News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by classichasclass on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:43PM (#21685376)
Not that there's any moral equivalence, but when I'm in Australia visiting in-laws, I have to provide my passport or similar ID to get my PAYG SIM activated. I just have them swipe it at the airport and my SIM is on in 10 minutes. My wife admits it's a lot easier in the States to get a PAYG SIM; AT&T doesn't care who she is as long as there's money in the account.

I'm not sure why Australia does that, but it's really annoying.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by grecy on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:08PM (#21685672)
I just drove around Africa, and I bought a pre-paid SIM in about 30 different countries. Every single one of them required a copy of my passport.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by sudosysgen on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:39PM (#21686002)
In Morocco at least they do ask for your passport if you want free or discounted cell service, but you can always go to a corner store and just get a Sim card from there.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by grecy on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:18PM (#21686416)
Sure, and it stops working a few days later. I had that happen a few times, then stopped buying SIM cards from random people on the street (or corner stores) and so would go into the actual carrier store (MTN or whatever)
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by sudosysgen on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:42PM (#21689734)
Well, at least in Morocco when I lived there I got my SIM card from the corner store and used it for a good year and a half.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by antpls on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:33PM (#21685943)
In Africa, aren't phone often used to make financial transactions ? It would make sense to have a bit more security in that case, maybe
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by dbspin on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:13PM (#21685729)
Interesting. Absolutely not needed in Ireland.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by aplummer on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:44PM (#21685384)
It's to track crimes associated with burner sims.

* Not trying to justify it either direction.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by vbezhenar on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:51PM (#21687407)
I wonder does it help? I'm sure that it's easy to find some homeless person, who don't know you and register SIM for his ID.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by nl on Monday December 02, 2019 @05:53PM (#21687948)
It helps a lot.

It isn't for tracking homeless people. It's for building network graphs of calls from burner phones to organised crime people.

Most of the time the burners are useless, but once you have a cluster of them you can automatically do data matching on them all, and sometimes (often!) they got lazy on a couple and used the same identities to buy them.

Once you have a few using the same identity then you track that identity down.

The friction in forcing identification means that lazy criminals at the bottom of the structure at some point forget to do it.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by skissane on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:28PM (#21686514)
> I'm not sure why Australia does that, but it's really annoying.

Suppose you buy a PAYG SIM, and then use it to make death threats or bomb hoax calls. Easy for the police to track you down and arrest you. (Of course, they still could using other means, like geolocation, but that could be a lot more work.)

And, of course, it isn't foolproof – one could use a fake ID, one could pay some random poor person to buy it for you using their ID, etc – but, the kind of people who make death threats or bomb hoaxes usually aren't very smart.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by eastendguy on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:50PM (#21686739)
Showing a password vs getting your face scans taken and stored in a gigantic face recognition library is a gigantic difference. Once the state has your biometrics stored, you can be ID'ed without you noticing, e. g. as you walk around the city.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by owenmarshall on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:01PM (#21686880)
Australia - like many countries - collects fingerprints and photographs from certain groups either when you get your visa or when you enter the country. And I’d be shocked if their entry systems don’t capture 100% of passport photos at the border. I’d be slightly surprised if they don’t additionally correlate passport scans to security photos at the border to further enrich their dataset.

Showing your passport is functionally equivalent to getting your picture taken. It ends up as a record in their databases that says John Smith, with these biometrics, purchased a SIM with this number.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by deogeo on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:49PM (#21685451)
There absolutely is moral equivalence - they're trying to cut off all means of anonymous communication. It's difficult to get a SIM without providing ID in the EU as well, and you have to provide ID when renting a room. I wish the media were always sensitive to privacy erosion, not just when China does it.

I guess using Chinese surveillance tech is a roundabout way of getting them to pay attention, as happened with the Hikvision cameras.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by mytailorisrich on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:21PM (#21685821)
Having a requirement to link a SIM to an individual is not privacy erosion.

It does not mean that usage is monitored, and usage is the important privacy aspect.

Furthermore, this just puts mobile phones on par with landlines. It used to be that having a phone meant having a landline at home, and obviously that meant knowing exactly who a number belonged to.

There needs to be a balance for everything in the real world. And even most Western countries have concluded that requiring IDs for SIM cards is a necessary measure.

Now, for Chinese authorities one issue (without even going into politics) is that China is a very low trust society where it is almost expected that everyone will flaunt the rules at the first opportunity. So I am half guessing that the government sees technological solutions as a way around that.

(As for renting a room, it would be crazy for a landlord not to know who their tenant is just for practical reasons considering land and tenancy laws in most EU countries)

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by jen20 on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:39PM (#21686000)
> It does not mean that usage is monitored, and usage is the important privacy aspect.

I think one would have to be especially naive to believe that an ID requirement is in place without any provision for usage monitoring.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by mytailorisrich on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:43PM (#21686042)
Do you think someone is monitoring your landline?
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by vbezhenar on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:54PM (#21687444)
It's incredibly easy nowadays. Compressed voice takes very little to archive. Speech recognition allows to index everything. I don't believe that every government does not do this.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by CamperBob2 on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:45PM (#21686692)
Well, we've been assured by the likes of James Clapper that no one is listening, so...
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by deogeo on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:52PM (#21686147)
This has been known for a fact for the last 13 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A

Edit: Downvotes for a factual answer? Pathetic.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by StanislavPetrov on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:50PM (#21686124)
It is absolutely beyond dispute that all communications are being monitored at all times by a variety of government and non-governmental agencies. Being forced to link your identity to these communications is yet another step down towards absolute tyranny (and we are already near the bottom step).
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by CamperBob2 on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:46PM (#21686706)
It's not necessarily a step towards tyranny in itself... but when tyranny does come, it will make life very easy for the tyrants.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by throw476543 on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:34PM (#21685951)
I feel anonymity is a part of privacy, and anything that limits anonymity also affects privacy.
Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by gruez on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:04PM (#21686269)
>Furthermore, this just puts mobile phones on par with landlines. It used to be that having a phone meant having a landline at home, and obviously that meant knowing exactly who a number belonged to.

Not really. Unless you lived alone, a landline was often shared with everyone in the household. Furthermore, just because there is a link (by necessity of delivering a service to a physical location), doesn't mean there needs to be a link.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by deogeo on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:50PM (#21686122)
> And even most Western countries have concluded that requiring IDs for SIM cards is a necessary measure.

> (As for renting a room, it would be crazy for a landlord not to know who their tenant is just for practical reasons considering land and tenancy laws in most EU countries)

That's circular reasoning, and could be applied to any law.

Edit: How it's circular reasoning:

"The law is necessary because it has been enacted."

"It's necessary to collect ID when renting a room, because the law requires it."

As for how "most Western countries determined it was necessary" - there weren't exactly large, public debates and demands as happened for e.g. gay rights, were there? The laws just came about, very discreetly.

Edit2, due to posting limit: I did no conflating - my point applies to both your statements, separately.

Re:Chinese telecoms must use "AI and other technical means" ... by mytailorisrich on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:53PM (#21686157)
How is that circular reasoning?

Edit: I have seen your edit.

I did not write that. You are conflating 2 unrelated topics and 2 unrelated parts of my comment although they were clearly separated.

In many countries IDs are not required by law in order to rent a house (afaik). In the UK (which I know most) it only became a requirement a couple of years ago, specifically to check that the prospective tenant was not an illegal immigrant (in fact the requirement is not to check IDs but not to rent to illegal immigrants...)

Landlords require an ID quite independently of any legal requirement because it does not make sense to entrust a real property to someone if you do not know who they are due to the financial liability and the legal procedures required to evict.

In some commercial and legal relations it simply does make sense to assert the identity of the other party.