Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by taneq on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:14AM
(#21749797)
The implication here is that maybe the cofounder's 'next business' is the same business with a different back-end and that the market presence and customer base (which absolutely are assets of the current business) are being carried forward. If this is the case then the OP has a valid claim to any profits generated by those assets, or to being bought out.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by owens99 on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:28AM
(#21749846)
This is not true at all.
The business's legal entity is being shut down and closed. The OP only has claim over assets of that business. If he agrees to certain assets being given to the other partners, he has no claim for the future use of those assets.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by taneq on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:36AM
(#21749902)
Of course, if that's part of the split (you take the code you wrote, I take the customers I sold to) then there's no future claim. The way I read it, there was no discussion of that, but maybe I'm wrong - after all we don't have much to go on here.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by owens99 on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @07:09AM
(#21751718)
Yes that’s a fair point. We don’t know all the details.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by goatherders on Monday December 09, 2019 @11:41PM
(#21749641)
It's not ridiculous at all if it's in the same niche doing the same thing.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by manigandham on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @01:06AM
(#21750064)
Ownership is bounded by legality. As long as someone starts a new company completely from scratch (without using any of the resources from the prior one), then you have no ownership claim to it.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by goatherders on Saturday December 14, 2019 @08:55AM
(#21789496)
No, but you can accuse them of fraud if they start essentially the same company without you in it.
Re:Ask HN: We are shutting down our startup, I get our code....
by owens99 on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @12:29AM
(#21749849)
Yes it is.
The business's legal structure is being closed and shut down. OP only has claim over how the assets of that legal structure are distributed.
If his partner goes on to start a new business in the same niche to do the same thing, legally and ethically there's nothing he can do or claim.
Just because your startup is worthless doesn’t mean you get a percentage of your cofounders next business. That’s ridiculous.