News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by aidenn0 on Monday December 09, 2019 @12:28PM (#21744455)
My parents bought the house in which I grew up in 1985. They had a double-digit interest rate on that purchase at more than 3 times the current going rate and that was with paying points too.

I do wonder what will happen if mortgage rates return to even their pre-Volcker level, much less the 1980s levels. Household incomes versus PITI on a 30 year mortgage places a ceiling on housing prices, so if interest rates go up, then the prices in currently hard-to-afford areas will have to go down.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by klodolph on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:01PM (#21744794)
You can already see that housing prices are inversely correlated with interest rates. Yes, this will reduce the sale price of houses in hard-to-afford areas, but the change on how affordable these houses are will not change as much as you might think.

E.g. $100k, 4%, 30y -> $477/mo, but $65k, 8%, 30y -> $477/mo. This isn’t the full picture, obviously, but in this hypothetical example, both scenarios are more or less equally affordable. (Again, this example is just illustrative. I know people who bought in the 1980s and then refinanced in the 1990s, which ended up being a pretty sweet deal.)

Re:Paul Volcker has died by runako on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:32PM (#21745044)
Yes! Also, long-term owners who bought while rates were high stood to benefit greatly as interest rates came down and home prices rose accordingly. (In your example, your $65k @ 8% house becomes a $100k house where you've refinanced down to 4%.)
Re:Paul Volcker has died by spamizbad on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:52PM (#21745226)
Part of what drove housing price escalation was supply constraints. Housing starts tanked during the early 90s and climbed back out much slower. Lower interest rates opened up housing affordability to more people, but supply constraints kept prices high. So those who already had home equity were able to sell for a profit and buy bigger. New entrants weren't so lucky.
Re:Paul Volcker has died by api on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:48PM (#21745188)
The down payment is a function of the sale price, and that makes housing completely unthinkable to a lot of people in high price areas. They could afford the payment. Sometimes the payment would be lower than rent.

Going under 20% down results in poor loan terms and extra expenses like mortgage insurance that ruin the economics.

So high sticker prices on homes really do make them unaffordable to first time buyers who don't have family help or a very high income.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by autokad on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:06PM (#21745323)
mortgage insurance does suck, but it didn't ruin the economics for me, but I was lucky. When I bought with an FHA, if you got down to 20% by year 5, you could get rid of MIP. Now the rules are stupid, you are stuck with mortgage insurance for the life of the loan regardless, unless refi. That's just wrong
Re:Paul Volcker has died by whyhow on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:50PM (#21745201)
>You can already see that housing prices are inversely correlated with interest rates.

I do not think this is true. Everything I have seen shows that mortgage rates and house prices are positively correlated. Probably because they are both determined by the overall state of the economy.

When the economy is good, prices rise and interest rates rise. When the economy is bad, both fall.

Re:Paul Volcker has died by adventured on Monday December 09, 2019 @01:31PM (#21745036)
> I do wonder what will happen if mortgage rates return to even their pre-Volcker level, much less the 1980s levels

It's a scenario that can't occur as far as the Federal Government's solvency is concerned.

Just 5% on $50 trillion in public debt, 20 years out = fiscally say goodbye to the US military and Social Security (or say hello to the highest taxes on earth). Even 3.x% on $35 trillion in ~10 years starts to become a figure impossible to manage as it explodes the budget. You can plainly see the limits on where the Fed can allow rates to rise to.

Instead, the Fed and government's only option is to do everything possible to hold rates down forever. The Japan model reveals some of what the US is going to face, most likely. It's also why US growth keeps persistently sliding lower as we keep taking on more public debt, the debt is putting our productive capital into perma cold storage, robbing the economy of dynamism until we hit zero expansion. That debt will gradually yield less and less, we'll have $40+ trillion yielding 1.x% eventually. Effectively a massive pool of permanently dead wealth stripped out of the economy that will never be put to productive use; and that process of removing money from the economy simultaneously is what helps prevent traditional inflation from soaring despite the low rates. Picture reversing that and rapidly injecting that $40 trillion of dead capital back into the economy and see what would happen in terms of inflation for example.