I understand why Snell wrote this article now--to tap some pageviews off the public interest in the 16" Macbook Pro announcement--but his fundamental thesis is wrong.
Apple has always balanced size vs functionality; it has not been a continuous track toward thinner and thinner under Jobs or Ive. Where they have made major missteps, it is because they guessed wrong about technology, not some Ive-driven quest for thinness at all costs.
The worst thing about the latest iphones(10, pro) is that they got heavier. I find it so bad that I skipped the upgrade(s) because of that.
(I'm not suggesting anyone updates, just curious how much weight caused this to be the primary decision point.)
Yet, they completely squander the opportunity to go with square PCB design and single cell battery. They would've done so if they were really concerned about that.
Split cell design doesn't give net boost to battery capacity with such small cells and only 2 of them. It's more of a compromise to packaging and cost, than about battery capacity. Foxconn bills them per-part and per operation for assembly, so they put as much as they can on single PCB, and order as much of pre-assembled modules as possible. This may well cost them more than a two-pieces PCB, but tell that to MBA types.
The Apple battery cases have always been a case of function over form. They have always been butt ugly, but more functional than third party cases.