News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by AcerbicZero on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @04:20PM (#21578436)
Network virtualization seems to have been extremely slow to be adopted. Even companies pushing "cloud first" seem to be running their physical networks like its 2003.
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by geofft on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @08:41PM (#21580374)
When your Kubernetes falls over, you can ssh to it and run commands like it's 2003 (or 1993). When your network falls over, not so much. We deprecated our network virtualization at $work and have been way happier for it.

Also, the end-to-end principle argues for putting complicated logic in the endpoints and making the network boring. See also, TCP is implemented at the endpoints and just requires network infrastructure to drop packets sometimes. You could imagine a congestion control protocol implemented on each router on the Internet, but it would be much more fragile and also much harder to deploy changes to.

Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by tptacek on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @11:33PM (#21581118)
Part of the reason for the end-to-end argument is to enable more clever (or, at least, more purpose-designed) functionality to ride on top of the dumb network. So e2e would suggest (to my reading at least) that you keep the "real" IP layer dumb and flexible, and do the fun stuff in overlays, which is what this is.
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by pvg on Wednesday November 20, 2019 @04:17AM (#21582338)
It's also mostly about two rather than N endpoints. The later, follow-on Blumenthal & Clark paper is a kind of long list of end-to-end-principle analysis 'it's complicated's.
Re:Nebula, Slack's Open Source Global Overlay Network by fulafel on Wednesday November 20, 2019 @01:13PM (#21586625)
There has been a big "software defined networking" bandwagon but it's been confined to inside data centers.