Its becoming clearer that the world is shifting towards coordinated world-wide tax rates, similar to how central banks are coordinated. Modern trade is complex and almost always multinational. Clear and easy tax rates will actually allow anyone to enjoy fair taxation, instead of the current unequal situation in which megacorps can use complex schemes to drastically reduce their rates, while normal businesses can't.
Incidentally , the most unequal territory in terms of shifted profits is Europe. An EU-wide corporate tax of 20-25% would be good for business
Also, using a US business to collect in-game payments no longer lets you avoid VAT compliance if you sell to EU customers. Which is why you can now use an EU VAT compliance "one-stop shop" which does it all for you.
If you mean do the EU countries have reasonable thresholds, then that's a country-by-country issue. As it should be...
In that respect, tax is no different than each platform or website having its own API and TOS. We don't make every Facebook and Google use the same API and TOS, so why should we force countries to use the same tax thresholds?
When did they make this change? Because initially when the system started the mini-one-stop-shop did not allow you to use VAT thresholds. That was one of the big points of contention about it.
It sounds like you're talking about a one-stop shop where you get to decide when you want to use it based on your own thresholds. You can certainly do that, it depends on the specific one-stop shop as to how much is manual vs done for you. Some are more technologically advanced than others.
I'm talking about the VAT thresholds at which you're required to collect VAT (and thus would consider using a VAT one-stop-shop). At the time the one-stop shops were introduced, there were no minimum thresholds.
Generally, beginning in 2019, EU members are supposed to have a EU 1000 threshold for requiring VAT compliance. But like all EU rules, this rule requires local implementation and it hasn't yet been implemented by all member states. So in some countries, you need to do at least EURO 1000 of business before needing to deal with VAT compliance...but in others, its still EURO 0.
The threshold is high enough to not impact incidental foreign sellers but low enough that it's not worth the costs of creating new sales entities to evade VAT compliance.
I'm pointing this out because when people draw the conclusion that "all politicians are corrupt" they tend to weaken the very institutions that could solve these and many other problems.
Of course there's also the fascinating tendency of the US public to empathise with corporations. That's why they can't even solve this entirely obvious dynamic within their own borders, and happily pay Amazon's taxes in an entirely zero-sum competition for HQ2.
> Britain’s financial services industry, the country’s biggest tax earner, risks being cut adrift from its main export market - the European Union - after Brexit.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-britain-eu-finance/britai...
Switzerland's haven status was shot down by the GWB administration, and Cyprus surprise taxation made a lot of shady billionaires weary of EU.
These things don’t happen in a vacuum and the non-participant’s view is highly distorted and intentionally manipulated.
Exhibit A is the IRS’ role. For most people the IRS is viewed as an adversary that retroactively attacks them and unilaterally decides how much that person will pay them. For perceptive people the IRS can preemptively approve your plan of how much you won’t pay them, and most of these multinational tax saving schemes are signed off by the IRS in advance.
This reality always escapes the populist furor that results in changing a tax rate or two, primarily because the people are not exposed to it and can only imagine some arbitrary loophole and an adversarial IRS that is limited by an interpretation of a passed law. When the reality is very different and not adversarial at all.
That power ultimately belongs to the billionaires that own the relative majority of stocks. The faceless companies are just proxies.
This is where wealth inequality comes from.
Ultimately, we have a choice: work hard to build the government that we want, or allow it to falter to the energies of the billionaire class. Or, even worse, allow the billionaire class choose the government that they want.
Under that worldview you end with strongly progressive taxation funding something like a Universal Basic Income, which allows you reduce corporations' economic power without just moving it to the government.
That said, government is definitely the appropriate place for a lot of decisions to be made.
What you say is self-contradictory. Corporations are literally a creation of the state. Libertarians do not support the State's protection of corporations and do not support corporatism.
Power, in all its forms -- economic, cultural, social, political -- is highly concentrated among impersonal giant corporations today.
For this kind of legal tax avoidance would be impossible without mutual understanding, collaboration, and coordination across national boundaries among many disparate groups of people, all serving their corporate masters in one way or another (as their employers, as their customers, as taxpaying entities, etc.).
Consider only how many people and organizations must be involved to make tax treaties and regulations around the world amenable to this kind of tax avoidance.
Whether this kind of concentration of power is good or bad for society, I'm not sure.
My best guess is no -- but I'm not certain. For there is also evidence that large-scale, concentrated business investment has been a force for good worldwide.[a]
--
[a] See, for example, Marc Benioff's book, "Trailblazer: The Power of Business as the Greatest Platform for Change" at https://www.amazon.com/Trailblazer-Business-Greatest-Platfor...