News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by kevin_thibedeau on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:06PM (#21634326)
These machines are sizeable and you can't just retrofit every existing store by fiat. Then, why shouldn't other special interest groups with dietary restrictions be able to impose their will too? We can have a flame broiler with separate meatatarian, vegan, halal, kosher, and hindu conveyors, all with their own exhaust management to ensure harmful vapors don't migrate where they would contaminate the other product lines.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by bsder on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:01PM (#21634728)
> Then, why shouldn't other special interest groups with dietary restrictions be able to impose their will too? We can have a flame broiler with separate meatatarian, vegan, halal, kosher, and hindu conveyors, all with their own exhaust management to ensure harmful vapors don't migrate where they would contaminate the other product lines.

BK chose this product and marketing specifically to cater to a special interest group with dietary restrictions. No one is demanding that BK must serve vegan food other than by usual consumer pressure.

The problem is that BK really doesn't give one iota of damn about the strict vegans. They're not coming to BK no matter what as only an idiot would believe that there exists any surface in a BK that isn't contaminated with meat. What BK cares about are the "sorta-vegan" folks who happen to be tagging along when the whole group hits BK. However, "Vegan enough that you can be a poseur and rationalize it" doesn't have the same ad copy quality.

However, bringing this back to specifics, someone who is halal should not be able to complain about going into a BBQ joint. However, if said BBQ joint claims to be halal, then it better comply. And if a someone halal decides to sue for your restaurant not being compliant, they deserve to win.

(And, what you forget, is that a lot of the "anti-pork" proscriptions came about as a way to avoid trichinosis. So, if it weren't for modern meat handling, this would be a health issue as well as a religious one.)

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cookie_monsta on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:21PM (#21634405)
Sure, and if BK decides to market specifically to people with meatatarian, vegan, halal, kosher, and hindu dietary requirements you would expect them to actually deliver, not just pay lip service - the same as any other offer in the marketplace.

This "impossible burger" isn't the result of vegans picketing BK HQ - it's a marketing ploy by BK... how are vegans being painted as the bad guys here?

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by LegitShady on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:25PM (#21634434)
Because suddenly to make them happy each store requires thousands of dollars in new equipment.

It's not just offering the product it's requiring a separate process for it that costs money to each franchisee

The impossible burger is a product. The demands are the result of these people not impossible burger

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cookie_monsta on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:29PM (#21634454)
Well, let's extend that argument out to the marketplace: Any company can make any claim they want about their products and then if it becomes too expensive to actually deliver that product they can swap in something inferior and in fact contrary to the original offer.

This is a problem between BK management and the franchises. You can't blame the consumer for expecting to receive the product as advertised. If it's too complicated to produce, don't offer it.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by learc83 on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:45PM (#21634579)
If it rounds down to 0, most marketing is allowed some margin of error.

You can put 0 grams fat per serving on a product that actually has 0.01 grams of fat.

If a vegan restaurant advertises 0% animal products I guarantee that is also incorrect. There is some small percentage of insect parts in almost everything.

Obviously there is some margin.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cookie_monsta on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:12PM (#21634792)
I think incidental insect parts are different to a production process that guarantees the product will be coated in animal fat.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by learc83 on Monday November 25, 2019 @09:36PM (#21635190)
It's cooked on a grill that is used for meat. How much animal fat it picks up is to be determined, but my guess is that by weight it still rounds down to 0. From my experience with grills I doubt it's very much at all.

Clearly there is some threshold. What is it? 1 part per thousand? 1 part per billion?

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by gregoryl on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @12:51AM (#21635924)
Can you not see the difference between the two?

In one case, the result is occasional accidental contamination, in the other, the product is intentionally placed on a contaminated surface.

I don't think anyone is expecting perfection, but there is no reasonable effort being made to avoid this problem for a product that BK advertises as "0% beef".

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by learc83 on Tuesday November 26, 2019 @09:36AM (#21638579)
>but there is no reasonable effort being made to avoid this problem for a product that BK advertises as "0% beef

Adding an extra grill to the restaurant isn't reasonable. Apparently they will microwave it if you ask.

However, the entire kitchen is covered in grease, it's a burger king. There's going to be some amount of cross contamination no matter what they do. They may be able to reduce it from 0.01% beef to 0.001% beef, but who cares? Who is ok with 1 part in 100,000, but not 1 part in 10,000?

There's no functional difference unless you have an allergy and that happens to be the threshold.

If you aren't OK with eating something to that touched meat and may contain trace amounts of beef, don't eat at a Burger restaurant.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by riwsky on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:43PM (#21634557)
I agree—a demand to retrofit everything isn’t feasible. But the demand isn’t “buy the new equipment”; the demand is “Buy the new equipment OR change your marketing to accurately reflect your equipment situation”.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by kevin_thibedeau on Monday November 25, 2019 @11:37PM (#21635675)
The word "vegan" is not regulated in the US. If hypocrisy is to be avoided then vegan friendly non-milk beverages need to refrain from calling themselves "milk".
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by lovehashbrowns on Monday November 25, 2019 @07:51PM (#21634636)
This is already a problem in the US with things like "chocolate" and "cheese products." This lawsuit isn't going to be addressing any of that. My concern would be if this lawsuit is going to have a detrimental effect on decreasing meat consumption in the US. Or maybe it'll just add another example to the list of foods that aren't what they say they are, so next time it'll be "chocolate," "cheese products," and "vegan."
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cookie_monsta on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:18PM (#21634818)
I don't know the situation in the US but in Australia I have noticed that we now have "dairy drink" instead of cheap milk, "sandwich slices" instead of cheap cheese. Nowhere on these products does it say milk or cheese because obviously it isn't. It looks like it and is packaged like it and there's no explicit warning that it isn't the real deal, but that's a marketing sleight of hand that I'm ok with I guess. Buyer beware. But false advertising? No. That's an enormous slippery slope and the consumer protections benefit us all, not just vegans.
Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by lovehashbrowns on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:25PM (#21634857)
But it's the same situation, and I'm sure BK will solve it with the exact same solution, disclaimers. So we still have "cheese products" right next to actual cheese, packaged in the same way as actual cheese, and this vegan burger is going to be advertised as vegan, but with a disclaimer. Just as some products specify that they're manufactured alongside other peanut products and may contain some peanut.

The downside here is that maybe it stops vegan products from getting more popular and becoming more readily available. That's my only concern. I'm otherwise not opposed to suing companies for false advertising, and I wish that happened more often because if it did, this problem wouldn't have come up in the first place.

Re:A Vegan Sued Burger King over Its ‘Impossible Whopper’ by cookie_monsta on Monday November 25, 2019 @08:37PM (#21634906)
Agreed. There should be a disclaimer and end of story.

Although I can see the ridiculous side to this. If I were a hardcore vegan I wouldn't be trusting BK to do the right thing. On my occasional shameful forays to BK I'm looking for a very specific combo - salt, animal protein, empty carbs and a sugar hit. If I'm looking for a healthy choice BK doesn't even cross my mind.