News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by teamjimmyy on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:30PM (#21651758)
We now have trackers acting like first-party properties, but where do you draw the line between first-party and third-party? What I mean is, if I build my own in-house analytics app that does a lot of what Adobe's product does, should that be blocked too?

I specifically mean for site analytics, like Experience Cloud or GA, not serving ads. Ad block is different IMO.

If this is hosted on a first party subdomain you're already blocking the ability of it to set third-party cookies and track you across sites. So, in practical terms, what's the difference between this CNAME trick and building the same thing in-house to run your own analytics?

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by munchbunny on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @03:44PM (#21651909)
It depends on why you care about the distinction. If you're talking from a purely privacy perspective, the important questions are (1) are you taking analytics? (2) what are you doing with them? (3) is that in line with users' expectations?

Third party, or third party disguised as first party, is only problematic because of an implied "there's very little keeping the third party from using your data for things that aren't just analytics for the first party." It's the red flag for "this site may not be using your data the way you would want it to."

Third party ad trackers disguised as first party cookies specifically violate the general assumption that first party data stays first party, because those third parties have specific mechanisms to track you across multiple first parties.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by x0x0 on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:39PM (#21654619)
> violate the general assumption that first party data stays first party

How? Because they can't do that with cookies.

I think the most prominent objection to 3rd party cookies is they allow systematic tracking. This seems like they just help eg apple or whomever understand what you're doing on that same site.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by munchbunny on Thursday November 28, 2019 @02:52PM (#21659778)
> How? Because they can't do that with cookies.

My point is exactly that: they can and are doing it (using first party cookies through CNAME redirects to correlate your identity across multiple independent sites in order to sell a data product to more than just the first party). For an example, see Criteo.

> I think the most prominent objection to 3rd party cookies is they allow systematic tracking.

And now first party cookies are starting to be used for that too. It's not that important how you specifically want to phrase the general ickiness of third party cookies.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by zonidjan on Thursday November 28, 2019 @12:21AM (#21654784)
There are plenty of other ways to fingerprint a user. https://amiunique.org/
Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by x0x0 on Thursday November 28, 2019 @04:10AM (#21655725)
That really doesn't answer the question. Munchberry claims these analytics tools have cross domain tracking and I'm asking how, precisely. In part because of professional interest, and in part because I don't actually think it's true.
Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by munchbunny on Thursday November 28, 2019 @02:58PM (#21659813)
Thanks for getting my username right. ;)

You specifically got one detail wrong: it's not just for analytics tools. It's the adtech industry in general using this technique, and Adobe offers its analytics as part of its marketing software suite.

From their own site: "What is Adobe Experience Cloud? It's a collection of best-in-class solutions for marketing, analytics, advertising, and commerce."

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by x0x0 on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:37PM (#21660037)
Apologies Munch bunny, gonna blame that on a need for new glasses.

fwiw, Adobe Experience Cloud is generally not the sort of adtech that attempts to sell information.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by munchbunny on Monday December 02, 2019 @04:43PM (#21687316)
You're right, Adobe Experience Cloud doesn't sell information, so how problematic you find the product depends on where you draw the line on privacy.

Specifically, Adobe Experience Cloud definitely offers retargeting capabilities (ads following you around the internet) and the ability to get statistics on the effectiveness of that advertising. If they're at parity with competing marketing suites, then they also have attribution capabilities to track you with per-user, per-interaction granularity.

A site that serves Adobe Experience Cloud cookies in the third-party-disguised-as-first-party way is likely enabling this capability for all marketers that are going through Adobe Experience Cloud. So the interesting question would be whether you, a visitor to Fox.com, consider being watched by marketers who aren't Fox.com to be a privacy problem.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by x0x0 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:36PM (#21695818)
All of the above is more private than eg google analytics because of the lack of cross domain tracking... I'd consider it a big improvement vis-a-vis google's product suite.
Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by 3xblah on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @05:31PM (#21652823)
"So, in practical terms, what's the difference between this CNAME trick and building the same thing in-house to run your own analytics?"

In practical terms, based on what we have seen up to now, few websites will run their own analytics.

Thus, focusing on the third party services is effective against most tracking.

The "CNAME trick" might be viewed as a good thing because it is putting evolutionary pressure on users to utilise DNS to "block" ads instead of using popular graphical web browsers to do the work. These browsers are written by companies or organisations that derive substantial revenue from online advertising.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by icebraining on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @07:15PM (#21653540)
> it is putting evolutionary pressure on users to utilise DNS to "block" ads instead of using popular graphical web browsers to do the work

How so? Browser and browser addons are perfectly capable of blocking these subdomains.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by garren on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @09:33PM (#21654183)
It's not that browser add-ons aren't capable of blocking them, it's that a) browser extensions generally don't have access to dns resolution, b) even if they did, cname tracker resolution would increase overall latency due to multiple requests to identify trackers /outside/ of normal resolution, c) it's trivial for a host to create a new cname for a tracker, so automating this makes a lot of sense from their perspective in order to avoid blocklists.

Extensions now have to identify which cnames are a front for which trackers, block the new tracker, and somehow manage to stay below the max rules-per-extension that the browser allows (30k for Chrome[0]). See original nextdns.io post for details [1].

[0] https://www.xda-developers.com/google-chrome-manifest-v3-ad-...

[1] https://medium.com/nextdns/cname-cloaking-the-dangerous-disg... ( https://outline.com/Y6PKr3 )

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by bscphil on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @10:48PM (#21654446)
> it's trivial for a host to create a new cname for a tracker, so automating this makes a lot of sense from their perspective in order to avoid blocklists.

This is the part I'm skeptical of. If your site is HTTPS, and a user forbids mixed content, all your ads have to be served over HTTPS. That means whenever you create a new CNAME, the ad server (not run by you) has to generate a new certificate, or else you have to give them a cert for *.yourdomain.com. Both are pretty big asks. Even if the ad server can automatically generate new certs, they're going to show up in a transparency log and can be automatically added to blocklists based on that.

So I'm not sure it's going to make much of a difference which blocking method people use. All the Easylist (or whoever) folks have to do is add new subdomains to their blocklist - the exact same thing an ad blocking DNS provider is doing.

Edit: the process for obtaining a certificate from Adobe for a new tracking CNAME looks absolutely excruciating, which is good evidence for my point. https://docs.adobe.com/content/help/en/core-services/interfa...

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by 3xblah on Thursday November 28, 2019 @12:00AM (#21654704)
"... the exact same thing an ad blocking DNS provider is doing."

Just to be clear, I was not advocating using third party DNS.

Using djbdns I can just "block" all non-www subdomains for a domain with a single line in a zone file (if using tinydns) or a single byte file in a directory (if using dnscache) and then add entries in the zone file for any specific subdomains I want to "allow".

It is only an opinion, but I think the ability to wildcard all subdomains makes DNS-based methods of blocking trackers easier to manage and allows it to scale better than having to list every tracker subdomain in a blocklist.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by bscphil on Thursday November 28, 2019 @03:38AM (#21655590)
> Just to be clear, I was not advocating using third party DNS.

Well, you weren't, but the OP is a Show HN by a company offering such a service.

> It is only an opinion, but I think the ability to wildcard all subdomains makes DNS-based methods of blocking trackers easier to manage

I dunno, I think for most people uBlock rules are going to be easier to handle then setting up their own DNS server. Sure, I have my own resolver too (Unbound), but since you need an ad blocker on top of that anyway, I just keep my rules in uBlock. The following is all you need to block all subdomains but allow the bare domain:

  ||example.org^
  @@*/example.org/*
Or to allow www:

  @@www.example.org^
Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by 3xblah on Thursday November 28, 2019 @12:21PM (#21658862)
With uBlock, is it possible to block all subdomains but allow a specific subdomain?

A resolver (e.g., unbound) is only one half of the DNS method I use. The other is an authoritative nameserver (e.g., nsd). For my own purposes, the resolver is optional.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by bscphil on Friday November 29, 2019 @01:40PM (#21666007)
Yes, that's just this:

  ||example.org^
  @@www.example.org^
> The other is an authoritative nameserver (e.g., nsd). For my own purposes, the resolver is optional.

True, although I imagine for most people the nameserver part of it is the more optional. DNS ad blocking software tends to be a recursive resolver that returns 0.0.0.0 results for some unwanted domains. Unbound has the ability to do that (for the few domains I'm filtering entirely), and so I've stuck with that.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by 3xblah on Saturday November 30, 2019 @12:28AM (#21668722)
It is no wonder that uBlock is so popular.

Not sure I understand returning 0.0.0.0. What if the user has some other servers listening.

I return the address of some server I control that is bound to a local address, e.g., an authoritative nameserver.

Compared to the available solutions this is way too much work for "most people", however from a purist perspective a self-managed DNS approach is not under the ultimate control of a browser-authoring, extension/app-approving company/organisation or some third party DNS provider.

Whether that even matters is debatable.

As long as these easy solutions keep working, there's no incentive to try a different approach.

Re:Show HN: TrackingTheTrackers – Is a website disguising it... by egdod on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @11:27PM (#21654578)
All analytics should be blocked.