News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by giancarlostoro on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:24AM (#21682535)
> The right to bear arms was paid for in blood and not just once.

And worse, gun restrictions only benefit criminals. There's plenty of people who legally own firearms and protect their homes and their property legally. They also avoid plenty of crime since criminals tend to run when a gun is pulled on them especially in stand your ground states.

They've tried banning everything in England and criminals will still kill people with just about anything. First it's the guns, then knives, then machetes. You can run over people, are you gonna make cars illegal too?

People who want to hurt people also don't care what laws there are, they can buy guns illegally.

Worse yet, depending on where you live, if something happens in your home, it's a lot safer to have a gun than to wait for cops to come to draw the chalk lines on you and your family.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:36AM (#21682621)
>They've tried banning everything in England and criminals will still kill people with just about anything anything. First it's the guns, then knives, then machetes.

If these alternatives are just as effective as guns, why do you feel that you need a gun?

Of course, you know that guns are more effective at killing people - especially large numbers of people. That's why we in the UK have not had a mass killing in a school since private ownership of handguns was banned over two decades ago.

>it's a lot safer to have a gun than to wait for cops to come to draw the chalk lines on you and your family.

You're more likely to use the gun to kill yourself or a family member than you are to use it to kill an intruder.

Killing someone who breaks into your home is most likely an overreaction in any case. The chances are very low that they've broken in with the intention of harming you rather than merely stealing something.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by giancarlostoro on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:43AM (#21682685)
> Of course, you know that guns are more effective at killing people - especially large numbers of people.

A knife is quiet, you could probably kill more people with knives, a gun is loud and everyone nearby will hear it, probably what a crazy shooter would want is to strike fear into victims.

> You're more likely to use the gun to kill yourself or a family member than you are to use it to kill an intruder.

Since neither of those two are a viable option for myself, I'd rather have a gun, and only ever shoot it at a range than not have one and watch the worse possible scenario unfold before me.

> Killing someone who breaks into your home is most likely an overreaction in any case. The chances are very low that they've broken in with the intention of harming you rather than merely stealing something.

I don't know that, and I don't have to kill them if I pull a gun on them unless my life is in immediate danger. There's cases where a mother held the intruder at gun point until cops showed up to make an arrest.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:50AM (#21682764)
> You could probably kill more people with knives

So why are you worried about gun bans? You can just use a knife instead.

I think you must know, really, that guns are more dangerous and effective than knives. That's why you want the right to own one. It's also why the US has frequent mass shootings in schools, whereas there are no instances of mass stabbings in UK schools.

Just look at the recent terrorist incident in London. The guy killed two people with a knife before being restrained by unarmed members of the public.

>And I don't have to kill them if I pull a gun on one

The first principle of responsible gun use is not to point a gun at anything you don't want to kill.

As you illustrate, hardly anyone is capable of using guns responsibily.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Kaiyou on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:17AM (#21683060)
As an attacker who wants to go unnoticed a knife is the better option. As a defender, who wants to stop an attacker, your best bet is a gun, since you don't have to get close.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCuuube on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:28PM (#21695065)
> So why are you worried about gun bans? You can just use a knife instead.

You seem to be confused about the concept that self-defense is a different use case than mass shootings. Why is that?

> I think you must know, really, that guns are more dangerous and effective than knives. That's why you want the right to own one.

Are you under the impression that this poster would not object to a ban on knives? Why?

> It's also why the US has frequent mass shootings in schools, whereas there are no instances of mass stabbings in UK schools.

Thank you for providing a good example of post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy

> The first principle of responsible gun use is not to point a gun at anything you don't want to kill.

And that's why there's always bullet holes anywhere that a gun has pointed, because they always have to shoot anything it points at? Were you similarly not aware that it is possible to pull a gun but not point it at the person?

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:13AM (#21700995)
Your first points is obscured by snark. The second seems to be based on a misreading. The third is merely the observation that empirical reasoning is non-demonstrative.

As for number four, I see that you are another pro-gun poster who is unfamiliar with the absolute basics of firearm safety. That doesn't make a great case for private gun ownership. Here's what the pinky leftos at concealednation.org have to say (see point 2): https://concealednation.org/2013/11/the-4-rules-of-gun-safet...

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCuuube on Thursday December 12, 2019 @01:58PM (#21775026)
> Your first points is obscured by snark.

What is obscured about the observation that your comment doesn't recognize the differences between self-defense and mass shootings, and how the qualities of the weapon affect the benefits for the user?

> The second seems to be based on a misreading.

You'll have to explain why questioning an intellectually defunct implication is a "misreading".

"that guns are more dangerous and effective than knives. That's why you want the right to own one."

Considering your claim is that desiring the right to own one is some kind of evidence that guns are "more dangerous and effective", it is thoroughly debunked if the person also desires the right to own knives.

> The third is merely the observation that empirical reasoning is non-demonstrative.

It should be noted that making a gigantic logical leap from "guns are more dangerous and effective than knives" to "It's also why the US has frequent mass shootings in schools, whereas there are no instances of mass stabbings in UK schools" is to ignore the social, cultural, economic factors that affect crime. That's not a good basis for understanding of criminal behavior.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCubee on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @11:43AM (#21703767)
That's quite a lot of pot calling.

And your last paragraph is just a complete misunderstanding of what the poster said. My comment was not to denounce the rule about where you point the gun, but to note that your claim about killing was unfounded.

> And I don't have to kill them if I pull a gun on one

The fact that you don't understand this is really troublesome. Are you one of those people who believes in that old myth about swords having to taste blood before being resheathed? Because this is on that level.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Thursday December 05, 2019 @06:25AM (#21711524)
Hmm? The point is that whenever you point a gun at someone there's a significant risk that you'll shoot and kill them. Hence, you should not do it if this is not your intention. This precludes threatening people by pointing guns at them, except in the case where you are prepared to take full responsibility for their death, should this occur.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCubee on Thursday December 05, 2019 @09:12PM (#21718705)
So you agree with the other poster that is is possible to pull a gun and point it at them without killing them. What a roundabout way of pretending to disagree.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:20AM (#21683096)
> Just look at the recent terrorist incident in London. The guy killed two people with a knife before being restrained by unarmed members of the public.

The people restraining him were armed with a fire extinguisher and a narwhal tusk, and he was ultimately subdued by the police shooting him with guns.

Also, since banning guns didn’t actually seem to fix anything, they’re now working on banning knives. So you can’t just use a knife instead. Better hope there’s a narwhal tusk handy when you need it.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:43AM (#21684069)
>The people restraining him were armed with a fire extinguisher and a narwhal tusk

I.e., whatever objects happened to be at hand. I don't think you'd have much luck using a fire extinguisher against someone with an assault rifle.

>Also, since banning guns didn’t actually seem to fix anything

Hmm? There have been no mass killings in schools since the handgun ban. What was anyone expecting it to fix that it hasn't fixed?

Bear in mind that very few British people owned handguns even before the ban (roughly 0.1% of the population), and none of them would have been carrying their guns around while going about their day to day business. One would not expect the ban to have had any great effect on anything - beyond eliminating the specific problem it was intended to address.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by giancarlostoro on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:52PM (#21686143)
> I.e., whatever objects happened to be at hand. I don't think you'd have much luck using a fire extinguisher against someone with an assault rifle.

A rifle is not automatically an assault rifle... But also, if law abiding citizens have their own guns, they can shoot a mad shooter before they cause too much damage.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:14AM (#21693641)
I said "assault rifle".
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by pnako on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:34PM (#21684588)
... that is, until they ban narwhal tusks too!
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCubee on Thursday December 05, 2019 @09:18PM (#21718738)
Don't forget fire extinguishers! There's no reason for a regular subject to have one of those, better to leave it to the professionals.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by asdff on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:04AM (#21690953)
My home defense weapon of choice is my Louisville Slugger. If a crackhead in my place saw me chasing them, crazed, in a bathrobe, with that bat waving blindly, they are booking it. There is no question that they are getting clubbed with this bat.

However, if I had a gun, I'm not sure I'm prepared to end a life right there in my living room and deal with that for the rest of my life. Bloodying a crackhead with a bat I can do, and the crackhead knows that too.

As far as guns being loud, that's almost a good thing for a criminal. Witnesses run away, and by the time the cops show up you are gone and the gun is in the sewer.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by SlowRobotAhead on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:29AM (#21683189)
> why do you feel that you need a gun?

A. In a free society, I am not required to justify my choices. I don’t have to explain my “feelings” about anything.

B. “Need”, there is that word again. In what ways are enumerated rights dependent on needs? If something better than a gun existed for personal defense, I’d want that, I don’t have to explain my “need” about anything. You seem like you are confusing rights with grants and privileges.

So you either don’t actually understand rights in the US, or you are arguing in bad faith because you just don’t like them.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:46AM (#21684094)
I don't care particularly about gun rights in the US as I'm not American and no longer live in the US. My question was simply why someone who believed that knives were as effective as guns would feel that they needed a gun to defend themselves. I think you are getting the wrong end of the stick.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by SlowRobotAhead on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:49PM (#21686106)
I don’t really care how it got there. You posed the question of why someone “feels” they have a “need” to a civil right.

No other right has to face such scrutiny. Do you ask people why they feel they need privacy? Or why the feel they need free speech?

Your argument is based on your own personal dislike for a right, that’s arguing in bad faith.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:26AM (#21693766)
I'm asking why they think they need the gun, not why they think they need the right to own it.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by deadbunny on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:33AM (#21683226)
> They've tried banning everything in England and criminals will still kill people with just about anything. First it's the guns, then knives, then machetes. You can run over people, are you gonna make cars illegal too?

We just had a Terrorist attack last week. He was armed with 2 knives and he killed 2 people before being taken down by some people with a fire extinguisher and a narwhal horn (I shit you not).

I'll take that over dozens in any shooting spree with victims in the dozens thanks.

And no, a "good guy" with a gun would have made things worse before you even start with that bullshit.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by justadudeama on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:33PM (#21685257)
What would you call the police officer that came with a gun?

By giving up private firearm ownership you are putting the safety of yourself and your loved ones in the hands of the government. This article is an example of why it is dangerous to do that.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:51PM (#21685465)
>What would you call the police officer that came with a gun?

Superfluous, in this instance. It clearly would have been possible to arrest the guy without shooting him. (I believe that they only shot him on the off chance that the suicide vest was real.)

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by justadudeama on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:12PM (#21685723)
Two things:

1.

> off chance the suicide vest was real

Would you argue that what the police officer did was wrong here? Is lethal force not justified with the credible threat of violence? I would argue that someone threatening you with a Airsoft gun with the tip taken out so it appears to be a real gun is enough to justify deadly force in self defense, you don't have to verify that gun is real. In hindsight, it is clear that you could have arrested him without shooting him, but that was not at all clear in the situation, and having that firearm could have saved dozens if the vest was real.

2. > In this instance

And, for arguments sake, if this was a different situation where the vest was real, what would you say?

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:12AM (#21693616)
Aren't these tangents? I didn't say that they shouldn't have shot him, just that it clearly wasn't necessary to shoot him in order to remove the threat. (It's obviously possible to apprehend someone armed only with a knife without shooting them.)
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by TheRealSteel on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:54AM (#21682809)
"gun restrictions only benefit criminals"

All the data from other countries that god rid of guns supports the opposite of this. Show some statistics or stop saying this.

"are you gonna make cars illegal too?"

Ones that can be easily used to kill people? Hopefully, eventually, yes. We already heavily restrict them, license them carefully, track them meticulously, require them to be registered, and constantly improve technology and legal standards to make them less likely to kill people -- unlike guns in America. Soon all new cars will have technology in them to make it very difficult to run someone over with.

"People who want to hurt people also don't care what laws there are, they can buy guns illegally."

So I suppose you're in favour of having no laws at all? Since people will just break them? This argument only works if you're in favour of total anarchism.

Both gun crime AND the overall murder rate dropped substantially since Australia heavily restricted guns in the late 90s [1] - i.e. people don't just switch to other weapons - murder, plus accidental death, actually decreases.

"They've tried banning everything in England and criminals will still kill people with just about anything."

Nope. Not having guns works:

Homicide rate per 100,000 people in 2017 according to UN-CTS:

United Kingdom: 1.2

United States: 5.3

[1] https://crimestats.aic.gov.au/NHMP/1_trends/

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by SlowRobotAhead on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:45AM (#21683376)
Go ahead and compare rural US where all the guns are to rural Europe. Similar rates of crime and violence. Take out the major US metropolitan areas that have gun control and see what happens to your comparisons.

When you compare an island the size of Mississippi with 29 citizens of 250k population and a much larger homogenous population, historically weak self-defense and higher reliance on government, etc etc to the whole of the US - I personally don’t think that’s an apt comparison at all.

Why is it size AND population similar countries aren’t ever compared when making this “gunz are bad” argument?

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:51PM (#21684785)
>major US metropolitan areas that have gun control

They don't have gun control in the sense that the UK and most other European countries have gun control. You can even get a permit to carry a concealed weapon in NYC, for example.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by SlowRobotAhead on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:38PM (#21685994)
> You can even get a permit to carry a concealed weapon in NYC

Ok, I’ll do it for you. Rural crime in USA is 2.0 - 3.5 / 100k in USA depending on region. Where all the guns are, the shootings aren’t.

NYC... for example... SHALL ISSUE state, you’re effectively wrong. Only the connected and elite can get carry permits in NYC. That’ll change soon with the latest SC case coming up.

You’re right, it’s not “the same” gun control. Like Paris where guns for private ownership and stored in your home are effectively banned, yet, worse mass shootings than any in the US ever. Or Norway where black rifles are banned, but worse mass shooting of kids than any in the US.

You’re right, it’s not the same - but what we can look at is IN THE USA, the places with the most gun control have the most shootings, in inconvenient fact.

Ok, so... by your argument. It’s the people carrying legally in the US that are going around shooting people?

And I believe I proposed the question of why size AND population aren’t compared ever? I think it’s because when you compare Russia or Mexico or Brazil to US, with much stricter the gun control the argument falls apart. You need to pick small population and or small isolated homogeneous populations to make your argument - if you think that’s legitimate keep at it.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:15AM (#21693661)
> Where all the guns are, the shootings aren’t.

So there are shootings without guns?

Norway and France both have vastly fewer shooting deaths per year than the US.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by SlowRobotAhead on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:28PM (#21694429)
Are you arguing crime or events? France and Norway beat US in events, gun control doesn’t seem to work there.

If you are talking crime, yes USA crime is higher - in the areas with more gun control. I’d argue the cause of the crime is our poor handling of drug and poverty and not focus on the tool used.

Guns have increased DRAMATICALLY since the crime highs of the 1990s, but crime has dropped to just above the lows of the 1960s.

You have ZERO data for causation of more guns equal more crime because we have opposite evidence.

So while I can’t say more guns EQUALS less crime - I can definitely say more guns hasn’t CAUSED more crime like you are saying.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:01AM (#21700948)
I don't know what you mean by "events". More people get shot in the US.

There are obviously lots of confounding factors in relation to crime statistics in different areas of the USA. It's more revealing to look longitudinally at the positive effects of gun control legislation in e.g. the UK and Australia.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by kissickas on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:56PM (#21686186)
NYC has an impressively low homicide rate, if there is such a thing, and has become a very safe city in the last decade or two.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/new-york-citys-murder-rate-hit-...

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:13AM (#21693630)
Yes, so what?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lm28469 on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:31AM (#21682588)
> And worse, gun restrictions only benefit criminals. There's plenty of people who legally own firearms and protect their homes and their property legally.

The real question is why are the US ranking so high in violent crime and murder rates compared to other developed countries. You shouldn't feel the need to "protect" your home in the #1 power in the world.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:25AM (#21683153)
The US isn’t a European country that happens to be in the New World, it’s a New World country that somehow managed to become a superpower. It makes a lot more sense to see the US as an overachieving Mexico or Brazil than as an abnormally violent Britain or Germany.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by jessaustin on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:58PM (#21686858)
As usual, colonial powers have difficulty acknowledging the effects of their colonialism.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by giancarlostoro on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:43AM (#21682697)
I don't think it's guns, there's other countries where you have gun rights that don't have this problem. Then there's countries where guns were forced out of citizens hands and the government went rogue (Venezuela).
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by dsfyu404ed on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:46AM (#21682719)
>The real question is why are the US ranking so high in violent crime and murder rates compared to other developed countries

This question has been asked time and again and the gist of the answer is that the people who make their living moving around illicit substances drag up the average. For people who don't associate with drug trafficking the US is basically on par with Europe.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lm28469 on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:00AM (#21682870)
> the people who make their living moving around illicit substances drag up the average.

Isn't that happening all around the world though ?

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by nrclark on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:42AM (#21683331)
Gun ownership doesn't help public safety anywhere near as much as you think.

The number one and number two uses of guns inside a home are suicide and murder of a loved one, respectively. Defending against a home invader is statistically uncommon at best. But people get angry every day, and we all have moments of weakness and vulnerability.

To your point about criminals, have you ever been robbed? A robber isn't going to announce his intentions from 20 feet away.

Does having a gun under your shirt help you if somebody pokes a knife into your back? Maybe you could draw and murder them in revenge as they leave I guess.

I know that gun-safety classes are mandatory for any kind of concealed-carry permit. But I can 100% guarantee that they don't prepare you for the psychological reality of killing somebody.

And let's say you actually find yourself in a situation where drawing your gun makes it better instead of worse - do you use it? If so, prepare yourself to pay every dime you have to a defense attorney, and to give up a year of your life to court proceedings. Even in a stand-your-ground state. And that's assuming you don't miss and hit somebody else by mistake.

Human-nature is to stand by and watch when something bad goes down. Carrying a gun doesn't change that. And a three-day course on gun safety doesn't prepare you for the reality of drawing on a human and firing.

On the other side of the argument - when guns are easy to buy, lots of people buy them legally. Then some of those people have them stolen or sell them. And others resell them.

When guns are cheap and cheerful, it's easy for a criminal to get one. When guns are expensive and hard-to-get, some criminals might still get one. But a lot of other criminals won't go through the effort. Why find an illegal gun dealer when you can buy a kitchen knife at Costco? And believe it or not - that's a big win for overall public safety.

Also if we could get guns out of the hands of the general population, we'd be able to make a better case for de-militarizing our police. And that would be a _huge_ win for public safety.

The US's founders weren't gods, and they didn't have a crystal ball into the future. We shouldn't treat their words as some kind of immortal and perfect document, to be interpreted on a word-by-word basis like bible scholars. And when the US was founded, the common gun needed a ramrod to load the single shot it carried.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by jdkdnfndnfjd on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:33PM (#21686559)
Some good points but I disagree. I got caught up in a situation where I really needed a gun. You say that guns aren’t useful for street crime. That just isn’t true. My experience made me an overnight 2A advocate. It’s insane that we give all this power and leniency to criminals and strip innocent people of the ability to stand up for themselves. Nobody will ever convince me that guns don’t help because I have lived it. I am living proof that that isn’t true. And it’s a shame that people in liberal communities have to live it in order to understand it.

There are countries with guns and low crime. Uk has no guns but a stabbing epidemic. The key to public safety is preventing crime with good education, opportunity and very generous disincentive, preferably a swift execution for violent crime.

For my particular situation, in the USA, the people who want gun bans are the same people that refuse to let police do stop and frisk. So it just doesn’t make sense for me to give up my right to have a gun. We shouldn’t need a ban in the first place. It’s other things that cause the underlying violent behavior.

You are so right about the civil suit. Especially in liberal states, you might as well just shoot yourself instead of the bad guy. But that’s a problem with the legal system, not guns. The legal system in general is responsible for all kinds of problems. A person who loses their case should have to pay the other persons legal fees, too. Lots to change. In the meantime I’ll defend myself in a way that is legally sound and with a gun camera that automatically captures an image of the guy attacking me before the trigger is pulled.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lm28469 on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:24AM (#21682528)
Education is a right, and imho it should rank higher than guns.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by sdinsn on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:52PM (#21686141)
> Education is a right

I can't find that in the constitution.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Kaiyou on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:20AM (#21683088)
Owning guns is a right, and imho it should rank higher than education.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by lm28469 on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:07AM (#21683662)
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:49AM (#21682752)
How do other countries get along so well without the right to bear arms, and have they paid any less blood than the US for the society they formed?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:07AM (#21682952)
Ask Venezuela or Iraq or Iran or Hong Kong or basically any of the countries in the Arab spring how it’s going for them right now.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by snowwrestler on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:58PM (#21684873)
Are you arguing that people in the U.S. should have guns so that they can shoot at U.S. police and military if they disagree with a government policy?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:24PM (#21685854)
Yes, depending on the government policy, that is precisely what I'm arguing.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:40PM (#21686011)
It's a fantasy Americans seem to uniquely believe in that arming the populace is a good deterrent against bad government policy.

If it actually worked, one would expect the US to be two separate nations now. After all, what was the Civil War if not a mass of Americans deciding extra-legally that the laws should not apply to them and taking up arms to break free of government oppression and form a government more inclined to protect their freedoms?

And yet, after a bloody conflict that claimed more American lives than World War II, the country is still one nation and Americans still cling to a strange belief that private gun ownership protects against tyranny (as if a tyrant wouldn't bring their own guns to bear against the citizenry, like Sherman burning towns south of the Mason-Dixon to hamstring the morale of the rebels).

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by AnimalMuppet on Monday December 02, 2019 @03:48PM (#21686729)
It's not perfect. But what it means is that if you're going to impose a policy that unpopular on half the population, you may have to go as far as the Civil War did, including accepting that many of your own people dying. That's... somewhat daunting.

And a tyrant, while perfectly willing to bring their own guns to turn on citizens, would have a military that might not be willing, especially if they didn't agree with the tyrant. (The Civil War wasn't just the US army against the citizens of the south. It was the army members from the south against the army members from the north.)

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:51PM (#21687408)
It's far from perfect. It demands a tax in blood during peacetime as a faulty guard against tyranny in time of civil war (to say nothing of the fact that---as the Civil War indicates---there's no particular guarantee that the armed civilians will be defending particularly virtuous rights against government interference; it was, after all, the state's rights to nullify laws curtailing slavery that was the crux of the conflict).
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by asdff on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:07AM (#21690965)
You think your AR 15 is going to stop a guided missile launched by an 18 year old with a joystick on a destroyer in the middle of the Atlantic? I think we've all played the AC-130 mission in Call of Duty by now. We are way past the days of a militia dealing with the U.S. government.

But back in 1776 when you and uncle sam had the exact same musket, sure, that was the last chance.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:24AM (#21692028)
Yeah, probably best to just surrender your weapons and pray for mercy.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @08:57AM (#21692243)
Instead of praying for mercy, Americans can vote for good leadership, be active in their local, state, and federal government, hold each other accountable, and take responsibility for living in a representative democracy.

It is, ultimately, these things that make for a free and stable society, not the proliferation of firearms. When you elect a tyrant, all the private firearms do is ramp up the bloodshed the tyrant will bring.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @01:45PM (#21695255)
If only democracies could be trusted to not elect tyrants. Unfortunately, there are many, many examples to the contrary. That fact was one of the primary motivators for the Bill of Rights. You are right that there would be bloodshed when facing a tyrant (certainly more than if there were no way to fight back). In my mind, better that than the gas chambers. Let’s not forget that Hitler came into power by popular vote.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:25PM (#21695685)
I've heard argumentum-ad-Hitler used as an example of why private citizens should be armed.

What I've never heard is a strong argument that a German citizenry armed as the US is armed now wouldn't have simply resulted in faster, gas-chamber-free deaths of minorities in Germany and German-occupied territories, as the government in charge gave quiet assent to extra-legal killings enacted by private citizens against "undesirables" and the citizenry bought into the mythology of the ubermensch.

After all, the hypothesis of the equalizing effect of private firepower assumes that "good guys" have the guns.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:42PM (#21695874)
I think that both having guns makes it marginally less likely that either shoots. That applies at both the micro and macro scale.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:56PM (#21696041)
Then given the proliferation of firearms in the US, the firearm-related homicide and injury rates should be lower than in countries that ban firearms (not absolute instances; lower rates, if more guns makes it marginally less likely that any party shoots).

They are not.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:08PM (#21697338)
In most (nearly all?) circumstances, one party is not armed.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @05:13PM (#21697386)
Then at what ratio of armed citizens do the benefits you anticipate kick in? 60%? 80%? Should we all expect to show up to church strapped with a 9mm, just in case?

Can you provide an example of a country where such a high ratio of armed citizenry has worked out well? There should be a positive example we can turn to. The US isn't it by the numbers.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @09:51PM (#21699190)
I never claimed gun ownership reduced gun violence overall, but excluding suicide it doesn’t seem to increase it either.[1] At the macro scale, I only mean to say it makes hostile government action less likely. Likewise, at the micro scale, I only mean to say violent confrontation between individuals is less likely when both parties are armed than when only one is armed. This much to me seems self evident (and underpins the macro thesis as well). At the micro scale, I might agree that there would be less gun violence if neither party were armed, but mass confiscation will never happen in the US. It would be ineffective given the lack of a central registry and it would likely incite civil war. In that light, even barring the macro thesis, it strikes me as prudent to be among the armed. With, of course, basic safety training.

[1]https://medium.com/handwaving-freakoutery/everybodys-lying-a...

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:14AM (#21702807)
I don't actually think mass confiscation would be necessary. Offer nationwide buyback and severely curtail manufacture and first-sale, and the equations change wildly. America is hyper-capitalist and capitalist incentives tend to work on people.

It's win-win; those who want their guns more than the money can keep their guns.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:13AM (#21683022)
Can we can also ask Denmark, Sweden, Germany, or other European countries that tend to be considered the US's economic and cultural peers?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:35AM (#21683246)
Sure, but I'm not sure the answer would be relevant. As an analogy, just because you haven't used your first aid kit doesn't mean you won't one day need it. To the contrary, we have many examples of countries that left the first aid kit behind only to realize they desperately needed it.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:38AM (#21683273)
But we're not talking about first aid kits, we're talking about guns. And I think the burden of proof is on those who claim freedom of private firearm ownership works as an anti-tyranny deterrant to play around in the historical fiction realm of how Venezuela, Iraq, Hong Kong, et. al would have turned out differently with a more armed populace (remembering to factor in the possible scenario "Basically the same as it did, only with an awful lot more death when the entrenched military power ramped up the violence level to deal with a populace that could shoot back"). It's probably also relevant in that historical fiction direction to ask whether the "background" level of civilian peacetime death would have been higher or lower and by how much.

Ubiquitous firearm ownership in a society is a bit of a wildcard.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:37AM (#21684003)
I don't necessarily disagree, but neither would I call it "historical fiction." Armed populaces have fought back against their governments repeatedly throughout history. In any event, I'm one of the guys who would rather go down shooting than in a gas chamber. And, yes, that kind of liberty comes at a price.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:00PM (#21684242)
... but it's a price generally paid by people other than the person who is armed in peacetime.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CompanionCuuube on Monday December 02, 2019 @06:08PM (#21688074)
No, it really isn't. The majority of the gun deaths in the US belong to suicides compared to homicides.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by hcurtiss on Monday December 02, 2019 @05:38PM (#21687854)
I disagree. Fortunately for me, I have the benefit of the Second Amendment, which shifts the burden squarely to those who would deny the right, presumably by further constitutional amendment.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @10:20AM (#21692987)
Support for repeal of the 2nd Amendment is at 20%, which is far higher than I, for one, would anticipate for a fundamental Constitutional right. For comparison, 12% of Americans answered "Do you agree or disagree? Homosexual couples should have the right to marry one another?" with "Agree" in 1988.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by qxnqd on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:00AM (#21682868)
With repression and fewer liberties, mostly?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:14AM (#21683027)
I don't get the sense that people in Sweden or Germany feel over-burdened by a lack of liberty.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:31AM (#21683211)
Germany has barely made it to the 30 year mark of “not being a dictatorship” if you count the East. America has been one of the freest countries in the world for at least 150-some years.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by radmuzom on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:59AM (#21684227)
Correct. So free that women got the right to vote in 1920s. African Americans in the 1960s.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:01PM (#21684255)
East Germans got the right to vote in the 1990's. Largely as a consequence of American diplomatic pressure on the Soviet Union, I might add.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by CDSlice on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:20PM (#21684440)
Which other countries were much better? Obviously the fact that women and African Americans got the vote so late is not good, but America could still be one of the freest countries in the last 150 years if most everyone else was even worse.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:56PM (#21684837)
I think there are lots of Western countries that have never had laws barring people from voting due to their race. E.g., there has never been any such law in the UK. Women in the UK also got the vote slightly earlier.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:53PM (#21685486)
The UK is an abnormally successful democracy by world standards. I suppose you could quibble about the British Empire, but the main difference there is that Britain colonized much more of the world than America did.

The main question I have concerns Britain’s history of anti-Catholic discrimination. It’s all well and good to point out that Britain never disenfranchised black people during a time when approximately zero black people lived there. Although I suppose Britain is responsible for colonizing South Africa and Rhodesia....

But sure, let’s concede Britain for the moment. France, West Germany, and Italy were effectively fascist dictatorships until the mid-1940’s. (Vichy being a “puppet government” is a lie concocted to spare French pride—Petain was a fascist sympathizer since before the war and he took power within the French political system at the time—its not like the Germans overran the government and installed him like they did in other occupied countries.) Spain and Portugal until the 1970’s. Yugoslavia had a communist dictatorship until the 1990’s. Which is incidentally the same decade that Switzerland achieved universal women’s suffrage.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:04PM (#21685637)
>But sure, let’s concede Britain for the moment.

Great - that was the point of my post. Not sure why you are going off on a bunch of other tangents. You haven't mentioned any other country which banned people from voting on racial criteria.

>It’s all well and good to point out that Britain never disenfranchised black people during a time when approximately zero black people lived there.

You say this as if Britain started disenfranchising black people once they were present in significant numbers, but this is not the case. (This is not to deny, of course, that there is a long history of racism in the UK. I'm merely pointing out that the US is relatively exceptional in passing actual laws banning black people from voting.)

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:07PM (#21685665)
Because you’re comparing a continent-wide federation to a tiny island-sized country.

> You say this as if Britain started disenfranchising black people once they were present in significant numbers, but this is not the case.

No, they just colonized Africa and disenfranchised them there. Totally different.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:12PM (#21685721)
>Because you’re comparing a continent-wide federation to a tiny island-sized country.

I really don't see what you're getting at here. You yourself have been making (irrelevant) comparisons to France, which has about the same population as the UK.

There is no such size as "island-sized". Islands can be big or small.

>No, they just colonized Africa and disenfranchised them there. Totally different.

Indeed, this is completely different.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Monday December 02, 2019 @02:30PM (#21685919)
> I really don't see what you're getting at here. You yourself have been making (irrelevant) comparisons to France, which has about the same population as the UK.

I’m comparing the US as a whole to Europe as a whole. If you want to cherry-pick the best example of Europe, maybe I should cherry-pick one of the northern states that abolished slavery and enfranchised black people in the early 19th century. If you get to claim that France, Spain, Portugal, etc. don’t count, I should be able to claim Mississippi doesn’t count.

Conversely, maybe we can compare the US to the entire British Empire. How many imperial subjects were truly enfranchised? Not the Indians, not the black Africans. Hell, even within the UK itself there was the entire Irish issue. But I guess Irish and Catholic aren’t technically races.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:13AM (#21693624)
You were not comparing the US as a whole to Europe as a whole.

It is not clear to me what point your are intending to make with this array of different comparisons.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:29PM (#21696929)
My overall point, I think, was adequately well-stated with my first comment in this thread: America has been one of the freest countries in the world for 150 years.

Your counterarguments seem to consist of, “so was Britain” (which is insufficient to refute my point) and “Britain didn’t disenfranchise based on race” (which is factually dubious when you consider colonization as well as insufficient in terms of proving that Britain was substantially freer than America as a whole).

You also alluded to “lots of Western countries”, which is why I specifically broke down specific periods where many (most?) Western countries were not free within the past century. This is when you doubled down on the UK angle, which is a fair point but proves very little.

You also claimed the UK enacted women’s suffrage before the US. I didn’t bother fact checking this at the time, but the US enacted full women’s suffrage eight years before the UK.

> In 1928 the Conservative government passed the Representation of the People (Equal Franchise) Act equalizing the franchise to all persons over the age of 21 on equal terms.

(https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women's_suffrage_in_the_Unit...)

The US:

> After a hard-fought series of votes in the U.S. Congress and in state legislatures, the Nineteenth Amendment became part of the U.S. Constitution on August 18, 1920.[4] It states, "The right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex."

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Women's_suffrage_in_the_Unit...

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @03:45AM (#21700631)
You're reading a lot of things into my original reply that just aren't there.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @10:53AM (#21703212)
If so, it’s only because I was making the IMO generous assumption that your original reply was meant to actually refute my thesis that “ America has been one of the freest countries in the world for at least 150-some years.”, and CDSlice’s argument that “America could still be one of the freest countries in the last 150 years if most everyone else was even worse.”

If you were intentionally making insufficient and hence irrelevant points, why wade into the thread in the first place?

> I think there are lots of Western countries that have never had laws barring people from voting due to their race.

This might technically be true, because many of those Western countries have taken the further step of abolishing democracy altogether. I hope you would agree that the various fascist and fascist-adjacent dictatorships of 20th century Europe were “even worse” than racial disenfranchisement.

> E.g., there has never been any such law in the UK.

The use of “e.g.” here implies that you’re discussing Western countries in general and not just the UK. Also, this point is rather fatuous for reasons I’ve already discussed.

> Women in the UK also got the vote slightly earlier.

This is false, as I’ve already discussed.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Thursday December 05, 2019 @06:23AM (#21711515)
>If so, it’s only because I was making the IMO generous assumption that your original reply was meant to actually refute my thesis

It wasn't. Note that I was not replying to your comment.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by philwelch on Thursday December 05, 2019 @01:57PM (#21715152)
You were responding—fatuously—to CDSlice’s comment that “America could still be one of the freest countries in the last 150 years if most everyone else was even worse.” Which is a restatement of my thesis.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by asdff on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @04:10AM (#21690976)
And right to gay marriage in 2015.
[dead]
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:42AM (#21683332)
I'm going to assume you don't mean to compare the citizens of Sweden and Germany to captive animals.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Kaiyou on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:26AM (#21683884)
Then what do you assume I wanted to say?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:31AM (#21683936)
I have made no assumptions; I believe I misunderstand you. Can you clarify your meaning?
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Kaiyou on Monday December 02, 2019 @11:52AM (#21684159)
If you put someone into a situation that isn't optimal, they generally have the means to adapt and not look disadavantaged. This is true for caged animals and humans that lost some of their rights. If you do it slowly enough, you can strip away basically all freedoms without the victim even noticing.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by foldr on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:00PM (#21684894)
Similarly, people will come to regard high levels of violence as normal if they spend enough time immersed in a violent culture.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Kaiyou on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:42AM (#21693930)
Yes, people adapt. I'm saying you can't look at someone and determine whether how things are for them are good, just because they look fine. An animal raised in captivity looks fine, but maybe it would be better if it was raised in freedom. Or maybe it wouldn't. The point is you can't tell by looking.
Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by shadowgovt on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @03:40PM (#21696470)
Sure, but that's a critical difference between animals and people.

In addition to sampling a whole host of metrics related to a person's health, life expectancy, purchasing power, &c, you can also just ask them how they feel about where they are in life and where they're going. You can't do that with an animal.

Sweden, for example, is showing an OCED Better Life Index of 8.5 for safety and 8.9 for life satisfaction [http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/countries/sweden/]. This is compared to the US's rankings of 7.5 and 7.4, respectively.

If the Swedes have sacrificed their freedom (assuming "freedom" is a quantifiable that the US hasn't sacrificed), I wouldn't draw the conclusion they haven't noticed; I'd conclude they actively don't miss it.

Re:Clear backpacks, monitored emails: U.S. students under co... by Kaiyou on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @04:04AM (#21700709)
My point is that you can't tell, because people adapt. You could come to the same conclusion about people without Internet access and then come to the conclusion that we should ban Internet access, because people without it are happier.