News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwawaysea on Thursday December 12, 2019 @02:56PM (#21775686)
I disagree that it is a 'dragnet'. That seems like an emotionally-colored take. It is camera owners voluntarily sharing footage with police when they request it. Citizens are allowed to lawfully film in many locations (their own homes, public spaces, etc.) and citizens are allowed to voluntarily exchange information they own with entities of their choosing.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by aidenn0 on Thursday December 12, 2019 @03:02PM (#21775744)
At some point quantitative changes to cost and availability make a qualitative change in the invasiveness of a technology. I don't know enough about how ring footage is being used to say whether or not it's crossed that point, but this can't be dismissed just because it's something that's always been legal and happening at a smaller scale.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by HarryHirsch on Thursday December 12, 2019 @03:05PM (#21775779)
Just the sheer scale of data collection by the Ring public-private partnership is worrisome already. Some of us worry about the amount of information held by Facebook, even those that do not have a Facebook account. The same principle applies here.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwawaysea on Thursday December 12, 2019 @09:08PM (#21778563)
If it is legally filmed footage (for example on public spaces or in a private residence), then there is no legitimate expectation of privacy.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by HarryHirsch on Thursday December 12, 2019 @09:26PM (#21778662)
There's the tiny issue that storage became so cheap over the last 20 years that recordings can now be kept indefinitely. In the past you had a CCTV camera, and you could store maybe a month's worth of movie (on tapes, in a safe), until you had to overwrite it.

Now you just keep filming and have a never forgotten record of who lives in the neighbourhood. And if Facebook runs it though its face recognition system they get names, friends and other preferences. That completely changes the nature of CCTV recordings.

The law just hasn't caught up with it, also because of prolific lobbying by the usual bigdata actors.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by homonculus1 on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:41AM (#21781933)
Expectation of privacy was defined in an era when recording was expensive, on the assumption that there was a certain degree of anonymity in public just from the sheer impossibility of tracking everybody.

There is no reason that our rights should be limited to what was found necessary to protect in the past. There must be a new category of expectation of transience, that Jeff Bezos and the FBI won't keep a permanent record of your every waking moment.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by glenda on Thursday December 12, 2019 @03:00PM (#21775727)
From what I’ve seen sharing these videos publicly also provides a potential thief with your location and information about the placement of your cameras, which is not a smart move if security is your main motive.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by Johnny555 on Thursday December 12, 2019 @03:51PM (#21776308)
What information is disclosed that the thief can't discover himself by driving or walking by your house?

It seems unlikely that a thief needs to see a published list of camera locations to find my house, unless for some reason he's looking specifically for houses that are protected by Ring cameras. My ring doorbell cam is readily visible from the street, so there's no secrets about placement.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by OnlineGladiator on Thursday December 12, 2019 @03:58PM (#21776384)
Knowing where the cameras are lets the thief know where the blind spots are. The thief wouldn't be able to see a hidden camera just by walking by (or at least it's much less likely).

I don't think most Ring cameras are meant to be hidden though, since it's primarily sold as a doorbell.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by heavyset_go on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:25PM (#21776661)
> It is camera owners voluntarily sharing footage with police when they request it.

Police can request that you share the footage you have, or police can get a warrant and obtain the footage directly from Ring.

The difference between a camera whose footage you control and Ring is that Ring provides a nice interface to let police know that potential video evidence that you captured exists. A camera system that you rolled out yourself doesn't send a message to law enforcement agencies each time your cameras potentially capture evidence.

The knowledge that video evidence exists makes it infinitely easier to get a warrant for it from a judge.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwaway393955 on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:45PM (#21776877)
They don't need a warrant. They only need to make a friendly administrative subpoena to Amazon, which will happily fork over the data without challenging the order, even if the owner has refused.

https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2019/08/police-can-get-y...

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by heavyset_go on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:50PM (#21776920)
This is a good point, as well. Part of Ring's business model is integration with law enforcement. The incentives in place certainly don't align with user privacy.

Thanks for the link.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwawaysea on Thursday December 12, 2019 @09:07PM (#21778559)
This is a false story that relies on an incorrect statement from someone in the Fresno police department. Your own article contains this update:

> UPDATE 5:55pm ET: After we published our story, a representative from Ring responded to our request for comment to deny all allegations in the Government Technology report.

> "The reports that police can obtain any video from a Ring doorbell within 60 days is false," a spokesperson said. "Ring will not release customer information in response to government demands without a valid and binding legal demand properly served on us. Ring objects to overbroad or otherwise inappropriate demands as a matter of course. We are working with the Fresno County Sheriff's Office to ensure this is understood."

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by heavyset_go on Thursday December 12, 2019 @10:32PM (#21778953)
> "Ring will not release customer information in response to government demands without a valid and binding legal demand properly served on us."

Ring's own statement reflects what the OP stated: that Ring will turn over evidence when given a subpoena.

Ring also released a contradictory claim to what the police said Ring made available to them. Either the police are lying about a process they seem to know well and have used many times before, or Ring is lying in their statement to Ars.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwawaysea on Thursday December 12, 2019 @11:01PM (#21779053)
I am primarily commenting on the "they don't need a warrant" bit, and the editorialized label of a "friendly administrative subpoena". A subpoena and warrant have a high legal bar, and the difference is who they are directed to. The way OP's comment is worded, it makes it seem like some significantly lesser bar than a warrant is being exercised. A subpoena still requires a court order, like a warrant! See https://legalbeagle.com/8676593-subpoena-vs-warrant.html.

Furthermore: Clearly, the Fresno police department person who spoke may not have understood the requirements for access or may not be aware of what prior actions (such as a subpoena) precipitated a release of video.

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by jellicle on Friday December 13, 2019 @10:58AM (#21782669)
An administrative subpoena, as the name tells you, is not issued by a court and does not require a court to be involved. It's a police agency, acting on its own and without supervision, requesting documents believed to be related to a criminal case.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwawaysea on Thursday December 12, 2019 @09:05PM (#21778548)
So what? I think it’s OK for them to know that footage exists. That’s not an invasion of anyone’s privacy. Using warrants to get evidence is a legitimate part of our justice system.
Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by throwaway2048 on Thursday December 12, 2019 @03:10PM (#21775831)
Consider if a police force was near omniscient, and could view everything happening in a city publicly, at all times 24/7.

Don't you think that changes the nature of things, even if technically legal?

Re:A podcast that hacks Ring camera owners live by erikpukinskis on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:16AM (#21779737)
Omniscient police would be a qualitatively new development, for sure.

But as surveillance increases, so does stealth. You’d have to include that in your model.