This is more like CAT refusing to sell road construction equipment to the highway department in the PRC.
The only thing the cancelation of this contract will do is make those within GitHub who are dissatisfied feel better that they have "done something". It actually accomplishes very little, and I would argue nothing at all.
https://www.hrw.org/news/2004/11/21/israel-caterpillar-shoul...
Yes, I am not from US so I have very little understanding of ICE other than a few policy problems on the surface.
Since it would achieve very little, but wouldn't it be better to actually have the contract and has all its profits funded to an organisation against ICE?
After all it is not that ICE in itself that is wrong, it is the policy maker or the government. ( Forgive me if this is not correct )
Funding a political side that abolish ICE, wouldn't that be better?
ICE was less of an issue under the previous administration.
All this energy and effort would be better spent on getting the current admin out. It is how things work in our top down democracy. The problem is that the votes of most Bay Area companies are going toward people who already align with these goals.
TO that end the effort could be better spent on contributing TO organizations that will help advocate for the changes they want. That might be money or time or technical talent...
For what it's worth, getting the Republicans out is almost certainly what this stunt is about. Maybe not consciously, but the groundwork of propaganda that led to villainization of ICE is certainly oriented around combating Trump and his policies, not actually disbanding ICE. Something like this is a way to help supporters feel engaged, passionate, and committed to the left's immigration policies (or at least attacking the right's), so that they will be more likely to vote and vote favorably in the next election.
Breaking up a contract like this won't directly accomplish any other realistic political goals.
CAT should refuse to do business with organizations that operate concentration camps, including ICE and the CCP.
Except politically, of course, which is why terms like that are abused so often.
It then quotes The American Heritage Dictionary's definition of concentration camp as: "A camp where persons are confined, usually without hearings and typically under harsh conditions, often as a result of their membership in a group which the government has identified as dangerous or undesirable."
Ergo, prisons which only contain people who have been convicted in a trial or agreed to a plea bargain cannot be regarded as concentration camps.
By comparison, the US held Japanese Americans in concentration camps during WWII, and held Filipino civilians in concentration camps ("reconcentrados") during the Philippine–American War. These can be distinguished from prisons as there was no trial for those held.
As I understand it, if the people being held at ICE are asylum seekers, then entry into the US is not illegal (even if they are not granted asylum). The US instead argues that they can be detained until that process is finished, even if that is indefinite.
This certainly sounds a lot closer to the definition of a concentration camp than US prisons containing prisoners who have be convicted in a court process.
In any case, we're talking about people in an organization which argued that the requirement for "safe and sanitary" conditions was so vague that it was okay to refuse toothbrushes, soap or adequate bedding to children.
Are all US juvenile prisons the same way? No. The 'typically under harsh conditions' is yet another distinction between "concentration camp" and "prison".
That said, many US jails and prisons are horrid, inhumane places.
"No one truly knows a nation until one has been inside its jails. A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens but its lowest ones." - Nelson Mandela in Long Walk to Freedom.
As for the harsh conditions, I completely agree they should be improved. But that would require funding that the Democrats refuse to provide, and services from other companies that Democrats like these activists are trying to block.
How many prisons are there where the people in detention are free to leave?
That is, isn't your current statement at odds with your previous statement?
Were the Japanese-Americans in the American West during WWII free to leave, and if so, what would happen if they were found in the exclusion zone? That is, do you think those were internment camps?
Not at all. As you've correctly shown, prisons are closer to being concentration camps than ICE detention facilities are. Therefore, if you move the definition far enough to include ICE facilities, you also include prisons.
Again I ask, were Japanese-Americans in the American West held in concentration camps during WWII, or not?
Many of the Japanese-Americans who were there have long fought to have those facilities (correctly, IMO) recognized as concentration camps, and high-level officials at the time, including Roosevelt, referred to them as concentration camps. Do you disagree with them?
Were the Japanese-Americans in the American West during WWII free to leave those facilities, and if so, what would happen if they were found in the exclusion zone?
What does it have to do with ICE detention facilities?
I pointed out that your own statements contradict your own conclusion, in that at least some prisons in the US 1) contain only people who have gone through the court system are the result of a crime, and not merely waiting for a hearing, 2) are not in harsh conditions.
I also pointed out that to many Japanese-Americans held in concentration camps in the American West during WWII, that to them "concentration camp" is a very important term.
Do you agree that those Japanese-Americans were in concentration camps?
If you agree, then why are the ICE detention facilities not concentration camps?
If you disagree, then why weren't they concentration camps, and why did high-level US officials at the time regard them as concentration camps in internal use, while officially avoided that term?
This is not true.
I looked into it. It seems that crossing the border not at a port of entry is a misdemeanor offense and typically results in "only" a few days in jail.
I was confusing that with the US law which says that the asylum process does not require entry at a designated port of arrival.
> Any alien who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the United States (whether or not at a designated port of arrival and including an alien who is brought to the United States after having been interdicted in international or United States waters), irrespective of such alien's status, may apply for asylum in accordance with this section or, where applicable, section 1225(b) of this title. - https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid%3AUSC-prel...
Since the people are being held for more than a few days, and not as a result of a judgement or plea bargain done over a misdemeanor offense, then "illegal" in the context seems more like a red herring. It's like saying that most people are illegal drivers, because few have never exceeded the speed limit.
https://www.nybooks.com/daily/2019/07/01/an-open-letter-to-t...
ICE detention is just plainly that, and that's all. Some conditions are poor because facilities are overflowing, not because they are designed that way. Most migrants are economic in nature, there's no pressing need for them to try to cross, and they know it's illegal - moreover - all of those economic migrants clog up the system to the detriment of actual refugees.
Of course, the migrants can leave any time - there's a policy in place such that they can chose to return home without having any mark on their record with respect to future ability to migrate to the US, and it's processed generally quickly, within several days.
There is really no comparison at all between those detained trying to enter a country, and 'concentration camps' - in terms of motivations, lawfulness, conditions, effects, legal recourse, fallout, etc. - they are in every way different.
The PRC camps in China could be referred to as 'concentration camps' because people are arbitrary detained on the basis of their culture, for any duration, they don't have legal recourse, they cannot leave, there is no judicial oversight, there is no freedom of information or freedom of press, they are not allowed any contact with the outside world, and they are put through some very aggressive 'thought control' programs that in many ways is worse than physical torture or confinement. To boot, the system itself is corrupt and prisoners organs are being sold through irregular channels.
- The Intercept published a report by the DHS Office of Inspector General revealing that 1,224 sexual abuse complaints while in immigration custody were filed between January 2010 and June 2017.
-As part of the 2018 Trump administration's zero tolerance policy, nearly 3,000 minors were separated from their parents, or the adults accompanying them
- From 2012 to early 2018, ICE wrongfully arrested and detained 1,488 U.S. citizens, including many who spent months or years in immigration detention.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U.S._Immigration_and_Customs_E...
As for protests "doing something" they absolutely do in this case,as github is only valuable for Microsoft so long as they acquire and grow a base of developers to use it. The brand already excludes several foreign nations, likely as part of a policy by Redmond to court the present administration. Their failure to maintain an ICE contract without an exodus of developers would slowly turn their newly acquired developer website into a 21st century hotmail.
Github isnt the only player in this field, no matter how badly theyd like developers to think this. Gogs, Gitea, and gitlab especially are all equally suited to quickly and effectively fill any gap Github might present. Most have auto-migration features to quickly ferry code away from Github.
Any data on what the rate post-Trump has been? Or during the Bush years? Because it's hard to reason from this alone.
(Not to mention that the rate of complaints is influenced by a whole bunch of factors other than the rate of incidents - for instance taking complaints seriously might make the number of complaints go up relative to ignoring them or retaliating against the complainants, and rewarding people for making complaints would likely increase the false complaint rate. What we care about is the number of actual incidents, but that's really hard to determine with any level of validity)
Of course, it's not...
> Boycotts, strikes, sabotage, sit-ins, work slowdowns, etc has all been used to pressure companies to take actions because of political reasons.
As long as I'm getting downvotes, I might as well add: These actions are usually done to achieve a realistic goal, not simply to punish a company for doing business with your own government because it's currently controlled by the opposition party.
It's not because it's controlled by the opposition party, it's because it's doing something we believe is immoral. The distinction is important.
it's doing something we believe is immoral
These deeds and these contract precede this administration, but there were no such efforts then.There was no broad knowledge of it too.
There was no broad knowledge of it
Now, ask yourself why you were unaware of it, bearing in mind what your choices of news/information were at the time.On the other hand, is it appropriate for GitHub to fire said employees, or perhaps press charges in the case of illegal activity?
When they have good enough reason to believe that breaking up the contract will achieve a positive end that is worth the violation of freedom of association and precedence for using coercive, destructive and potentially illegal methods.
In this case, I don't think any of the activists can really articulate the goal they think would be reasonably achieved, beyond having a vague personal feeling of satisfaction for making ICE's job harder and punishing their employer for doing something they didn't like. In fact, it seems to me as if temporarily crippling ICE's software development workflow is not likely to improve the situation on the ground for migrants at all.
Fair enough. So the goalpost is moved back a bit as to whether or not the U.S. government is morally reprehensible in enforcing border security just as all other governments do.
I take issue with this, as the manner in which other state actors enforce their border security do not all involve similar cruelty to the particular manner in which ICE enforces border security.
But they're in bad shape because Democrats refuse to fund them. What share of the blame do you allocate to the Democrats for that?
Edit: Downvote away, if you want to bury the truth, but this is a fact. Democrats are limiting the number of beds in ICE facilities, causing overcrowding, in a misguided attempt to stop immigration enforcement.
https://www.npr.org/2019/02/11/693460861/ice-detention-beds-...
But how much do you blame the far-left Democrats, who want exactly the same open borders policy you want, for the predicable consequences of their policy of defunding ICE?
And if these activists succeed in blocking ICE's contract with GitHub, and that causes even worse conditions, will you also blame these activists for that?
When your boss tells you "do X" and you don't agree with it you have choices. Do it, or don't do it and face the consequences.
There are very few people in ICE who can actually make this sort of decision and not risk consequences. Most of the people who COULD set this sort of policy are politically appointed, they aren't the (more or less) apolitical staffers who simply do as they are told (assuming it is respectful of the law).
> After all, that is clearly the intent of Congress
The intent of congress and the president interpreted by the courts, NOT individual ice agents, or for that matter you or I.
> whose duty it is to set policy priorities via budgetary allocations.
Again, that isn't how it works. Budget can be guiding but it is not always absolute, and sometimes it is (earmarks, pork) but in this case the "cut" isn't a "removal of the underlying law that is to be enforced".
Congress is divided. Democrats only have the power to block funding, because it's easier to block legislation than to enact it.
> sabotage
Not sure about this one, this sounds a tad illegal
If one were to make this level of sacrifice would it be at an ICE office, or the Whitehouse? Where would the protest be more effective?
People have been getting arrested dismantling US war machinery for decades, etc.
I'm not saying it's legal, I'm not even commenting on whether I agree, I'm just saying the "it's not appropriate to pressure a company for political views, companies should be off limits from politics" doesn't hold water.
You haven't actually presented a supporting argument for it, though.
What exactly is the problem with applying pressure to get a corporation to stop taking money from an organization/corporation/government/person that you find immoral?
You are interfering with their freedom of association. You must weigh the morality of that violation vs what you hope to gain. It's not an obvious answer and is why the example of Boeing selling bombers actively being used to bomb civilians is misleading and why I objected to it.
A corporation has no inherent "freedom of association." A corporation has exactly what rights we choose to give it, because it is fundamentally a legal fiction - the concept of a "corporate person" is useful for legal reasons, so we create such a thing in our laws. But it only has the rights we ascribe to it, because it isn't an actual being.
With that in mind: we've given corporations no "freedom of association." But even if we accepted your claim here - how does "pressuring a company to drop a contract" violate its supposed "freedom of association?"
"Freedom of association" is not freedom from consequences. "Freedom of association" means "you may associate with whomever you please and the government may not interfere". It does not mean "you may associate with whomever you please and no one may protest."
Your attempts at refutation are all general and fail to address the critical equation.
It makes sense that you don't think my refutations are valid: I fundamentally disagree with your underlying premise that a corporation has any rights beyond the limited ones explicitly assigned in various bodies of law. And I specifically disagree that a corporation has a "freedom of association" or a "freedom to do business."
So of course I'm not engaging with your question of "is whether a corporation's freedom to do business is worth more than stopping the action you consider immoral". Why would I? I disagree with the whole, underlying, fundamental premise of your question. A company has no freedom of association! It has no freedom to do business! These things do not exist, so refuting your question is impossible!
(And, setting aside the whole absurdity of the central question: even if companies had these rights as you claim, how on earth would a letter from concerned developers infringe upon those rights? It's patently absurd to think that a group of customers sending a letter to a company somehow infringes upon its rights, unless you think that these "rights" entail freedom to do business without any criticism or bad press whatsoever)
Can you explain to me how does people pressuring them to stop a contract affect their freedom to do business? This is a free market, Github can still do business with ICE, they just know that people won't share that same view and that theses peoples may move their business elsewhere.
Let say there's 2 business that sell chocolate, you want to buy chocolate. One is 1$ cheaper, but they kill a kittens for each purchase. Is it wrong to go buy the one that doesn't kill kittens because for you it infringe on their freedom to do business?
I would, for example, expect climate change activists to start actively interfering with shipping logistics (the ILWU has long used pressure at ports for political goals) causing the possibilities of large amounts of economic costs across entire industries if there isn't significant movement towards addressing their goals.
Uh, no.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-saudi-security/obama-...
It is the populist left and populist right.
If it was Boeing providing bombers to the PRC to use against civilian populations, many people inside and outside of Boeing would be pressuring that contract to be cancelled.
What exactly is the problem with applying pressure to get a corporation to stop taking money from an organization/corporation/government/person that you find immoral?
The company doesn't have to /care/. The company can go after their almighty dollars for their shareholder if they want. And people can then choose to target that company in different ways, or target other companies that do business with that company, etc.
Boycotts, strikes, sabotage, sit-ins, work slowdowns, etc has all been used to pressure companies to take actions because of political reasons.