Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012)
by kd5bjo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:45AM
(#21674393)
That statement is a corollary to “A federation must make some attempt to treat its members as equals.” While not necessarily true, deviating too far from it starts to stretch the definition of a federation.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012)
by umanwizard on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:04AM
(#21674470)
Do you have any examples of federations that don't work that way, i.e., that have purely proportional representation of all the constituent entities?
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012)
by satori99 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @06:13AM
(#21674925)
Australia uses a highly proportional electoral process for its lower house.
The constitution requires that electorates be apportioned among the states in proportion to their respective populations; provided that each original state has at least 5 members in the House of Representatives.
Districts are decided and managed by a politically independent federal commission (ie: not by politicians).
The Australian senate is still a state house modelled in the US fashion. And is therefore not proportional to the population.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divisions_of_the_Australian_Ho...
This is a very Americocentric view. There is in fact no such requirement in general.
The US in particular has a problem of being pulled by some small, fringe groups.