I think there are valid philosophical differences that significantly affect how the system interprets technicalities. I understand the US takes an approach that's much like code: specify everything precisely in great detail, and technicalities and loopholes can be exploited to subvert the original intent of the law. I may be mistaken on this, but understand the EU tends to laws that specify broader principles, so technicalities and loopholes aren't as useful.
The US approach leads to more precise and consistent application, at the expense of flexibility and achieving the original purpose of the law easier to subvert or avoid. The EU approach leads to less consistent application in corner cases, but is more flexible and harder to subvert the original purpose.
Apologies if I got the EU case wrong, please correct me if I did.
Personally I wish the US tended more towards the EU approach: so in this case if California law mandates public beach access, Khosla needs to provide it somehow, and can't weasel out of it on a technicality.
Much of Europe works with civil law where everything is expected to be codified beforehand. Past cases have little bearing on how a new one will be decided.
Technical and principled? Yes
Precise? If that particular scenario has been anticipated and coded for, yes.
Consistent? No
Of course the facts being the same is the big "if". Jury verdicts are also not strictly bound to precedent the way judges are.
I'm talking about civil law or codified jurisdictions. The ancestor comment confused the US for being a (mostly) codified system, which is why I quoted that, but it was really about describing civil law as being "precise and consistent".
In hindsight I see that it's confusing...
I think people may be misunderstanding here a bit. This case is regarding access above the high tide line. Access below the high tide line is not in question. I'm just thinking from a lot of the comments I'm reading on both sides of this issue that people really aren't quite grasping the question being settled.
In essence, the only thing being debated, is whether or not Khosla has to provide a road and convenient parking above the beach. Predictably, the courts are saying the obvious, "No he doesn't." Why? Because he is obliged by law to make the beach below the high tide line accessible.
FOMB will likely lose their case because, as a series of judges are now making more clear, the public is only entitled to keep the beach proper public. (ie-below the high tide line.)
Also, the courts are not being paid off here by the wealthy in an attempt to disenfranchise the public. The base issue is one of definitions. Obviously, globally speaking, high tide line has served as a fairly convenient, and somewhat obvious definition of "beach". The question you have to answer if you change that is, if the property line is not at the high tide line, then where is it? That's the point at which you start to run into problems, with some saying it's high tide plus maybe 100m? Others might say high tide plus 400m, while still others could claim high tide plus 800m and on, and on, and on.
It seems perfectly sensible to me to require a public access easement to reach the beach below the high tide line. It's a mockery of public access if the only access is by sea.
> FOMB will likely lose their case because, as a series of judges are now making more clear, the public is only entitled to keep the beach proper public. (ie-below the high tide line.)
If you're correct, the law should be amended to require a public access easement.
Also:
>It's a mockery of public access if the only access is by sea
It's the high tide line that is the marker, not the low tide line. So access is always by land.
The issue is that the current custom is to access via the road and parking above the high tide line. That's what locals are accustomed to, that's what is being taken away by Khosla, and that's what the suit is about.
It's the public version of squatters rights, and you can't claim squatters rights if you've been paying rent the whole time.
The US has certainly leaned more towards codification since it's inception, but it is still primarily and very much a common law jurisdiction at heart.
What you're overlooking is that laws are often compromises, and governments routinely invoke "the spirit of the law" to end-run around previously made compromises.[1] That's why the US approach is such a stickler for things like textualism (which is associated with conservatives, but is in reality the default interpretive style on both the left and right). "I'm only going to give you as much as I agreed on paper to give you and not an inch more."
[1] A great example of this is the Clean Water Act. There is a ton of fighting over what the phrase "waters of the united states" means. A bi-partisan coalition passed the CWA, intending it to allow the federal government to clean up the country's lakes and rivers. Lately, however, the same law has been interpreted to give the government authority to basically engage in building permitting involving "wetlands" that may be far from the sorts of lakes and rivers that Congress originally sought to address.
We're talking about the compound H2O which isn't considered "water" until it reaches a lake, river, sea.
My bad.
One billionaire can easily have a full-time team working for him to defend his case, and also buy politicians to do the same. In an oligarchy, technicalities can easily become tools of power.
Initially, access was completely free, then the government allowed one owner to collect parking fees from visitors, and now they try to ban all public access outright... Then before you know it, in line with historical technical trends, they will put us all in cages and force us to work for free.
The law is not about technicalities at all, that's BS. The law is irrational; it's all about feelings. It should reflect how the average person feels about things. That's why criminal court cases have a jury instead of a computer to decide on the verdict.
Justice depends on poorly written, easily hacked code with almost no amount of security team or patching, and also the security team is paid off.