On the supply side (while TFA looks legit) people who are a few lessons ahead want to increase their visibility, start a blog/brand, make their CV stand out by showing community engagement and writing from a position of authority. This is mostly seen on Medium.
How to avoid the trap of being an eternal beginner? Accept that it will take time, be clear on your goals, try gathering a group of peers and expert guidance. Reddit and forums can be crap for this as you the beginner will gravitate towards the self proclaimed experts who may be full of shit and just play social games well, creating a blind leading the blind situation and cargo culting around terms that nobody really understands. There is a value in universities: they lay out a path, give guidance and let you work/learn together with peers. Ok, enough with this rant.
I give you an analogy. Electricity. Who needs to know complex numbers and differential equations to understand electricity? Technician, civil engineer, scientist or research engineer?
Technician who just wires the house don't need math. They just read the wiring instructions and follow standard practices. Nvidia boasts about the tools it builds for 'ML technicians' in this analogy.
You need to know math if you are building new architectures and applying complex models for something nontrivial. It's not going to work first time and you need to know what's going on. Even if you are the 'civil engineer' in this analogy you should be able to read the math and understand it even if you don't do the math by yourself. You won't be able to do literary research and learn new stuff if you can't read math fluently.
If you are programmer who is given ML tools to implement something someone else designed and understand you don't need this or use existing models, you don't need this. Your career might benefit from knowing it but you can manage without.
Undergraduates, or graduate students who didn't happen to take the right prerequisites. Most STEM degrees require vector calculus, but few require matrix calculus. A physics undergrad might see matrix calculus if they studied general relativity, or math undergrad interested in optimization or differential geometry. A statistics major might have seen it when working with multivariate distributions and regression. But it would be easy to miss.
Nevertheless, matrix calculus, which is not in fact a large subject, but only some new notation and a handful of theorems, is the key to understanding back-propagation. It's not the only way to approach it - you could just keep track of all those subscripts and indices - but it's one of the best. The differential form[1] is particularly good to learn because it maps almost 1-1 onto the error terms in a gradient descent implementation.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matrix_calculus#Identities_in_...
> So it’s for people that have been getting into DL but also haven’t bothered or needed to look up the math concepts?
Everyone has to start somewhere. The usual pedagogical technique to teach a subject twice: once at an "undergraduate" level, omitting the technical details of proofs, with the goal of providing a big picture intuitive understanding of the subject and some practical symbol pushing ability; then again at the "graduate" level, with more formal definitions and detailed proofs. Your own education presumably used this structure, no? Even if you've already graduated, this "two pass" approach to learning new material is still a good idea. Few of us are von Neumann, able to dive immediately into the deepest depths of theory in a new field: we can all benefit from taking the time to develop some good intuitions first.
This is where all textbooks come from - a lecturer presents the material the way that seems clearest to them. They prepare notes to keep everything straight in their own head. Sometimes they find that their presentation resonates with students and is superior to what's currently available, so they start to develop their notes into something publishable. Most such projects get abandoned before too long, but many end up in some form on the internet, and a few go on to be developed into standard texts. As long as you can find even one new way to explain things that helps students, the exercise is not in vain.
Gradients, Jacobians, etc are typically covered in a multivariable calculus class along with vector calculus (line integrals, Green's theorem, Stoke's theorem, etc). This is required for engineering and physics degrees.
Pick any journey to any destination. This article occurs at many points along them.
Need to have a thorough understanding of math? Then this is a starting point.
Don't? then this is an endpoint.
I agree with your assessment that's it doesn't have much practical use on its own, nor is it an efficient means to any particular end.
Edit: Just noticed the other author is the creator of ANTLR, which I recall using in school to write our own languages. Cool!
In physics we did matrix calculus primarily for electromagnetism and fluid dynamics. Maxwell's equations are the first time most students see the div/curl operator and it's also used in e.g. Navier-Stokes. But even though we were taught it, I don't think we really bothered to remember what a "Jacobian" is.
A lot of this stuff also comes up in physical rendering.
For example: a large number of clustering methods boil down to matrix factorization, with variations in the constraints. If you have both domain understanding and a general understanding of what kind of output these variations are likely to result in, you can often narrow down the list of methods you need to try.
Also, interviews.
In ~July 2016 I was at a presentation by NVidia at GW in DC. They showed off how easy it was to build out and train a model using some of their tooling (Digits maybe?). After the demo they opened it up for questions and a grad student ‘asked’ “You just did in 10 mins with 30 lines of code what I worked on for an entire semester”.
That’s been the trajectory of the tools and increasing abstraction in this space. It’s just getting easier and easier to build models that work (which is great), and it gets easier and easier to do so without knowing more than an extremely high level overview of the math behind it all.
So while this looks like a great resource - who’s it for?
For jobs/problems that need you to have a thorough understanding of the math and theory behind the networks this isn’t going to cut it.
For jobs/problems that need you to get something working math or not - this likely isn’t necessary to get started.
So it’s for people that have been getting into DL but also haven’t bothered or needed to look up the math concepts?