Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access
by specialist on Wednesday November 27, 2019 @12:51AM
(#21645605)
Water tends to eventually cycle thru rivers and then oceans. Even if it's temporarily stuck in ponds, humans, snow globes and whatnot.
Re:Vinod Khosla Wins Ruling Threatening Public Beach Access
by specialist on Thursday November 28, 2019 @08:03PM
(#21661185)
Oh.
We're talking about the compound H2O which isn't considered "water" until it reaches a lake, river, sea.
My bad.
What you're overlooking is that laws are often compromises, and governments routinely invoke "the spirit of the law" to end-run around previously made compromises.[1] That's why the US approach is such a stickler for things like textualism (which is associated with conservatives, but is in reality the default interpretive style on both the left and right). "I'm only going to give you as much as I agreed on paper to give you and not an inch more."
[1] A great example of this is the Clean Water Act. There is a ton of fighting over what the phrase "waters of the united states" means. A bi-partisan coalition passed the CWA, intending it to allow the federal government to clean up the country's lakes and rivers. Lately, however, the same law has been interpreted to give the government authority to basically engage in building permitting involving "wetlands" that may be far from the sorts of lakes and rivers that Congress originally sought to address.