News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by georgespencer on Monday November 18, 2019 @07:28AM (#21563766)
I've had:

1. Bose QC-15

2. Bose QC-25

3. Bose QC-35

4. Bose QC-35 ii

5. Bose 700

6. Apple AirPods Pro

Far and away my choice now is AirPods Pro. They are comfortable to wear whilst sleeping on a flight (over ear can't be worn comfortably), and the noise canceling is significantly better than the Bose.

The only downside for me is battery life (I get about 5hrs out of them).

Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by orev on Monday November 18, 2019 @09:27AM (#21564515)
For sleeping on a flight, you can switch to a $0.25 pair of earplugs. Today’s technology consumer seems to forget about the simple and obvious things.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by rhinoceraptor on Monday November 18, 2019 @03:05PM (#21567639)
Earplugs are great, but they can't play the podcast I use to fall asleep (Sleep With Me).

Without it, it's hard to quiet the racing thoughts in my mind that keep me up for hours.

Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by gmiller123456 on Thursday November 21, 2019 @02:00PM (#21597987)
Earplugs don't really block sound, they just muffle it. They're mostly made to make very loud sounds not damage your hearing. But you can still easily hear people talking and other noises, even if they're quieter than without them.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by georgespencer on Monday November 18, 2019 @04:41PM (#21568406)
A lot of people like to fall asleep to music or a podcast (including me!).
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by insickness on Monday November 18, 2019 @08:58AM (#21564318)
I have both the Bose QC-35 ii and the Airpod pros. The Bose have better noise reduction. Plus, if you really want total quiet, you can wear earplugs underneath the Bose.

The Airpod Pros are good but the physical noise isolation isn't that great. The rubber tips in Etymotics are far superior. Even my Jabras had better physical noise isolation than the Airpod Pros.

My friend has the Sony WH1000XM3, so I got to play around with those. They have slightly better noise cancelation than the Bose. However, the Bose are more comfortable to me because they rest around your ear instead of on your ear like the Sony's.

Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by LocalMan on Monday November 18, 2019 @11:14AM (#21565420)
I'm pretty sure those M3's are around-the-ear. Unless you have gigantic ears. I'm wearing the M1 right now and it's around-the-ear.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by insickness on Monday November 18, 2019 @02:41PM (#21567441)
They Sony is around the ear but the speaker still rests against the ear. On the Bose, the only part that touches my head is the cushion.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by makruiten on Monday November 18, 2019 @03:46PM (#21567979)
The noise cancelling is very good, but not better according to rtings.com [1].

I think that the comfort while sleeping/resting is a valid concern. I really like how comfortable the QC-35 II are, but you can’t rest your head against them. The Bose 700 headphones appear to have better mics as the main advantage over the QC-35 II.

Personally I like the sound of the Bose headphones better than Sony’s, but judging from online comments I think that most people prefer the more bass heavy Sony sound.

My advice to OP for over ear headphones would be the QC-35 II. Physical buttons, decent sound quality (although you can get better sound quality if you don’t need noise cancelling) and very comfortable. I can’t speak for the Apple AirPod Pros, as I’ve never used them.

[1] https://www.rtings.com/headphones/tools/compare/bose-quietco...

Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by georgespencer on Monday November 18, 2019 @04:52PM (#21568503)
I actually can't see rtings saying that noise cancelling is better on there -- just noise isolation. But I'm probs missing it and also think it's highly subjective -- in-ear just feels more effective to me.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by eden_hazard on Monday November 18, 2019 @08:50AM (#21564259)
Wow, you are right! I'm reading the reviews of the Airpod Pro vs QC 35 for noise cancelling and the pros look like they are able to match the tried and tested Bose and Sony headphones. I think I will wait for gen 2 before I splurge. 5 hours of battery life isn't even enough to get through the work day.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by medbrane on Monday November 18, 2019 @11:50AM (#21565815)
After 5 hours you can put then in the case for charging:

> 5 minutes in the case provides around 1 hour of listening.

Together with the case Apple quotes 24h.

Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by zelienople on Monday November 18, 2019 @10:46AM (#21565180)
Don't buy things with a repairability score of zero.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by lm2s on Monday November 18, 2019 @01:19PM (#21566676)
Not only repairability, but the battery can't be changed not even by paying Apple to do it. And with such a tiny battery, cycles will accumulate rapidly, degrading its performance.

I understand that a lot of folks don't care about that, but to me it's a bit mind boggling the electronic waste being generated with these kind of earphones.

Also, this isn't exclusive to Apple.

Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by cascom on Monday November 18, 2019 @09:02AM (#21564343)
Do you have to be playing something with the AirPods pro, or can you just turn on the noise cancelling function (e.g. sleeping on a plane)
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by nickthegreek on Monday November 18, 2019 @09:15AM (#21564432)
They can cancel noise without anything playing.
Re:Ask HN: Best Noise Canceling Headphones by phyalow on Monday November 18, 2019 @07:31AM (#21563786)
Same here, tried or owned nearly all on your list + others. Airpods pro are magical.