. Rarely, very rarely do these people ever get caught or have to pay back the ill gotten money.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by kortilla on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:44AM (#21795016)
To the point where the business is no longer viable? Very rarely because without fraud it’s hard to hide that in the IPO docs.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by onetimemanytime on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:53AM (#21795035)
No longer viable or barely viable is a fine line. Here are a few cases: https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/the-debt-laden-lbo-t... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2006-08-06/buy-it-st...

Edit: It's not fraud, they disclose it all but a lot of people are fooled by the low IPO price, even though the business is loaded with debt and has a gazillion shares issued.

Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by unityByFreedom on Sunday December 15, 2019 @02:03AM (#21794913)
The public is left holding the bag every time a public company fails to achieve profit. No fraud necessary.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by Gibbon1 on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:47AM (#21794869)
I've been wondering lately about the similarities between startups and the movie industry. Most movies don't make a profit. But everyone involved makes money. One wonders what's in it for the investors using their own money. Along with the suspicion that making a profit isn't 1st on the list.
Re:Veteran executives and financiers helped fuel WeWork’s ri... by onetimemanytime on Sunday December 15, 2019 @01:50AM (#21794877)
>>Most movies don't make a profit. But everyone involved makes money.

They do this to screw the small fish that might have a % agreement and/or for tax purposes. So ABC Movie makes no money for Disney but (say) Disney Productions made $XX million to produce it, Disney Promotions $XX to promote it and so on. In the end it all went to Disney' pockets, but the movie lost money.