News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Saturday January 29, 2011 @01:50PM (#2156037)
Taxing the rich (even more than they are already which IMHO is a lot) is just punishing success and rewarding failure.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by izendejas on Saturday January 29, 2011 @07:04PM (#2156847)
Of all those that agree with such argument, I'd like to get an answer to these questions:

1) have you traveled to a developing|third-world country? 2) if you haven't, you should. if you have... 2a) what price tag do you put on first-class infrastructure that makes your business run smoothly, not to mention make it safer to deliver? 2b) what price tag do you pay to ensure that you have a well-nourished and healthy work-force that is more intelligent, stronger and efficient? 2c) what price tag do you pay to ensure that everyone has access to a world-class education (again, compare to a third-world country, I know ours sucks compared to others') that is again, more knowledgeable, more creative, etc and will one day help you boost margins, compete globally, etc?

And I could go on...

You see.. safety goes hand in hand with: 1) economic stability 2) health (ever wonder why some people risk their own lives to cross borders? their families are starving/dying!) 3) education 4) and much more than just a strong military, uncorrupt/just police/court system

And those things cost money. If you'd rather grow wealthy in another country, I dare you to try! And if you're already wealthy and you think taxing you more is unfair, I dare you to move to countries like Mexico where many business owners now have to pay "taxes" to drug gangs or else, they just don't go to prison, they get killed!

I'm not arguing that our tax system doesn't need reform or that current rates are fair, I'm arguing that if you want to be wealthy one day or are already, it's in your best interest to contribute more. Consider it an investment where you can. Yes, surely there is waste, but focus on that, don't whine about the fact that you're getting punished because YOU ARE NOT... you were rewarded with all these great opportunities and public goods and services you seem to take for granted, that's all (again, see my first question above).

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benmccann on Saturday January 29, 2011 @09:27PM (#2157151)
You're arguing that education, infrastructure, and a non-corrupt court system is responsible for this country's success, which may well be true. However, only a tiny amount of spending is on those things. 85% of spending is on social security, the military, and medicaid. We could cut all of those things dramatically without a corresponding decrease in the country's economic output.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by three14 on Sunday January 30, 2011 @07:09AM (#2157906)
Preventing old people and sick people from dying in the streets is just one of those costs you're going to have to pay for, like it or not. Raise Social Security to 68, maybe. Cut it off, though, and you'll find that the country will still pay, one way or another. (Maybe force kids to support their parents - it could be a completely different solution from Social Security, but that money is going to get spent.)
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by izendejas on Monday January 31, 2011 @02:24AM (#2160633)
I'm glad you bring up that idea out at the end (by now, few will read it, but that's okay). It pains me to learn that some people in this great country (for cultural reasons?) don't do this. It's a "crazy" idea, but one that works very well in other countries. Latin Americans, Indians, and others will attest to that. I wouldn't call for forcing families to take care of their elderly, but I'd find ways to motivate that because it's simply sad that we have to take care of others' parents.

And yes, the whole problem with our health care system isn't so much that we're paying (we have to no matter what, either by premium increases or footing the bill for emergency patients). The problem is that it sucks at preventing major health problems that later cost more if undetected and not treated early.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by khafra on Monday January 31, 2011 @09:56AM (#2161596)
The problem with that system is that it incentivizes overpopulation. If your retirement plan is your children, you have a lot of children.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by izendejas on Tuesday February 01, 2011 @09:00PM (#2168527)
Perhaps. But grandchildren, brothers, sisters, etc can all help, not just children.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by datapimp on Sunday January 30, 2011 @02:56AM (#2157654)
Really? I think the ecosystem created around large government contracts is pretty significant, and that it would cease to exist without government spending, which naturally would decrease economic output in that a lot of people would be unemployed, a lot of businesses whose customers are the employees of these businesses would shut down, etc etc. It is most obvious in the case of military spending related to manufacturing, but just think about it for medicaid as well.

I think you're off your rocker with this one.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by izendejas on Sunday January 30, 2011 @06:11AM (#2157839)
No, I'm including the whole package including health care (see 2b) and military spending which I know just about everyone agrees we need to have some of (see 4), and so on.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by sixtofour on Saturday January 29, 2011 @07:46PM (#2156942)
2d) a workforce that is relatively well off enough that there's little incentive for them to steal your assets or time.

Edit: 2e) comfortable enough not to wage revolution against your ass.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Sunday January 30, 2011 @02:57AM (#2157657)
> " I'm arguing that if you want to be wealthy one day or are already, it's in your best interest to contribute more."

The rich already contribute more. Where's the line? 90% tax rate? 99.9999%?

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by izendejas on Sunday January 30, 2011 @05:38AM (#2157801)
I should be clear: more than people who are in the middle/lower classes in terms of the effective tax rate (not just marginal), and given our current situation, it may have to be even more than it is today (along with cuts) or the alternative is that the system could collapse.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Sunday January 30, 2011 @09:36AM (#2158108)
Maybe the 'system' collapsing is a good thing. It's a modern invention.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by vannevar on Sunday January 30, 2011 @11:50AM (#2158408)
Where's the line?

That my friend is the central question of domestic politics. Right now 'the line' is at historically low levels, and we're facing massive budget deficits. And fresh from a US election year where everyone agreed the deficit is the most important issue facing us, the first thing the government did was vote to extend those historically low rates.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by scythe on Saturday January 29, 2011 @04:33PM (#2156452)
The rich are taxed a lot? They're taxed at a lower level than any other time in the past twenty years -- that's not a lot. The richest people around today -- Gates, Jobs, Ellison, Buffett -- made a significant portion of their money during a time (the '90s) when the top marginal rate was higher than today's. Clearly, that didn't stop them!
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by pistoriusp on Saturday January 29, 2011 @05:29PM (#2156613)
Exactly, this kind of thinking freaks me out.

They want to take property from people who have earned it precisely for having earned it! It's theft, it's looting, and it's slavery!

You cannot take one man's property and give it to another based on need.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by Pinckney on Saturday January 29, 2011 @06:47PM (#2156819)
By living and working in a country such is America, you are accepting a social contract: if you do well, you will be taxed, if you do poorly, you will at least receive some services to support you. This strikes me as an entirely reasonable contract, though there are others that are different. In Abu Dubai, you can do well, and keep all your money, or do poorly and wind up in debtor's prison.

To complain that you're taxed too heavily after you have already become wealthy and secure strikes me as akin to looking back on your healthy, illness free life and complain that you should get a refund on your insurance payments, since they didn't do anything for you.

The above is not to argue that one system is superior to the other, but rather that you're in one, and very probably complaining about it now that you know you're well prepared enough that it's clear that you'll probably never be destitute.

In a perfect world, we might ask everyone how much risk they want. Unfortunately, so much is determined in your youth. You (I assume) grew up in a family that raised you well, and left you with reasonable earning potential. If we just asked everyone at 18, we would wind up with an upper class that would rarely suffer financial failures, and would accept risk, and those who know they won't get rich on their own, and accept no risk, and so for the most part, this system would be unfundable. As a compromise, and as many of us feel quite strongly that it's simply not acceptable to have people destroyed when they suffer financial ruin, we have some basic social services.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by mike_esspe on Sunday January 30, 2011 @09:08AM (#2158067)
As long as you can't leave this contract (with your property), it's not a voluntary contract. With the same logic you can justify slavery.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by khafra on Monday January 31, 2011 @09:58AM (#2161604)
If you get your property by exploiting the contract, then get to leave the contract instead of paying your side of it, it's not worth much as a contract.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Sunday January 30, 2011 @09:54AM (#2158151)
The problem for me arises when you start taxing 'the rich' more heavily than others.

And having a tax rate above 50% for anyone is morally indefensible IMHO.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benohear on Sunday January 30, 2011 @04:32AM (#2157755)
I have a theory:

In the good ole days, taxation consisted of the lord owning the land (the means of production) and taxing the peasents.

This is pretty much what happens when you're employed - someone else owns the means of production, and you are paid less than the value that you create (hopefully for the company, anyway). For me this is a form of taxation - The main difference is that insead of being paid the gross amount and being hit for x%, you get the net amount.

On a macro level, it's similar. The country IS the ultimate means of production, and you pay a tax to use it.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by jacques_chester on Sunday January 30, 2011 @08:04PM (#2159789)
You've reinvented the core thesis of Marxism: that the difference between what the worker earns and the capitalist sells is a theft of value. The problem is that it assumes that labour is the true source of value -- this has turned out to be a troublesome assumption. In practice value is subjective.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benohear on Monday January 31, 2011 @08:31AM (#2161349)
That's not quite what I meant. I was referring to the value your employment adds to the company, not the sales value of the final product.

And yes, that's extremely difficult to evaluate, but it seems to me that on average everyone has to be paid less than their contribution, otherwise there would be no profit or funds to pay salaries for people not directly contributing to production.

Nor was I passing judgement, by the way, so I don't go along with the "theft" thing. I do however think it is a form of taxation.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by jacques_chester on Monday January 31, 2011 @05:46PM (#2163514)
Sorry if I gave the impression that you were passing judgement. I just find it interesting that smart people come up with the same ideas again and again.

"Taxation" is not the best way to put it. It is a market exchange. In exchange for a fixed portion of your value output (which will be variable), the company guarantees a certain payment upon a fixed input (usually hours-per-week).

Thus the company is essentially taking on the risk that you will produce enough value to cover the cost and leave some space for profit.

If you or the company disagree about the values involved, the employment relationship ends.

The concept that a capitalist's profits come from the risk he or she takes to earn them is the other half of what is missing from the Marxist theory of economics -- following almost inevitably from the adoption of the labour theory of value.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by sixtofour on Saturday January 29, 2011 @07:45PM (#2156938)
Then why does Warren Buffet famously say that his [effective?] rate is lower than his secretary's?
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benohear on Saturday January 29, 2011 @01:54PM (#2156049)
It depends a wee bit on how you got rich. Taxing the financial industries close to 100% wouldn't strike me as punishing success.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Saturday January 29, 2011 @02:05PM (#2156073)
Why? Are you saying it's easy to make money if you're just providing financial services? :/
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benohear on Saturday January 29, 2011 @02:08PM (#2156078)
No, I'm saying the industry as a whole failed.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by jimminy on Saturday January 29, 2011 @02:38PM (#2156150)
The whole industry didn't fall. It was about a dozen extremely large insitutions, and the extremely small institutions that depended on that group.

There were institutions in the middle who weren't involved in the mess. See BB&T, as an example, they were actually forced by the government to accept a bailout, as to make it seem like the whole industry failed.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by javert on Saturday January 29, 2011 @05:42PM (#2156652)
Agreed. The whole industry bailout was a huge punishment to BB&T, which otherwise probably would have profited tremendously from taking over much of the business of the failed banks.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benohear on Sunday January 30, 2011 @04:12AM (#2157737)
By the way, as I understand it, there's a difference between "the whole industry" and "the industry as a whole"
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Saturday January 29, 2011 @02:21PM (#2156107)
I don't think that's true at all.

Several banks did fantastically, announced record profits etc. The industry as a whole didn't fail, some particular institutions did.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by benohear on Saturday January 29, 2011 @02:48PM (#2156173)
The way the bailout was sold to us was that if these failing institutions were allowed to collapse, they would have brought down the rest with them. I actually hold that to be true and for me that equates to an overall failure of the industry.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by axod on Saturday January 29, 2011 @02:59PM (#2156208)
I know it's how it was sold, but I disagree with it. We should have let the bad companies fail and the good ones succeed.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by davorak on Saturday January 29, 2011 @03:12PM (#2156245)
With out the community and the government those opportunities to get rich would not exist.

If the perfect world the rational rich person might realize this and protect and improve the system that allow people like himself to be possible.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by javert on Saturday January 29, 2011 @05:40PM (#2156644)
The government only helps the rich to the degree that it provides courts, police, and military. Beyond that, it's looting them.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by dhugiaskmak on Saturday January 29, 2011 @06:32PM (#2156779)
So true. Everyone knows that every businessman has completely bootstrapped from scratch all of the roads, utilities, schools, hospitals, scientific research, and a thousand other things that they took advantage of to make their fortunes. No one else made any contributions to their success and that's why it's only fair that we should be required to hand over a significant portion of our incomes to them.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by javert on Sunday January 30, 2011 @02:40AM (#2157635)
That's right, let's justify stealing from businessmen based on the fact that they grew up in a society that was already stealing from businessmen.

None of the things you mentioned need to (or should) be funded by loot.

In fact, utilities and hospitals didn't used to be in the U.S., and only partially are now. The US education system is a stagnant cesspool that still uses a model developed in the Middle Ages. And the government expropriates more wealth created from non-government funded scientific research, than it generates from funding scientific research.

Look, nobody has a duty to serve as a sacrificial animal to anybody else. You do not have the right to demand that businessmen sacrifice for you or for society.

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by vannevar on Sunday January 30, 2011 @12:00PM (#2158435)
I agree. I think the first thing we need to do to bring about your utopia is to bring back personal liability and eliminate the corporate entity (which after all is a construction of government). Then if a businessman's activities injured someone, we could be sure that a court could strip them of their personal assets in order to compensate the victims of their negligence.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by javert on Sunday January 30, 2011 @04:13PM (#2159199)
That's sort of unrelated to my point, but it's an interesting question.

A corporation's rights and responsibilities just derive from the rights and responsibilities of those who own it. I think this is the premise behind "corporate personhood" and I think it works correctly almost all the time. (I'd be interested to see examples where that's not the case.) For example, a corporation can exercise free speech, because the people who own it can exercise free speech; so if you deny the corporation from exercising its free speech, you are denying those who own it their right to exercise free speech.

I'd think that in the case of personal injury caused by a corporation, if the corporation's full assets are not enough to compensate the victims, then the owners could then be held responsible to cover the difference. (Whether that is actually legally the way it works now, I don't know.)

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by vannevar on Sunday January 30, 2011 @09:20PM (#2159995)
A corporation's rights and responsibilities just derive from the rights and responsibilities of those who own it.

It doesn't work that way, unfortunately; if it did there would be no reason to have 'corporate personhood' since the owners could simply assert their own right of free speech. A corporation can assert its own right of free speech completely apart from its officers or owners. In theory a corporation with no living officers and only the estate of a deceased person as a shareholder could nonetheless legally assert a right of free speech based on computer generated messages. Not that it's ever been tested. Angry mobs, on the other hand, are not generally viewed as persons, nor are parades, crowded beaches, or book clubs.

I'd think that in the case of personal injury caused by a corporation, if the corporation's full assets are not enough to compensate the victims, then the owners could then be held responsible to cover the difference.

It doesn't work that way, either. In the case of big liability, a corporation's owners frequently try to shuffle as much of the corporation's assets as possible off the books and then declare bankruptcy in the face of the liability. The personal assets of the shareholders are generally untouchable. Turns out that when you tell people their only responsibility is to create shareholder value, they take it pretty seriously (particularly if they're the shareholders in question).

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by nitrogen on Sunday January 30, 2011 @04:05AM (#2157726)
Without the entrepreneurs and executives organizing companies and the engineers designing products, there'd be nothing for everyone else to work on but subsistence farming. Should providing something for the rest of us to do go unrewarded?
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by vannevar on Sunday January 30, 2011 @11:44AM (#2158382)
But those contributions don't go unrewarded. They are compensated highly, otherwise we wouldn't be having this discussion. The problem here is that higher tax rates are being mistaken as punishment when they're just a reflection of reality. The rich leverage society's institutions more to acquire their wealth, consequently they pay a greater share of their income for them.
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by nickpp on Saturday January 29, 2011 @06:30PM (#2156770)
But those opportunities are available to everybody. Why should the reach be the ones paying more for them?
Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by bermanoid on Saturday January 29, 2011 @09:58PM (#2157219)
A flat tax rate, by charging a higher dollar amount to the rich person than the poor person, is still punishing success and rewarding failure, because the rich person pays a hell of a lot more for the same services than the poor person.

I propose that we charge everyone an equal dollar amount, that's surely the only way to be fair - after all, if you go out to dinner with five people and rack up a $200 bill, everyone pays $40, that's "fair".

Right?

Re:Scott Adams: How to Tax the Rich by vlisivka on Sunday January 30, 2011 @11:51AM (#2158411)
No. It depends on how much someone eat.

Imagine company, which has 10000 shareholders. You own 10% of company. Company needs some financial helps, e.g. $250M. How much you should pay? $100? $250M/10000?