Why do so many people think that human rights flow from US citizenship? That's not how the Constitution works. The 4th Amendment to the Constitution doesn't say anything about citizenship:
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.
The Bill of Rights is a set of limitations on the government, saying that the government is not allowed to do these things. It doesn't say anything about who they might hypothetically be doing them to, just that they cannot do it.
So regardless of your citizenship, the government can't prevent you from practicing your religion, can't throw you in jail without a trial, and they can't search you without a warrant. This applies to any actions the US government takes, regardless of who they're directed against and where.
It is true you don't need to be a US citizen to have protection. However, you do need to be under the jurisdiction of the US (on US soil). Otherwise, the US Constitutional rights don't apply to you.
Therefore, using it as a argument for why due process is only restricted to a certain group is a bit of a non-sequitur. A case against a foreign person still has to be conducted through proper channels, either with Constitutional protections in force if the U.S. has ultimate jurisdiction, or through diplomatic channels to ensure conformance with whatever other country considers due process or actionable if the U.S. doesn't have ultimate jurisdiction. This doesn't really negate the GP's point in the way you may have been intending to.
While the government technically isn't allowed to do some of these things, the way our judicial system works, there's no lever with which these can be stopped (other than at the ballot box, and it seems no one cares enough to vote based on this). In particular, what little controversy there was surrounding the Edward Snowden revelations showed us that the Courts don't recognize any of us as having standing to pursue the question in court.
See also FISA.
I don't buy that, but there you go. It just goes to show that the people (whoever they might be) need to be continually vigilant - in a sense, government is always the adversary.
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."
Are you saying that the US congress has the legal authority to collect income taxes from every human on earth?
The US went through a judicial process and didn't just imprison or delete this person's account ( I know this isn't a US national), but this is a false equivalency to say that this process is even close to China when China currently has over a million prisoners in concentration camps.
If you'd like to understand the integrity of the US process, please read The New Jim Crow. It's not at all clear the US process is better than China's.
Yes..just last week I was stopped outside Pennsylvania Avenue and forced to install a government mandated app on my phone and submit a DNA sample...
The argument is that the US justice system uses pressure of plea bargains to put millions of innocent people in prison, financial pressure to keep millions of people from getting justice, etc.
The level of injustice seems at least similar.
You're right the reasons are different. But until we fix our courts, we don't quite have the moral high ground here.
Plus gitmo.
Journalists investigating the suppression of Falun Gong estimated that approximately 60,000 convicted members were executed and their organs harvested. People are routinely arrested and never heard from again. In some cases families have been told a relative was executed years previously, but often they hear nothing at all.
In 2008 China's own deputy health minister estimated over 60% of transplant organs were sourced from prisoners, but Chinese officials have clamped up about this in recent years. They have occasionally said that this source of organs has been excluded, but there's no way to verify this as rates of donor registration aren't known, rates of executions are a state secret and none of the people or facilities involved are known or open to investigations.
So yes, sure, just like the USA.
> In 2014, former CIA and NSA director Michael Hayden said in a public debate, “We kill people based on metadata.”
> According to multiple reports and leaks, death-by-metadata could be triggered, without even knowing the target’s name, if too many derogatory checks appear on their profile. “Armed military aged males” exhibiting suspicious behavior in the wrong place can become targets, as can someone “seen to be giving out orders.” Such mathematics-based assassinations have come to be known as “signature strikes.”
https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-features/how-...
Certainly there's no rule that during war one has to know the name of someone before killing them.
We are entering a new era and no one knows what the rules are.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1018646
https://www.forbes.com/sites/zakdoffman/2019/11/16/china-cov...
https://www.foxnews.com/world/organ-harvesting-china-survivo...
https://nypost.com/2019/06/23/the-ugly-truth-about-chinas-or...
https://qz.com/1717338/china-accused-of-harvesting-organs-fr...
https://www.chinaorganharvest.org/
https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/the-nightmare-of-human-orga...
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-rights-organ-harves...
All I can see are extreme news sources (Breitbart) and NBC reporting on https://chinatribunal.com, and while I know nothing about the chinatribunal, its name somewhat implies a clear stance at the outset.
Particularly in relation to the Uyghur muslims, I can't find any evidence that they're having their organs harvested
It's about the Fulan Gong movement, FWIW.
I find the fact that the media doesn’t report this, but they do report the re-education camps, suggests the sources aren’t very solid.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Organ_harvesting_from_Falun_...
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna1018646
https://www.forbes.com/sites/zakdoffman/2019/11/16/china-cov...
https://www.foxnews.com/world/organ-harvesting-china-survivo...
https://nypost.com/2019/06/23/the-ugly-truth-about-chinas-or...
https://qz.com/1717338/china-accused-of-harvesting-organs-fr...
https://www.chinaorganharvest.org/
https://www.wsj.com/amp/articles/the-nightmare-of-human-orga...
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-china-rights-organ-harves...
Contrast that situation to China. China has over 1 million Uyghur Muslims in concentration camps for non-criminal, political reasons. Most (if not all) of the said Uyghur people imprisoned were given no judicial review, and have no access to legal counsel.
God damn I hate the whataboutism on HN I see with regards to China - it is really rampant. It may shatter some folks' liberal sentiments but the US really is not the worst country on the block (planet), by a long-long margin.
I'll assume you're exaggerating for effect, but please don't do that.
"I think this is horrible" [maybe I don't agree but it's a valid opinion]
"The US is as totalitarian as China" [ok, this person doesn't know what they are talking about]
This is not true, the warrant served would absolutely have to be signed under a finding of probable cause.
I believe the GP is saying they don't believe the probable cause was valid, not that no probable cause was given.
No, but who would that be and how is it related to your points about the US?
They weren't a US citizen they where Australian so the judge didn't need probable cause.
It is perfectly legal and that should make any foreigner question their relationship with America.
Do we really want an ally that has proven them selves as totalitarian as China and is determined to spy on us?