Re:How to (not) have sex in the 600s
by paulddraper on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @02:46PM
(#21577403)
To be fair, "even though this feels really good, it is [bad]" is frequently correct. Similar in correctness to "if it tastes really good, it is bad for your health"
Even from a scientific point of view, the ability to refrain from sloth, gluttony, and lust helped give rise to homo sapien's dominance above his fellow animals.
Re:How to (not) have sex in the 600s
by hn_throwaway_99 on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @03:00PM
(#21577586)
But that misses the point. Sex in a monogamous, loving marriage certainly is good for your health. But the bishop wasn't saying "Sex in the context of a monogamous, loving marriage is wonderful and leads to one of God's highest commandments, procreation." He was saying "sex is gross, a sin, so get it over with as quickly as possible even with your spouse."
So I think implying that the Church was only interested in maintaining the nuclear family misses the mark.
Re:How to (not) have sex in the 600s
by paulddraper on Tuesday November 19, 2019 @03:53PM
(#21578159)
> the bishop wasn't saying
I didn't read the original source material or notice a link, so I don't know what Theodore didn't say, just the 140 character excerpts.
> implying that the Church was only interested
I intended no such implication. "conscious or otherwise"
Perhaps you consider that one of the "extras" by this bishop, but I see it as central, for all of the other rules are basically along the lines of "even though this feels really good, it is the way of the devil".
So yes, while many of the rules do promote reproduction in nuclear families, I think more importantly by turning one of the most basic human desires, sex, into an inherently shameful act, where your only method of salvation is through the Church, that it is a fairly brilliant attempt at furthering the levers of control of the Church.