News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by ReptileMan on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:34AM (#21674346)
>The fundamental problem of the electoral college is that the states of the United States are too disparate in size and influence.

No, that is the problem that the electoral college solves. In any federation you must curb the power of the most powerful and boost the weakest for it to work.

Instead of blaming with the institutions that are working as intended, start the dialog to convert the US from federation to something else.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by the_why_of_y on Sunday December 01, 2019 @09:01AM (#21675510)
The problem that the Electoral College solves is that the constitution guaranteed the slave holding states that their political influence at the federal level would take into account the number of people they enslaved.

For the legislative branch, this was done by counting a slave as 3/5 of a person for allocating seats in the House of Representatives. For the executive branch, there is only one president, and of course the slaves did not have the right to vote themselves, so an indirection was needed, i.e., the Electoral College.

https://time.com/4558510/electoral-college-history-slavery/# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-Fifths_Compromise

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by TMWNN on Sunday December 01, 2019 @01:31PM (#21676967)
The Electoral College's intention was to balance large states' power with small states' desire to not let large states run everything. The college had nothing to do with slavery or the Three Fifths Compromise. Slave states gained more power in the Electoral College from the extra 3/5 votes, but a) the compromise itself had nothing to do with the Electoral College's creation or design, and b) 3/5 of a vote gave less power to slave states than their preference, a full vote for each slave.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by kohler on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:13PM (#21676463)
Trump, November 13, 2016, on “60 Minutes” “ I would rather see it, where you went with simple votes. You know, you get 100 million votes, and somebody else gets 90 million votes, and you win. There’s a reason for doing this. Because it brings all the states into play.”

In 2012, the night Romney lost, Trump tweeted. "The phoney electoral college made a laughing stock out of our nation. . . . The electoral college is a disaster for a democracy."

In 1969, The U.S. House of Representatives voted for a national popular vote by a 338–70 margin.

Presidential candidates who supported direct election of the President in the form of a constitutional amendment, before the National Popular Vote bill was introduced: George H.W. Bush (R-TX-1969), Bob Dole (R-KS-1969), Gerald Ford (R-MI-1969), Richard Nixon (R-CA-1969), Jimmy Carter (D-GA-1977), and Hillary Clinton (D-NY-2001).

Past presidential candidates with a public record of support, before November 2016, for the National Popular Vote bill that would guarantee the majority of Electoral College votes and the presidency to the candidate with the most national popular votes: Bob Barr (Libertarian- GA), U.S. House Speaker Newt Gingrich (R–GA), Congressman Tom Tancredo (R-CO), and Senator Fred Thompson (R–TN),

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jakeogh on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:58PM (#21676763)
Hey, everyone is wrong sometimes.

Romney was a designated loser between two "global gov" sponsored candidates. Like Jeb!

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by adamnemecek on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:37AM (#21674356)
> In any federation you must curb the power of the most powerful and boost the weakest for it to work.

This is a very Americocentric view. There is in fact no such requirement in general.

The US in particular has a problem of being pulled by some small, fringe groups.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by kd5bjo on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:45AM (#21674393)
That statement is a corollary to “A federation must make some attempt to treat its members as equals.” While not necessarily true, deviating too far from it starts to stretch the definition of a federation.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by umanwizard on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:04AM (#21674470)
Do you have any examples of federations that don't work that way, i.e., that have purely proportional representation of all the constituent entities?
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by satori99 on Sunday December 01, 2019 @06:13AM (#21674925)
Australia uses a highly proportional electoral process for its lower house.

The constitution requires that electorates be apportioned among the states in proportion to their respective populations; provided that each original state has at least 5 members in the House of Representatives.

Districts are decided and managed by a politically independent federal commission (ie: not by politicians).

The Australian senate is still a state house modelled in the US fashion. And is therefore not proportional to the population.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Divisions_of_the_Australian_Ho...

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by kortilla on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:00AM (#21674451)
> This is a very Americocentric view.

Well it’s how the European Union works as well. Think of each US state as an individual State in the EU of that helps you understand it.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by peter_retief on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:44AM (#21674390)
Very important point. Democracy can destroy the Republic, the law must always be above the will of the masses. Electoral college is key to preserving the freedoms individuals enjoy. Whats wrong with a Federation?
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by peter_retief on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:00AM (#21674453)
I wonder if people understand how powerful the American Constitution is? Pure Democracies is essentially mob rule and has been tried and failed since ancient times
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by eropple on Sunday December 01, 2019 @10:40AM (#21675943)
How very fortunate that nobody is talking about "pure Democracy", but rather a more balanced representative republic that does not make land more powerful than the citizenry.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jakeogh on Sunday December 01, 2019 @01:00PM (#21676776)
Then stop using the wrong term. Democracy -is- majority rule. It's endlessely parroted by the groups that specialize in nation-breaking.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by eropple on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:43PM (#21677397)
Nobody in this reply chain used the term "democracy" as a descriptor, so why is your trilby so tipped?

We've got borderline lizard people--sorry, globalist--conspiracy from you elsewhere in the thread, so to be frank I'm not expecting much, but the words are right there for you to read.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by jakeogh on Sunday December 01, 2019 @10:39PM (#21679638)
Ah lizard people. Paradoxically you fell for that, it's a confirmation bias hack. Note the reflexive grasp for the conspiracy blanky.

Try holding the idea that some people are for open borders, and that there are power centers behind nation breaking in your head at the same time.

CF hacks: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21057230

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by peter_retief on Sunday December 01, 2019 @12:30PM (#21676594)
Representative republic sounds good. Land is important though, probably at least as important as the citizenry.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by eropple on Sunday December 01, 2019 @02:41PM (#21677382)
No, it's not. People take primacy over either corporate interests or empty dirt.

The insistence that this not be the case always, in every case, comes from some sewage-tier political pseudophilosophy.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by peter_retief on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:00PM (#21677480)
Well I guess we disagree on that. If we take Zimbabwe as a example of a democracy by the people we get the majority taking the possessions of minority groups. Now there are no jobs and no food. People are starving. Its not as simple as you say.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by umanwizard on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:06AM (#21674474)
There are many countries that are not federations and are functioning fine, in practice. (E.g.: France, UK, Japan, many others...)
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by ReptileMan on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:11AM (#21674499)
UK is not functioning quite well at the moment. And is something of a federation IIRC.
Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by umanwizard on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:19AM (#21674526)
The UK is functioning okay, actually. Not being able to agree on what Brexit means is quite a minor problem by world standards. It doesn't change the fact that the UK is a highly developed country both in terms of GDP and HDI, has excellent infrastructure, plenty of food, etc.

And the UK is not a federation, at all. The central Parliament in London wields all power and the devolved legislatures (in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland) only have whatever authority the central state chooses to allow them to.

Re:US 50 states redrawn as equal population (2012) by peter_retief on Sunday December 01, 2019 @03:11AM (#21674501)
Sure, there are but in larger countries federations might make more sense.