News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by orko42 on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:11AM (#21781202)
I'm a big fan of reducing traffic and doing stuff that's good for the environment, but ..."Hey, everybody! Let's stop doing stuff that I used to tell you was a good idea and make money off of and do this new thing that I think is a good idea so I can make money off of it. Also, you should stop owning things because those don't provide me with a constant revenue stream, and for the good of the planet you should pay me all of the time. Public transportation is bad, mmmkay?"
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by mc32 on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:37AM (#21781372)
Soon we’ll hear from the construction industry, don’t buy houses, let and rent your next domicile, we’re building apartment buildings like crazy. House ownership is over, except for us builders, you will rent from us.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by ehnto on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:54AM (#21781486)
Builders don't mind handing over all the risk to banks, real-estate speculators and developers. Developers on the other hand, would love to have you rent indefinitely. At least until their speculation pays off and they can flip you and the house to the next developer.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:10AM (#21781618)
Builders are generally not interested in being landlords.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by willvarfar on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:16AM (#21781690)
I'm not sure if you are talking about some local builders you know, or big construction companies in general?

I know lots of people who rent or buy-a-share-in apartment blocks. Each apartment block is owned by a company spun off of the construction company that built it.

There are all in a particular european city I am familiar with, but I imagine that system works in other countries too.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:24AM (#21781775)
I work in building design in the US and that's not what I've seen here. There are investment companies that finance building / renovating buildings. They might hold onto it until they get it filled with tenants then they sell it to a different investor who runs it. The construction company that does the building is unrelated to either of these. They specialize in construction, which is a completely different skill set from property management.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:59AM (#21781525)
I don't think there's anything wrong with making money. Consider the average personal car is only in use 5% of the time. People are paying an enormous amount to own, house, and maintain a car that they are barely using.

If they could instead just pay for the 5% of when they are using it and have it go off and be used by other people the rest of the time, it would probably ending being less expensive overall. There would also be fewer cars around.

Yeah, maybe the GM president once told people to own cars. Maybe that was the right thing at the time. Now circumstances have changed and something else makes more sense. Updating your views to account for new information is not a bad thing.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by snarf21 on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:07AM (#21781585)
It would be less expensive but that isn't why we own cars. It would also be less expensive to buy cheap fuel efficient cars.

We buy these cars because we are buying flexibility and time. Even public transportation can take lots of extra time if you aren't in the center of dense service. With my car, I don't have to wait for an Uber, I don't have to plan, I can just go whenever and wherever I want. It also doesn't get exponentially more expensive if I want to go somewhere 1+ hours away. Obviously if you never leave a three block radius, a car would be pretty silly. I'm just trying to say car ownership isn't generally about cost.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:19AM (#21781735)
Jeez, it seems every time in these threads there's someone who comes in like "Hey I live 40 miles from the nearest paved road, I need my own car!!!"

Nobody is saying it's going to be illegal to own your own personal car or anything. Sure, if you want to live in the middle of nowhere then you'll probably need your own transportation. For a lot of people it's not going to be as necessary to bother owning your own car when you can call one whenever you need it and it will be there in 5 minutes.

If you can get 90% of the flexibility and time for 10% of the cost that is going to make sense for a lot of people. Not owning a car at all is a much larger difference in savings than owning one that gets 30mpg rather than 20mpg.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by AlexandrB on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:33AM (#21781867)
I think you're missing the point. For the last 70 years American politics has promoted a set of policies that have made cities hard or impossible to navigate without cars. You don't have to be "40 miles from the nearest paved road" to experience this.

Now a lot of the same people that promoted and lobbied for these ideas are trying to sell a "quick fix" in the form of car sharing and other recurring revenue models.

There is no quick fix. The US needs a lot of public infrastructure investment before not owning a car is viable for the majority of people. Uber is not affordable compared to buying a $500 used car from Craigslist if you commute every day and does not solve the problem of navigating big box store "shopping centres" as a pedestrian.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:41AM (#21781939)
We don't know yet what the cost of something like Uber is going to be if the car can drive itself.

I don't know what city you live in, but where I live the city is pretty difficult to navigate with a car. This is because of all the other cars clogging up the road.

And besides, the entire point here is that you still have access to a car. You are not facing the problem of navigating a car based infrastructure without a car. The entire idea is that there are cars available on-demand!

I guess we could do nothing and hope that at some point governments figure out to build public transportation in a reasonable time frame for a reasonable amount of money, but I'm not going to hold my breath for that. There is zero reason we can't simultaneously work on more efficiently using the infrastructure we already have.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by AlexandrB on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:58AM (#21782108)
> I guess we could do nothing and hope that at some point governments figure out to build public transportation in a reasonable time frame for a reasonable amount of money...

Non-US governments already have. This isn't incompetence, it's intentional policy.

> This is because of all the other cars clogging up the road.

Ride sharing has only made this problem worse[1]. Is there any evidence that even more ride sharing will improve the situation? The basic problem is that everyone needs to get into or out of a few central locations at around the same time (typically 9am/5pm). Solving this requires moving people more efficiently (as in more people/m^2 of roadway) than cars, even ride sharing cars, would allow.

[1] https://www.smartcitiesdive.com/news/report-ride-sharing-inc...

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @11:02AM (#21782713)
Nobody is saying not to invest in public transportation. I'm for that 100%. I sincerely hope the US develops the political will to do it.

But even if everyone agrees to do it tomorrow, we're talking decades to completely rebuild infrastructure of major cities.

I don't know why this is framed as an either/or choice. Build better public transportation, sure. How about we also use cars more efficiently. Why are you against that?

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by kaibee on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:16AM (#21781698)
> Consider the average personal car is only in use 5% of the time. People are paying an enormous amount to own, house, and maintain a car that they are barely using.

This statistic is silly. It's like the "you only use 10% of your brain!!1" meme.

I don't disagree with the overall premise and there's definitely cases where it makes sense (especially in cities), but there's a real trade-off being made.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by AnimalMuppet on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:46PM (#21783661)
> Consider the average personal car is only in use 5% of the time.

Freedom to choose has value. Convenience has value.

I keep my cleats in the car, so that I can just pick which day I want to play ultimate frisbee on the spur of the moment. I don't have to decide in advance and pack something. That freedom to make up my mind on the spur of the moment is worth something.

I can be at home, and decide I need something from the grocery store, and just go get it. I don't have to order a car and wait for it to arrive. Once I'm done at the store, I don't have to order another car for the trip back. That "it's ready right now" convenience is worth something. (Yeah, I know, in a decent urban world, the grocery store would be within walking distance. I don't live in that ideal urban world.)

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @04:55PM (#21785921)
And if you really want the have a car payment and insurance payment and deal with parking and everything else so that you have a 2000lb box to store your cleats in and can avoid waiting five minutes for a car share, I won't stop you from doing that. I doubt anyone else is going to either.

The point is a lot of people are going to decide that maybe they can plan a little in advance on when they want to play ultimate frisbee if it helps them avoid the myriad hassles and expenses of owning a car and that's probably going to be good.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by _visgean on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:08AM (#21781606)
would the car last as long as it lasts when you use it 5% of the time? From what I have heard its common to replace company fleets after 5 years or so...
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by FussyZeus on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:31AM (#21781847)
> Consider the average personal car is only in use 5% of the time.

I only use my toilets a small fraction of the day as well, would you suggest we crowdsource them for greater efficiency too?

Also this statistic presumes that cars work better with higher utilization and that's muddy at best. Sure, greater utilization is more efficient but it also means the cars go through parts much faster, require more oil, more fuel obviously. And of course the ride share companies aren't paying to maintain the cars that they are running into the ground.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imgabe on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:42AM (#21781958)
You notice that when you go out in public there are shared toilets everyone uses and you don't have to lug your own toilet with you everywhere you go, right?
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by FussyZeus on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:51AM (#21782046)
And they're also disgusting, poorly maintained, and full of drug addicts.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by sandworm101 on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:45AM (#21781427)
The real fear is the potential lifespan of electric cars. IC cars already last decades in private ownership. With fewer moving parts, electric cars could last even longer. They need to keep everything in fleets, where cars can be forced off the road after a specific timeframe, if they want to maintain sale/replacement rates long term.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by pxtail on Friday December 13, 2019 @11:37AM (#21783056)
> With fewer moving parts, electric cars could last even longer

Judging by what is happening right now with EV cars already produced long time ago [1] general outcome and EV cars lifespan will be lower than IC cars due to non-available batteries, there are already people who are seriously disappointed [2] and I think that it is going to be worse because lack of affordable batteries replacement is in best interest of car maker companies.

[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/leaf/comments/aocih1/battery_replac...

[2]https://www.reddit.com/r/leaf/comments/b2etie/more_affordabl...

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by bluGill on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:58AM (#21781517)
Electric cars will fail just as soon as IC powered cars because the engine hasn't been the limit in years. The power source has no effect on how fast the seats wear. The power source as no effect on the rubber door seals failing. The power source has very little effect on how long before the suspension wears out. The power source has no effect on how long before the "new car" smell goes away. The power source has no effect on changing styles. The power source has no effect on when an accident destroys the car.

IC cars do last decades if you care for them. Very few people do.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by zaroth on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:12AM (#21781651)
Engines, transmission, emission systems / catalytic converters, timing belts... there are dozens of components in an ICE which start failing or performing badly around 80k-120k which contribute to maintenance fatigue at that point. When you start spending $3-5k per year making all these expensive repairs to an old ICE car it feels like throwing good money into a pit.

The other big item is the software in the car becomes slow, dated, and no longer inter-operates properly with the latest phones.

Both of these factors are significantly mitigated with an EV with OTA updates.

Particularly when the manufacturer makes their latest generation hardware field upgradable, you can buy a new MCU and slot it into a late-model car and get all the latest features and performance.

The Model 3 in particular has an esthetic which IMO is particularly timeless and will not feel dated in 10 or even 20 years.

No car is maintenance free. The question is predictability and TCO. If A) maintenance is predictable, B) TCO remains low, and C) performance is consistent, then people will hold onto their EVs for more miles than their ICE equivalents.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by Unklejoe on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:34AM (#21781881)
> The Model 3 in particular has an esthetic which IMO is particularly timeless and will not feel dated in 10 or even 20 years.

Maybe the physical appearance of the car, but I guarantee the interior and infotainment system will age poorly in 10-20 years, just like any other car. In fact, it might even age worse.

Try using a 5 year old Android tablet and you'll see what I mean.

> people will hold onto their EVs for more miles than their ICE equivalents

Some people, but there are a lot of people who buy cars for status, and they won't want to be driving a 10 year old car whether it's financially practical or not.

This aspect will not change just because the cars are more reliable.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by bluGill on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:31AM (#21781849)
Every car I own has > 140k miles with no such problems. The timing belt is a maintenance item. It isn't $3-5k/year it averages out to about 1.5k/year - some years it is 5k, but other years it is much less. Most people give up on the car at the first 5k estimate not realizing they just fixed/replaced the expensive parts which are now good for more years.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by sandworm101 on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:01AM (#21781544)
Try getting an old car past new emission standards. A new cat converter on a 15yo Honda isn't cheap. A tranny rebuild isn't cheap. I don't know of any cars junked for lack of new car smell.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by dsfyu404ed on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:07AM (#21781586)
>Try getting an old car past new emission standards.

Outside of California and a couple other states making a car pass emissions until it ages out of the emissions testing program at 15-25yr is not cost prohibitive.

>A tranny rebuild isn't cheap.

Transmission replacement is of similar cost and happens around the same mileage as a battery pack replacement.

>I don't know of any cars junked for lack of new car smell.

His point was that the people that buy new cars typically trade them in and buy another new one for reasons other than it being no longer economically viable to run.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by souprock on Friday December 13, 2019 @07:57PM (#21787052)
Emission standards??? I'm Florida Man. Car inspections are not required.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by semi-extrinsic on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:09AM (#21781609)
The "fewer moving parts" myth needs to die. IC engines themselves are extremely reliable, it's usually something else that finally kills an old car.

Just think about it: a very high mileage car does maybe 300 000 miles. At an average speed of 30 mph that's only 10 000 hours of running, or 420 days continuously. IC engines in generators, excavators, ships, trains, heck even in aircraft routinely do many many multiples of this before they are scrapped.

For any part on a vehicle, IC or EV, it's possible to make it last fifty thousand hours no problem. But value engineering is a thing, so companies will make stuff cheaper and cheaper until it lasts only for 10k hours, or maybe 2k for a "regular replacement part". There is absolutely no reason they won't do exactly the same value engineering on an EV car as an IC car.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by purplezooey on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:37PM (#21784629)
But if they are built so cheaply like other durable goods, why would we expect them to last.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by dmix on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:32AM (#21781316)
A smaller group of cars getting replaced faster due to greater use, potentially with recurring subscription models reducing the amount of long term financing people have to get stuck with for the same amount of cars produced (or less) which they rarely use is still better than a glut of cars filling up parking through out a city and rusting out needlessly.

It’s more efficient by fully utilizing each vehicle efficiently for the environment and economically for customers in many ways when debt loads are the biggest issue in recent times...

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by noobermin on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:36AM (#21781353)
Uber and Lyft certainly did not decrease congestion in cities. The idea that ride-hailing services would decrease congestion already has not panned out.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by dmix on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:53AM (#21782069)
We're not anywhere near what the GM is talking about. He's not talking about how Uber and Lyft are today. I also didn't mention congestion in my comment.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by imglorp on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:39AM (#21781384)
Do they reduce parking usage at least?
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by jackcviers3 on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:15AM (#21781685)
You need at least a $45,000 car to equal paying uber to drive you everywhere.

The ride share services haven't made a dent in the transportation needs of the world.

You know what's necessary? On demand minibusses that go everywhere and are routed to riders along the route to the destination to keep them full. Uber isn't that.

Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by javiramos on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:39AM (#21781380)
Your comment reminded me of John Boehner who went from opposing any type of drug legalization to marijuana salesman. And making millions out of it.
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by bigkm on Friday December 13, 2019 @11:45AM (#21783114)
The real life Gavin Belson
Re:GM’s Former President Calls for the End of Car Ownership by janpot on Friday December 13, 2019 @08:21AM (#21781252)
this, it's capitalism/consumerism feeding on the green wave. while it's actually the cause of the mess.