Re:Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
by zaphirplane on Wednesday December 11, 2019 @10:31AM
(#21763318)
I’m not sure asserting Facebook is a third party is correct. They are a third party in the communication sure but are also the provider of communications medium. Compelling then to back door it wouldn’t be compelling a third parry
You're right that there are warrantless exceptions (most notably, Horton, which clarified the plain view doctrine), but I'm not aware of any case law that compels a third-party to break encryption/build a backdoor in order to satisfy a warrant. That was the genesis of the Apple v. FBI case. Even Lavabit, the rulings were largely procedural and didn't get to the merits of Lavabit's claims against the government's attempts to coerce a service provider into turning into a surveillance apparatus.