It's of note that those comments were on a HN story that was posted by pinksoda, is hosted on sinkfloat.com, and has BrianHolt responding in the comments as the subject of the article. That alone seems to link them all together and make the whole thing fishy.
Re:Tell HN: There is a Scammer Amongst Us
by taylorbuley on Monday January 31, 2011 @08:04PM
(#2163949)
It looks like he's responding to each individual comment thread, as if to try to get people to notice via their threads link
Re:Tell HN: There is a Scammer Amongst Us
by fakelvis on Tuesday February 01, 2011 @03:21AM
(#2164875)
I see a lot of upset and accusations without many facts from either side. Without the pertinent information being clearly presented (read: facts and facts only, no accusations), it seems that we can't make an informed decision on what is really going on.
I'm happy to be corrected, and I am sorry that this has happened to you, but we must realize that there is a huge difference between a scam and a private business transaction that was conducted without proper due diligence that ended in one person feeling cheated.
Which of these two has occurred here is difficult to tell with the facts being presented, and without us playing amateur detective.
As raganwald said, "While anyone who invests money and gets nothing in return has my sympathy, I don't see the relevance of a private business transaction to HN." [1]
I hope this gets sorted out for you, and please correct me if I'm wrong.
jiganti was helped by mahmud
yesterday, lrm242 investigated X and turned up addresses (Chinese) etc. from DNS
lrm242 is now being libelled on complaints forums, as of yesterday
X appears to have several HN accounts: pinksoda, sinkfloat, and BrianHolt
Vaguely interestingly, Totiboti (now auto-dead - you need to turn on showdead to see his posts) was warning about the guy repeatedly: http://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=Totiboti