It's usually a driver configuration issue if you have tearing.
None of these need to be animated and even if they are not animated they can be disconcertingly janky under X. Tearing is even worse/more obvious if screens are rotated into a portrait orientation.
Then why does every popular desktop/mobile OS/app have UI animations?
Playing a movie produces moving pictures on a monitor? Great!
Tearing? Without telling them, they'll hardly ever notice it.
Users might not consciously call out screen tearing but they absolutely can tell when something runs smoothly. Just look at the reviews for iPhone vs Android devices in the early days when Android felt more like X11 with jank, frame drops and redraw glitches.
Then look how much time and money year on year Google spent fighting that jank. Money well spent.
And the irony is, that early iOS used animations to hide latencies when changing application state. These animations were the cause, why it was considered so smooth.
Then having a tear-free desktop is going to be something you strive for.
I upgraded every part of my setup which I needed to, just in order to be able to run Wayland (via sway), and I have to say I absolutely think it's worth it.
I think it’s amusing that that opinion is so common given how bad X is. Mac OS X was developed in the nineties and has a jank-free hardware-accelerated compositor. Windows vista also had one, as well as every windows version after that.
I am certain that I’m not the only end user who notices the difference between smooth animations on those other OSs and what you see on X.
Wayland may be incomplete but it’s obvious that it solves some of these issues.