News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by z_open on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:17PM (#21671663)
You also pay for calves being torn from their mothers while the mother weeps for days. You pay for the calf to be slaughtered in the cheapest legal way, and often not even that. You pay for the times the cow doesn't die immediately, but sits in agony haven't done nothing to deserve this.

By the way, the agriculture industry loves that you believe those farms on the side of the road are where your meat comes from. Instead of the factories that actually produce the overwhelming majority of the meat in this country. You pay for them to be cramped up, tormented, and murdered.

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by codyb on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:57PM (#21671862)
Yea, the factory farms are definitely pretty awful.

I’m lucky enough to both cook at home, live in a big city with lots of good butchers, and have the resources to be able to afford to buy organic, pasture raised, and grass fed meats as much as possible.

It’s not always possible to avoid factory farmed meat products, I assume anything I eat out unless the restaurant is very upscale is going to be cheaper cuts, and my parents aren’t rich and don’t buy like that although I’ll try sometimes to grab a turkey for Thanksgiving for instance.

Interestingly, my girlfriend is from India and vegetarian as many Indian people I’ve met seem to be, she didn’t like the Impossible Burger at all, because it was too meat like, which is a bit funny to me.

Lab grown meats are showing promise for the future which is neat.

But yea, life is bloody, violent, and miserable a lot of times. We should be thankful to live in such relatively peaceful times. Seems like there were just millenia’s of near constant region conflicts, famines, plagues, epidemics, religious wars.

It hasn’t all gone away, but maybe we’re closer than we’ve ever been?

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by nradov on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:04PM (#21671885)
Do you get upset when a pack of wolves murders an elk? The elk seems to be suffering quite a bit of torment, and the killing process sometimes takes quite a while.
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by z_open on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:34PM (#21672002)
The wolf has little choice. You do but choose pain for others for hedonistic reasons. The agriculture industry is outrageously more cruel than a pack of wolves killing an elk. My expectation is for people to choose the path of least suffering to the extent they have the ability.

And to answer your question, I do get upset when I watch a pack of wolves kill an elk. Just because it happens doesn't mean I don't recognize and empathize with things in pain.

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by dr_dshiv on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:32PM (#21671055)
Would you pay 2x so you could know they had fields and beach balls? Or 1x for industrial cow-cubicles? Be honest now..
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by usrusr on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:08PM (#21671293)
Not GP, just answering for myself: I definitely would.

But I don't.

Because without making it a full time hobby, it's impossible for me to know that the money will actually be spent on the animals' lifestyle and not on the lifestyle of their owners. Or even more likely, that of some intermediary. Also I don't really know if 2x would even be enough to offset the extra cost given the high efficiency of factory farming. The only practical way is improving minimum standards through regulation. Sorry free market, you are too opaque.

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by username90 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:44PM (#21671131)
That reasoning works just as well for human labor, we could always spend more to help the poor but we don't. At some point idealism hits reality and you have to make a trade-off. And at least I think it is better to give them 1x than 0x. And if some laws comes in saying that meat needs to cost 2x to give them decent conditions then I'd still buy meat. We even already have many such laws, so I'm not sure why people say that we don't care.
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by __s on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:04PM (#21671266)
My primary issue for paying premium for "the more ethical product" is that transparency is lacking, so I can't know whether I'd be only paying more to make myself feel better
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by dr_dshiv on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:51PM (#21671179)
I'm not talking about being nice out of naive altruism, I'm talking about the selfish desire for karmic serenity. Sure, we could always act like assholes, but for many of us it doesn't feel good. That was Adam Smith's first book, "theory of moral sentiments", if you are into that sort of thing.
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by jancsika on Saturday November 30, 2019 @07:04PM (#21672882)
I'll pay you 1000x for the patent on the system that allows me to verify at the supermarket that the meat I'm buying came from the beach ball cows
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by dr_dshiv on Sunday December 01, 2019 @04:49AM (#21674738)
Pay these guys. Be sure to have your Dutch translation on. It's on nearly every piece of meat in the major stores in the Netherlands.

https://beterleven.dierenbescherming.nl/

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by Footkerchief on Saturday November 30, 2019 @02:17PM (#21671666)
The above comment may read to some like a facile argument, but it expresses an important problem in some formulations of utilitarian ethics:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by ben_w on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:47PM (#21672810)
None of the logic in that argument would change if I replaced “beef” with “long pork”.

Personally, I don’t claim to know how much “personhood”[0] a cow has. It’s possible they don’t count and we shouldn’t care. But it’s only consistent to say “the meat industry is good for cows“ if you also say “the cannibalism industry is good for humans”.

Not that I’m doing a great job of being a morally consistent person myself, as I’m only vegetarian, and dairy is also really bad for bovine welfare, what with the forced pregnancies and slaughtered newborn calves.

[0] for lack of a better term — I know some people regard “person” as a synonym for “human”, but “self aware” and “sentient” are just as bad.

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by Noos on Saturday November 30, 2019 @03:57PM (#21672103)
Yeah, the main poster doesn't get that the end result of veganism is the relegation of food species to very expensive, very impractical pets that many people won't see outside of youtube or in protected areas.
Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by hombre_fatal on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:12PM (#21672168)
Well, they probably do understand that but reject that on the same grounds they reject raising humans just to harvest their organs when they're 10 years old no matter how great of a life they had up until they were lead into the operating room. And organs actually save lives.

It seems obviously unethical to me to raise a sentient organism (human or cow or cat) just to kill it prematurely for what's purely a luxury good for most people. Giving it a beach ball to play with seems completely ethically inconsequential.

I wonder how many people who assert how great of a life this must be, only to be killed at someone else's pleasure, would accept this life for themselves or their children or even their pets. And they certainly buy their meat from the supermarket where their meat never got to play with a beach ball, anyways. It's closer to ethics-at-a-distance fantasy and utopian thought experiments instead of anything grounded in the horrors of reality.

Re:Giant tortoises show surprising cognitive powers by ben_w on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:52PM (#21672823)
Why do you consider that outcome to be bad?