News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by burnte on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:41PM (#21671110)
No it shouldn't. Every state has elected judge positions, and they only require being able to win an election. In my home state of PA a local magistrate was caught by the FBI trying to fix cases of people who appealed her judgments, was removed from the bench for 6 months, and still ran for reelection unopposed. The people we let get elected to judicial positions is scary.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by chongli on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:02PM (#21671253)
Judges shouldn’t be elected at all, they should be appointed in a non partisan process, from a pool of experienced and respected lawyers.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by SamReidHughes on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:14PM (#21671315)
That is by construction a partisan process, with the outcome matching politics of the median lawyer, instead of the median voter.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by michaelmrose on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:24PM (#21671367)
You want medical practice dispensed by the median doctor not the median patient. The median voter already sits on juries.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by roenxi on Saturday November 30, 2019 @04:04PM (#21672138)
But the only similarity between a judge and a doctor is they both traditionally require degrees. If we accept that a judge doesn't need a degree then there is no comparison to a doctor. Ie, that is probably a form of circular reasoning.

Degrees might be a reasonable proxy for general intelligence which is nice to have in a judge, but so is popular support. We already let any fool off the street write the law, they should also be qualified to interpret the law.

Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by chongli on Saturday November 30, 2019 @06:25PM (#21672717)
they should also be qualified to interpret the law

The problem with this is that our system is built on literally centuries of case law, in addition to all the legislation. Fools off the street don't know any of that stuff. Are we going to wait around while they spend weeks doing the research for every case?

We already let any fool off the street write the law

Foolish legislators often have their laws struck down for being unconstitutional. If we're going to let fools also be judges, then the inmates are running the asylum and we might as well not have a constitution at all.

Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by chongli on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:19PM (#21671343)
Partisanship is a state of mind moreso than a formal system. Judicial appointments in Canada are non partisan. The politicians who appoint them are operating under the principle of “who would be the best judge from among these candidates” rather than who is my closest ally.

Elected judges are entirely the opposite.

It sounds like the entire judicial branch of the United States has become politicized. That’s really unfortunate. It’s not the case in other countries.

Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by SamReidHughes on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:26PM (#21671378)
That's a result of how the federal/state constitutions here work. Judges don't matter as much if Parliament is sovereign.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by refurb on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:57PM (#21671564)
Judicial appointments in Canada are non partisan.

Take a look at the backgrounds of the judges who are appointed and tell me it’s not partisan in Canada.

Usually the liberals appoint judges with close Liberal Party ties and the same with the conservatives.

Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by Spooky23 on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:30PM (#21671409)
New York does this in NYC for traffic court... they use administrative law judges who are civil service employees to adjudicate traffic violations.

Most places outside of NYC prefer to have elected judges “town/village justices” for revenue purposes. Basically, they plea down as many state violations as possible to local ordinances, as more of the fines go to the towns instead of the state.

Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by snagglegaggle on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:12PM (#21671306)
The law is supposed to be relatable and human. It is already twisted enough as it is, I would hate to see it under that kind of system.
Re:South Carolina judges often lack formal training in the law by chongli on Saturday November 30, 2019 @01:15PM (#21671326)
So in other words, you would hate to see the legal system in Canada? Because that’s how it is here. We don’t elect judges at any level. We seem to be getting along just fine.