Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers
by ben_w on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:47PM
(#21672810)
None of the logic in that argument would change if I replaced “beef” with “long pork”.
Personally, I don’t claim to know how much “personhood”[0] a cow has. It’s possible they don’t count and we shouldn’t care. But it’s only consistent to say “the meat industry is good for cows“ if you also say “the cannibalism industry is good for humans”.
Not that I’m doing a great job of being a morally consistent person myself, as I’m only vegetarian, and dairy is also really bad for bovine welfare, what with the forced pregnancies and slaughtered newborn calves.
[0] for lack of a better term — I know some people regard “person” as a synonym for “human”, but “self aware” and “sentient” are just as bad.
Personally, I don’t claim to know how much “personhood”[0] a cow has. It’s possible they don’t count and we shouldn’t care. But it’s only consistent to say “the meat industry is good for cows“ if you also say “the cannibalism industry is good for humans”.
Not that I’m doing a great job of being a morally consistent person myself, as I’m only vegetarian, and dairy is also really bad for bovine welfare, what with the forced pregnancies and slaughtered newborn calves.
[0] for lack of a better term — I know some people regard “person” as a synonym for “human”, but “self aware” and “sentient” are just as bad.