News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:07AM (#21682952)
Ask Venezuela or Iraq or Iran or Hong Kong or basically any of the countries in the Arab spring how it’s going for them right now.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by snowwrestler on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:58PM (#21684873)
Are you arguing that people in the U.S. should have guns so that they can shoot at U.S. police and military if they disagree with a government policy?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:24PM (#21685854)
Yes, depending on the government policy, that is precisely what I'm arguing.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:40PM (#21686011)
It's a fantasy Americans seem to uniquely believe in that arming the populace is a good deterrent against bad government policy.

If it actually worked, one would expect the US to be two separate nations now. After all, what was the Civil War if not a mass of Americans deciding extra-legally that the laws should not apply to them and taking up arms to break free of government oppression and form a government more inclined to protect their freedoms?

And yet, after a bloody conflict that claimed more American lives than World War II, the country is still one nation and Americans still cling to a strange belief that private gun ownership protects against tyranny (as if a tyrant wouldn't bring their own guns to bear against the citizenry, like Sherman burning towns south of the Mason-Dixon to hamstring the morale of the rebels).

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:48PM (#21686729)
It's not perfect. But what it means is that if you're going to impose a policy that unpopular on half the population, you may have to go as far as the Civil War did, including accepting that many of your own people dying. That's... somewhat daunting.

And a tyrant, while perfectly willing to bring their own guns to turn on citizens, would have a military that might not be willing, especially if they didn't agree with the tyrant. (The Civil War wasn't just the US army against the citizens of the south. It was the army members from the south against the army members from the north.)

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:51PM (#21687408)
It's far from perfect. It demands a tax in blood during peacetime as a faulty guard against tyranny in time of civil war (to say nothing of the fact that---as the Civil War indicates---there's no particular guarantee that the armed civilians will be defending particularly virtuous rights against government interference; it was, after all, the state's rights to nullify laws curtailing slavery that was the crux of the conflict).
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by asdff on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:07AM (#21690965)
You think your AR 15 is going to stop a guided missile launched by an 18 year old with a joystick on a destroyer in the middle of the Atlantic? I think we've all played the AC-130 mission in Call of Duty by now. We are way past the days of a militia dealing with the U.S. government.

But back in 1776 when you and uncle sam had the exact same musket, sure, that was the last chance.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:24AM (#21692028)
Yeah, probably best to just surrender your weapons and pray for mercy.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:57AM (#21692243)
Instead of praying for mercy, Americans can vote for good leadership, be active in their local, state, and federal government, hold each other accountable, and take responsibility for living in a representative democracy.

It is, ultimately, these things that make for a free and stable society, not the proliferation of firearms. When you elect a tyrant, all the private firearms do is ramp up the bloodshed the tyrant will bring.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:45PM (#21695255)
If only democracies could be trusted to not elect tyrants. Unfortunately, there are many, many examples to the contrary. That fact was one of the primary motivators for the Bill of Rights. You are right that there would be bloodshed when facing a tyrant (certainly more than if there were no way to fight back). In my mind, better that than the gas chambers. Let’s not forget that Hitler came into power by popular vote.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:25PM (#21695685)
I've heard argumentum-ad-Hitler used as an example of why private citizens should be armed.

What I've never heard is a strong argument that a German citizenry armed as the US is armed now wouldn't have simply resulted in faster, gas-chamber-free deaths of minorities in Germany and German-occupied territories, as the government in charge gave quiet assent to extra-legal killings enacted by private citizens against "undesirables" and the citizenry bought into the mythology of the ubermensch.

After all, the hypothesis of the equalizing effect of private firepower assumes that "good guys" have the guns.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:42PM (#21695874)
I think that both having guns makes it marginally less likely that either shoots. That applies at both the micro and macro scale.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:56PM (#21696041)
Then given the proliferation of firearms in the US, the firearm-related homicide and injury rates should be lower than in countries that ban firearms (not absolute instances; lower rates, if more guns makes it marginally less likely that any party shoots).

They are not.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:08PM (#21697338)
In most (nearly all?) circumstances, one party is not armed.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:13PM (#21697386)
Then at what ratio of armed citizens do the benefits you anticipate kick in? 60%? 80%? Should we all expect to show up to church strapped with a 9mm, just in case?

Can you provide an example of a country where such a high ratio of armed citizenry has worked out well? There should be a positive example we can turn to. The US isn't it by the numbers.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @09:51PM (#21699190)
I never claimed gun ownership reduced gun violence overall, but excluding suicide it doesn’t seem to increase it either.[1] At the macro scale, I only mean to say it makes hostile government action less likely. Likewise, at the micro scale, I only mean to say violent confrontation between individuals is less likely when both parties are armed than when only one is armed. This much to me seems self evident (and underpins the macro thesis as well). At the micro scale, I might agree that there would be less gun violence if neither party were armed, but mass confiscation will never happen in the US. It would be ineffective given the lack of a central registry and it would likely incite civil war. In that light, even barring the macro thesis, it strikes me as prudent to be among the armed. With, of course, basic safety training.

[1]https://medium.com/handwaving-freakoutery/everybodys-lying-a...

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:14AM (#21702807)
I don't actually think mass confiscation would be necessary. Offer nationwide buyback and severely curtail manufacture and first-sale, and the equations change wildly. America is hyper-capitalist and capitalist incentives tend to work on people.

It's win-win; those who want their guns more than the money can keep their guns.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:13AM (#21683022)
Can we can also ask Denmark, Sweden, Germany, or other European countries that tend to be considered the US's economic and cultural peers?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:35AM (#21683246)
Sure, but I'm not sure the answer would be relevant. As an analogy, just because you haven't used your first aid kit doesn't mean you won't one day need it. To the contrary, we have many examples of countries that left the first aid kit behind only to realize they desperately needed it.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:38AM (#21683273)
But we're not talking about first aid kits, we're talking about guns. And I think the burden of proof is on those who claim freedom of private firearm ownership works as an anti-tyranny deterrant to play around in the historical fiction realm of how Venezuela, Iraq, Hong Kong, et. al would have turned out differently with a more armed populace (remembering to factor in the possible scenario "Basically the same as it did, only with an awful lot more death when the entrenched military power ramped up the violence level to deal with a populace that could shoot back"). It's probably also relevant in that historical fiction direction to ask whether the "background" level of civilian peacetime death would have been higher or lower and by how much.

Ubiquitous firearm ownership in a society is a bit of a wildcard.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:37AM (#21684003)
I don't necessarily disagree, but neither would I call it "historical fiction." Armed populaces have fought back against their governments repeatedly throughout history. In any event, I'm one of the guys who would rather go down shooting than in a gas chamber. And, yes, that kind of liberty comes at a price.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:00PM (#21684242)
... but it's a price generally paid by people other than the person who is armed in peacetime.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCuuube on Monday December 02, 2019 @06:08PM (#21688074)
No, it really isn't. The majority of the gun deaths in the US belong to suicides compared to homicides.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @05:38PM (#21687854)
I disagree. Fortunately for me, I have the benefit of the Second Amendment, which shifts the burden squarely to those who would deny the right, presumably by further constitutional amendment.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @10:20AM (#21692987)
Support for repeal of the 2nd Amendment is at 20%, which is far higher than I, for one, would anticipate for a fundamental Constitutional right. For comparison, 12% of Americans answered "Do you agree or disagree? Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another?" with "Agree" in 1988.