News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future of War Technology by simonh on Thursday December 12, 2019 @09:21AM (#21772029)
>This development happened after the war, when supposedly no "revolution" happens

I don't think that's fair, both atomic weapons and long range rockets to carry them only existed due to wartime research. WW2 definitely lead to very much accelerated developments in a whole range of areas of technology, but 4 or 5 years just wasn't enough to bring them all to full fruition.

Radar, rockets, jet engines, autonomous air vehicles, helicopters, guided munitions, nukes, computers, assault rifles were all first developed as effective systems during WW2, but for the most part only fully matured and became widely adopted afterwards. Even to this day we are largely fighting with weapons technologies originally developed during WW2. The US civil war and Franco-Prussian war looked nothing like WW1, which looked nothing like WW2, but Operation Desert Storm looked exactly like an updated version of WW2.

Having said all that a full-on existential 'total war' conflict between the USA and Russia would look like nothing we've ever seen. It would look like something military planners in 1945 were trying to achieve though.

Re:The Future of War Technology by SiempreViernes on Thursday December 12, 2019 @11:37AM (#21773365)
The field where the military dominates all others is the development of weaponry, so certainly the atomic weapons owe their existence at that point in time to the war. But you make a broader claim about the history of technology in that simply doesn't hold up.

Certainly a war greatly accelerates development of military applications, which can drive the broader technology forward, but invariably the basic work is done before the war: crude radar was developed before the war, powered flight pretty famously was developed outside of war, modern rocketry has its early days in the inter-war period, and fission was mastered before the war.

So the basis for all these "revolutionary" weapon technologies lie outside of war time research, and thus would plausibly have been developed regardless, if a bit later. In fact, the USA is the only country to have developed nukes during a war, all others have done it in peace time, and many have done it with very little outside assistance (besides the fairly important knowledge that it is possible at all).

On closer inspection I find the claim that many technologies owe their existence to the military, and the particular needs of war, to be very overblown: certainly weaponisation of technologies own much to war, but people tend to not be very clear on the detail that the miraculous technological development of a rocket that can fly very far before crashing at a predetermined spot isn't very helpful for society at large. The technologies we enjoy today don't owe that much to those developed for killing.