News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @02:59PM (#21732235)
This article is misleading (full disclosure, I am French and did protest against this last Thursday)

This article talk mainly about "special pensions" from the public with privilege... For sure they will be the biggest losers and they are very vocal, but the law and the protest is about much more than that...

This reform will impact everybody, people will have to work longer, possibly to get a lower pension. Women are particularly exposed here.

Points system allows to more easily lower the value of the point... This has been done in Sweden, and former French Minister Filon told that is one main reason he likes the point system...

With this new reform, life expectancy are not taken into consideration : a manager will live longer than an industrial worker on average ; with the same share of contribution he will benefits from the system longer than "poor people" in general

People working longer means... a little bit more unemployment and more health expense for the workers (and more absenteeism for companies) as older worker have more health problem. So you save some money for retirement at the expense of other public spending...

Some economists, like Thomas Piketty are very vocal against this "law"...

It is a pity the NYT did such a poor job...

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by privateSFacct on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:27PM (#21732672)
SNCF (the rail company) is something like $45 Billion in debt?

Their conductors can retire using last 6 months of wages (vs avg wages)?

They can retire at 52? So payments will go to 82 (france has great life expectancy) That's 30 YEARS of pension payments!

They are guaranteed a job for life?

They get free / low cost housing?

They get 28 regular paid days off an maybe another 22 or so RTT days? (ie, 50 paid days off before any sick / unpaid etc).

Not bad!

These articles always start with a description of how hard the job is. In Europe they actually have great automated safety systems for trains and the trainsets are in good condition. I realize it's a hard job, but boy - my heart goes out to greyhound bus drivers in the US and many many other workers with no where NEAR these benefits and frankly much harder jobs.

The special pension folks are in the streets to protect their special pensions. Tie getting rid of the special pensions (which are often for the elites) with an increase to basic pension and social safety net for all?

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by einpoklum on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:56PM (#21732827)
> SNCF is something like $45 Billion in debt?

The state owns and controls the SNCF, its expenses, subsidies and pricing. Its debt is meaningless, in that the government decides how much in debt it is in.

> can retire using last 6 months of wages (vs avg wages)?

Retiring based on the status and position you've reached is common in many workplaces/industries, in many countries.

> They are guaranteed a job for life?

Nobody is guaranteed a job for life. If you mean to say, that if they do their job, the company can't fire them, then I don't see a problem with that.

> They get free / low cost housing?

They don't get free houses. Maybe they get free accommodations if their shifts take them far away from home; which would be reasonable.

> They get 28 regular paid days off an maybe another 22 or so RTT days?

Read about RTT days here: https://www.e-days.com/news/france-in-focus-understanding-di...

this is not special to railway conductors. The fact that in other countries people are being worked to the bone is the problem, not the fact that in France they aren't.

Also, RTT is a means to decrease unemployment by spreading work among more people. Saying it's excessive means essentially "let's pay the same thing to less people for more work".

Yes, the conditions are not bad; and people in the US should be inspired to organize, unionize - and not in those yellow collaborationist unions in the AFL-CIO, but in independent unions or in an IWW section, and demand decent, French-level employment conditions, at least.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by privateSFacct on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:31PM (#21733016)
> The state owns and controls the SNCF, its expenses, subsidies and pricing. Its debt is meaningless, in that the government decides how much in debt it is in.

The debt is a sign of the amount of additional subsidy needed to cover the benefits / expenses being paid. This amount (largish for France) will need to be paid by taxpayers. It is not meaningless.

> Retiring based on the status and position you've reached is common in many workplaces/industries, in many countries.

The french system normally pays based on a 25 year average pay (inflation adjusted)?Using most recent (highest paid) 6 months is not the same or standard. Can you name any other country that uses this method? Short periods like this are also prone to manipulation.

> If you mean to say, that if they do their job, the company can't fire them, then I don't see a problem with that.

The prohibition on layoffs consecutive to economic difficulties or technological changes is one of the benefits of the railway job - I'm just pointing that out. Other jobs even in france allows dismissal for economic reasons (if you offer employee modified job etc etc).

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by throwaway73629 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @06:24PM (#21733320)
> The french system normally pays based on a 25 year average pay (inflation adjusted)?Using most recent (highest paid) 6 months is not the same or standard.

I’m not sure “normally” is the right word here. The system in France is rather complicated. SNCF workers aren’t the only ones whose pension uses the last six months of income to determine the amount of the pension payment.

Under the current system:

Private sector salaried workers receive one pension where the calculation is based on their highest earning 25 years (adjusted for inflation). The calculation also takes into account the number of years worked in the private salaried worker sector. These workers may, depending on their job, also receive a second pension where the amount received is based on total points earned over all years worked (AGIRC - ARRCO).

Public sector workers receive a pension where the calculation is based on their last six months of earnings, as well as the number of years they worked in the public sector.

Self-employed workers pay into yet a number of different systems. I’m not familiar with all them, but many are based on total points earned over the years of contribution.

Finally, it’s possible for someone who’s worked at different times as a private salaried worker, a public sector worker, and a self-employed worker, to collect pensions from all the different sources.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by TulliusCicero on Saturday December 07, 2019 @06:16PM (#21733279)
> Retiring based on the status and position you've reached is common in many workplaces/industries, in many countries.

It's silly everywhere it exists. Why should a last year promotion change your retirement income so much?

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by privateSFacct on Saturday December 07, 2019 @08:36PM (#21733857)
Most places average over at least 3 years.

If you do a shorter period it's not uncommon for folks to pension spike. Do cash-outs / do bonuses for each other or temporary / activing director of positions that are empty but very high paying.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pension_spiking

The french system may prohibit these kind of raises and promotions in the last year of employment.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by TulliusCicero on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:59AM (#21735673)
That's still dumb though. Why should it be anything other than averaging over your whole career? What makes the last few years super special?
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by einpoklum on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:47PM (#21746370)
It's all "dumb". Why should a manager or an engineer get a higher salary than a warehouse employee who works his ass off all day? Why should younger workers get lower salaries than older workers just because they have less seniority? One could argue that it should be the other way around, since the younger ones are not established yet and have a lot more expenses.

The logic is that you retire with a pension corresponding to the level you've reached as an employee. It's not more or less dumb than averaging.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by user5994461 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:45PM (#21732769)
In short, yes to all except the free housing. Don't know the exact debt number but it's massive.

I doubt get they get free housing unless they're staying away from home (long distance train drivers). Noting pensions make no distinction between tubes, long distance train or administrative personnel.

Special pensions are not for the elites, quite the opposite, it's mostly for government-related entities (including railways, education, research centers, military, energy).

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by privateSFacct on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:35PM (#21733038)
Sorry - I meant elite workers! France has a three class system. Temporary workers and informal workers (sometimes terrible conditions), regular workers (state pension is not great, 50% of 25 year average), and workers with jobs that frankly ALREADY are better (railway admin jobs) AND that have the special pensions (crazy good). You could do accounting at the railway till 52 and then retire for 35 years! I love the idea - but not sure of the affordability.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:38PM (#21732741)
The protest is not about SNCF - they are only part of the pic. Let's talk about the pension reform in general, not about the SNCF (with some sloppy info btw)
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by user5994461 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:49PM (#21732790)
The protest is about all the special pensions, SNCF and the 50 other, they're all quite similar.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:06PM (#21732881)
I was in the protest with my friend entrepreneur, tour-guide, teacher, unemployed, artist-assistant and a bartender...

Special pension is only one point of many, and there are different ways to deal with it.

Note that for some special pension people pay more on their wages every month, and that special pension was also a way to stay attractive on the employment market with low salary...

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by privateSFacct on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:40PM (#21733070)
With formal youth unemployment at 20% or so, plenty of young folks would take some of these friends and family jobs and retire at 52 with a pension MUCH higher than most other french workers. There's already issues finding permanent employment in france with a temporary employment crisis.

https://www.ft.com/content/119c2b4c-bc0c-11e8-94b2-17176fbf9...

There is a reason you need to be on the inside track to get these "bad" jobs - because MANY folks would like them.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @06:07PM (#21733231)
That is why they can't recruit math teachers for example...
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by user5994461 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @06:33PM (#21733369)
There is no more shortage of math teachers than there is a shortage of developers.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @03:38PM (#21732403)
The European population is stagnating or shrinking so as a millennial I have little faith in ever receiving any pension when the time comes.

Whoever doesn't have a plan B (inheritance, properties for rent) will be super fucked.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @03:39PM (#21732413)
Automation, robots... Things are changing, so can the pension system... But this implies to share the value created by our society in a different way
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by ChuckNorris89 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @03:47PM (#21732451)
Except most of the profits from the productivity gains of automation have been going to off shore megacorp tax havens.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by olivermarks on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:11PM (#21732581)
Globalization has plateaued and to keep the money coming in the megacorps require austerity, which is essentially what the Gillet Jeunes and these strikes are protesting. The NYT piece is typical of the under reporting and spin put on this reality by the corporate media
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by PunchTornado on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:10PM (#21732578)
> People working longer means... a little bit more unemployment

this is not proved or true. society is not as simple as that.

they thought unemployment will drop if people worked only 35h a week, but it didn't.

why don't you accept that people have to work longer? the population is not booming anymore so you cannot accept future generations to pay.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by wazoox on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:27PM (#21732671)
In France, more than 60% of unemployed people over 58 stay unemployed until retirement. So pushing away the retirement date only worsen the situation. There are simply no jobs for the elderly.

Unemployment dropped dramatically thanks to the 35h work-week. They provably created at least 350000 jobs ( https://lexpansion.lexpress.fr/actualite-economique/les-35-h... ).

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by slooonz on Sunday December 08, 2019 @07:10AM (#21735511)
> Unemployment dropped dramatically thanks to the 35h work-week. They provably created at least 350000 jobs ( https://lexpansion.lexpress.fr/actualite-economique/les-35-h.... ).

Bullshit. You can find official unemployment figures here : https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/3676628?sommaire=369693.... 35h workweek has been voted in 2000 and started enforcement in 2002. Unemployment has increased uninterruptedly between 2001 and 2005. It decreased between 2000 and 2001, but it was part of a decreasing trend that started in 1997.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by user5994461 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:59PM (#21732843)
It's two fold, there is no work AND there is no point in working. If you get unemployed at 58, you get 2 years of unemployment benefits at almost full salary (was supposed to be reduced to 18 months earlier this year). If you have side income (rental properties bought long ago since you're 58) or some undeclared work on the side, you're golden.

That's not to diminish the issue of there are no jobs, it's a real problem, but there isn't any hurry to find or accept a job either.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:08PM (#21732889)
France lack 4 millions jobs at least... hurry to find or accept a job don't change this !
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by user5994461 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:30PM (#21733001)
Well, I left to London because I couldn't find a job in France, so too late for me ^^
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by PunchTornado on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:46PM (#21732773)
it dropped dramatically to ... still 10% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/35-hour_workweek many think that the 35h week had no impact on employment figures
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Sunday December 08, 2019 @06:03AM (#21735331)
Note that 35h did not applied to everyone, relabeled some paid break time as unpaid work time... Most importantly it was "sold" by allowing companies more flexibility with the workers... gain in productivity, more pressure (and a bit of more overtime) explain why the impact on unemployment had not been massive. This is totally different than what happen with pension scheme.

If people work more years, it means more people for the same "stock" of job at first... So more unemployment at least at short and medium term.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by einpoklum on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:58PM (#21732838)
Maybe the French don't under-count Employment like they do in many other countries; see:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unemployment#Alternatives

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by user5994461 on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:02PM (#21732860)
Rest assured, they undercount employment like every other country.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by sokoloff on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:26PM (#21732660)
As life expectancy increases, it seems eminently reasonable that a typical working career would be longer.

[1]-https://www.ined.fr/en/everything_about_population/graphs-ma...

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by wazoox on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:35PM (#21732721)
Life expectancy doesn't increase much; life expectancy in good health is decreasing, thanks to worsening work conditions.

Are you supposed to work with crutches, canes and walking frames?

In the meanwhile, during the past year the plutocrat class has seen its fortune soars immensely. This is revolting, this is a shame, and this has to stop. Now.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by sokoloff on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:51PM (#21732796)
Eyeballing the graph, it looks like it’s growing about 10 years every 30 or 40 years. That’s fast enough to put a drain on the system to pay for a decade longer of pension for the average participant.
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by Amezarak on Saturday December 07, 2019 @09:17PM (#21733983)
Almost all the gains in life expectancy are due to less children dying. Life expectancy for sixty year olds has increased by a single digit number of years in the past century and is stagnating or declining in most countries.

The argument that we have to work longer because of increased life expectancy is absolutely a rip-off. People who survived to retirement are not living much longer than they were a hundred years ago.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by sokoloff on Sunday December 08, 2019 @05:49AM (#21735292)
I see different data for France at least.

https://www.ined.fr/en/everything_about_population/data/fran...

Seems that life expectancy at age 65 has increased by about 1 year (a little over 5%) from 2008 to 2018. That 5% increase in pension coverage has to come from somewhere. It will come from reduced benefits, increased pension taxes for the working, and/or increased working times for the working.

There does appear to be some natural limit, but it does not seem that almost all gains are from a reduction in childhood mortality.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by wazoox on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:01PM (#21732855)
There is no such animal as an "average participant". For a start, a low-wage male worker has a life expectancy of 74 while his manager has a life expectancy of 84. Conveniently, the managers pension system have amassed a huge cash pile of 150 billions (that the government -- these evil bastards -- plan to snatch away instead of spending it to pay pensions for the poor and the sick).
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:46PM (#21732772)
Why ? As automation and robotization increase it seems eminently reasonable that a typical working career would be smaller (working less every week, or less years "full time")
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by PunchTornado on Saturday December 07, 2019 @09:01PM (#21733936)
where is this automation and robotization? because I see it only in the news and from Elon Musk who was saying 5 years ago than in 2 years self driving cars will be everywhere.

we don't even have robots that can clean a carpet properly in my house. each one of them sucks.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by lightgreen on Sunday December 08, 2019 @02:41AM (#21734784)
Uber is an example of automation and robotization: taxi company phone operator is replaced by mobile app.

Ticket machine at the train station is an another example of automation and robotization.

Online courses instead of teachers, classes and books is also an example.

Computerized air traffic control is also it.

Trains using rails more efficiently because computers instead of signals for humans is also it.

Bike and scooter rental in many cities with mobile app instead of taxis and bike renting human services is it.

Software (instead of a manager) which decides how many apples, bananas and peaches this particular grocery store needs today is automation and robotization.

And so on.

Automation and robotization doesn’t necessarily mean human-like robots doing housekeeping.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by PunchTornado on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @11:21AM (#21753850)
those are small examples with a few thousands job loses. they're already here and you can't see an impact in unemployment because of them. + I'm sure they actually created some jobs in IT.

I'm talking about massive job loses because of automatization. Nothing like that happened or is on the horizont.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by XMPPwocky on Saturday December 07, 2019 @10:20PM (#21734158)
> we don't even have robots that can clean a carpet properly in my house.

Have you got a vacuum cleaner?

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:25PM (#21732656)
"why don't you accept that people have to work longer? the population is not booming anymore so you cannot accept future generations to pay. "

Well that is a political choice. There are option possible where we don't work longer, and option where we work longer. According to the option money and worked are not shared in the same way.

Both option are possible - e.g. different economist have different personal preference.

The only think we have to is to have a debate, and a democratic decision.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by PunchTornado on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:48PM (#21732782)
and will a democratic debate be achieved by mass protests in the street OR by elections? And Macron is an elected president.

Instead of seeing who screams harder and who throws the bigger stones, lets see which politician is elected by the majority of French people.

Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:16PM (#21732932)
Debate and a referendum would be the democratic way.

Current French Republic was dubbed "presidential monarchy" (in no other democracy a single person had this level of power)... Since 2002 French President has even more power... And now with the extreme-right, who does not lose the first round of the presidential election (aside of extreme-right) win.

Macron had been elected by 18% of voters, and have "full powers" for 5 years

I personally don't think it is super democratic

[dead]
Re:French Strike Aims to Save an Envied, but Convoluted, App... by skitout on Saturday December 07, 2019 @04:28PM (#21732674)
Not saying he is god. Just saying that different people, including well-know experts, has different opinions... and that this article is misleading.