News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Man or boy test by number6 on Thursday November 28, 2019 @01:41AM (#21655105)
As we read things from the past it is as if we travel into the past not that we summon the author into our time. Always kept that in mind. The author himself is a product of his time not of ours.
Re:Man or boy test by bethly on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:20AM (#21655527)
It's not like he's from the Middle Ages or something; 1964 is within living memory.
Re:Man or boy test by coldtea on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:02AM (#21657781)
For one, culture norms can change in less than a decade, much less 1964. In 1964 there was still legal segregation in the US. And whatever you think "natural" today might not be considered so in 2030 or 2040, much less 2019 + (2019-1964).

Second, it's not like the terms men and boys don't carry different attributes still today, or just because the anglosaxon culture is going through an Emo hyper-sensitive phase that everybody of the 8 billions in the world will have qualms to use the terms "men" and "boys" in such a matter (more capable, more mature, etc).

Re:Man or boy test by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:28AM (#21655553)
We're riding an exponent in everything around us, culture included - not just in amount of transistors per silicon wafer. 2019 is much more different from 2009 than 1974 was from 1964.
Re:Man or boy test by growlist on Thursday November 28, 2019 @04:49AM (#21655900)
> We're riding an exponent in everything around us, culture included

Popular culture perhaps - but in my experience there's a massive yawning chasm between 'woke' culture and the culture of the majority of the population, which has remained remarkably sceptical. The whole pronouns thing for example would still get very strange looks down the pub.

Re:Man or boy test by TeMPOraL on Thursday November 28, 2019 @05:01AM (#21655966)
That the chasm exists matters too. I doubt that this submission would spur HN comments accusing it of sexism 10 years ago.
Re:Man or boy test by Cougher on Thursday November 28, 2019 @05:15AM (#21656029)
"2019 is much more different from 2009 than 1974 was from 1964."

I call your exponential change and raise you with recency bias.

Re:Man or boy test by coldtea on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:04AM (#21657796)
And I call your recency bias and raise a "things have always been the same" bias.

Whether exponential or not, we've had more culture-defininging technological, lifestyle, and moral changes in the past 200 years than in the previous 3000.

Re:Man or boy test by ranko on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:25AM (#21657915)
I'm not sure that I agree, given that those 3,000 years encompass the beginnings of (amongst other things) Christianity, Islam and Buddhism, as well as the development of printing, explosives, and algebra.
Re:Man or boy test by coldtea on Thursday November 28, 2019 @11:30AM (#21658485)
Christianity unfolded over 2000 years. It took around 500-600 years to dominate Europe, it wasn't some huge sudden shift.

Algebra didn't matter much (as far as life changing applications) for most of the time after its invention until around the industrial age. Then we had a huge math explosion, and a huge science explosion, physics, chemistry, etc plus practical applications as advanced as sending people to the moon.

Explosives and printing are part of the exponential curve we talk about. We went from knives, swords, arrows (used for millennia) to crude explosives to nuclear weapons and rockets between 500 years or so.

Same for printing. We went from stone carving, papyri, hand copying and limited literacy for millennia, to the printing press, mandatory mass education, and onwards to computers, and the internet, and now whole world knowledge reachable in one's pocket wherever they are in the span of 400 years or so.

Every day life in most of the world wasn't much different between 500 B.C and 1800 B.C. Ancient Rome, or Medieval Paris, could as well be Ancient Babylon. In villages life was almost entirely the same. The slow cultural changes (the introduction of Christianity, the change in rulers, etc) didn't change or affect much of everyday life.

Re:Man or boy test by Cougher on Thursday November 28, 2019 @11:17AM (#21658358)
This is a pretty bizarre take on my post.
Re:Man or boy test by dbcurtis on Thursday November 28, 2019 @08:11AM (#21657029)
2019 is nearly identical to 2009 when compared to the gap between 1967 and 1970. 1968 was a watershed year, 1969 not far behind.
Re:Man or boy test by ido on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:39AM (#21655592)
Is it? I wasn't around for 1964 but 2009->2019 doesn't seem like a greater leap than 1989->1999 was.
Re:Man or boy test by cthor on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:45AM (#21655629)
Bigger leap when it comes to finger wagging over word choice, smaller leap when it comes to things that actually matter.
Re:Man or boy test by kungtotte on Thursday November 28, 2019 @05:20AM (#21656050)
People can't only be judged on where they are right now, you have to include cultural and sociological aspects as well.

I would consider myself open minded and liberal and for lack of a better term, "woke". But I was born in the 80s to parents who were born in the 60s and their parents in turn were born in the 30s and so on. So my parents were raised with some racism and a bunch of sexism. That meant I grew up with a bit less racism and declining sexism, but those things were still there.

In my teens I used "gay" as a slur.

Am I awful? Can you take one look at a forum post I made in the late 90s and judge me entirely? I'm doing my best now to fix these things so hopefully my son will grow up with none of this cultural and sociological baggage, but I'm not a bad person for acting in accordance with the times 20 years ago. Nor were my parents in the 80s. Nor was Knuth in the 60s.

Is it okay what he did? No, of course not. But let's not hang the man for something that wouldn't have raised an eyebrow at the time.

Re:Man or boy test by coldtea on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:05AM (#21657799)
>Am I awful? Can you take one look at a forum post I made in the late 90s and judge me entirely?

The opposite. I'd judge anybody judging a person from a 90s forum post as awful scum themselves.

>Is it okay what he did? No, of course not.

Yes it is. It's not even that controversial. Men and boys, whether one is woke or not, have some different characteristics, age, maturity, strength, etc, being some of them. That was the purpose of the analogy, which was, and remains, a common idiom across the globe.

Is it okay for 2019 people of a particular (woke) subset of a particular (Anglo-Saxon) culture to impose whatever latest retrospective moral panics they have on everybody? No. For one, that's cultural imperialism...

Re:Man or boy test by goatinaboat on Thursday November 28, 2019 @10:58AM (#21658183)
hopefully my son will grow up with none of this cultural and sociological baggage

It might be worth considering that you are simply replacing it with other baggage that will seem equally antiquated eventually.

Re:Man or boy test by iiv on Thursday November 28, 2019 @05:54AM (#21656197)
>Is it okay what he did?

Of course.

Re:Man or boy test by dunefox on Thursday November 28, 2019 @06:46AM (#21656492)
This is a test that concerns maturity, not 'better or worse'. It's perfectly adequate to say this these days as well. Please stop with this stuff.
Re:Man or boy test by lgeorget on Thursday November 28, 2019 @05:24AM (#21656066)
It doesn't imply better or worse, it just means than one compiler is more experienced than the other since it doesn't fall for the traps that get the other one caught, presumably due to the experience put into its development.
Re:Man or boy test by nayuki on Thursday November 28, 2019 @11:22AM (#21658408)
Factually speaking, a man refers to the grown-up version of a boy. This is not a value judgement, just a statement about developmental progression. In this sense, it is justified to distinguish "man or boy?" for programming languages that have primitive features/behaviors versus more developed features.
Re:Man or boy test by lopmotr on Thursday November 28, 2019 @02:36AM (#21655332)
The definition of boy is literally an immature man who lacks some qualities. It's entirely appropriate.
[dead]
Re:Man or boy test by felixyz on Thursday November 28, 2019 @04:33AM (#21655816)
"delightfully anachronistic" - did you, and everyone else, miss that appreciative adjective? Even one of those "sentiment analysis" models would have been able to correctly classify this.
Re:Man or boy test by dunefox on Thursday November 28, 2019 @06:58AM (#21656559)
That's the point, it's not anachronistic.